Cedar Key Schools and Nearby Homes for Sale and Rent

Please click on one of the below schools to see properties that are marked as being nearby those schools in the MLS.






Newest Cedar Key Homes by School

  • 1170 WHIDDON AVE, CEDAR KEY, FL - MLS# GC539563

    Cedar Key High School-LV - GC539563 - 1170 WHIDDON AVE, CEDAR KEY, FL 32625
    29 Days on yellowkey

    $250,000 | Single Family Home | 2 beds | 2.0 baths

    This Cedar Key property presents a rare opportunity for buyers looking to rebuild or reimagine a coastal home in one of Florida’s most unique waterfront communities. Previously impacted by storm damage, the property is now positioned for potential repair or reconstruction under current FEMA and local guidelines. Based on guidance from local officials, rebuilding may be possible depending on the scope of work and overall project cost relative to the structure’s pre-storm value. This creates a unique opportunity for buyers to design and execute a project that fits within those parameters—whether restoring the existing footprint or creating a thoughtfully updated coastal retreat. The value calculation is based on the structure only (excluding land), giving buyers a clear framework to explore renovation or rebuilding options. Due to FEMA regulations and the 50% rule, buyers are encouraged to work with the City of Cedar Key, contractors, and design professionals to fully understand allowable improvements, elevation requirements, and permitting options. If you’ve been looking for a project with flexibility, upside, and the ability to create something truly your own, this is an opportunity worth exploring.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: HOME ENV REALTY

  • 1170 WHIDDON AVE, CEDAR KEY, FL - MLS# GC539563

    Cedar Key High School-LV - GC539563 - 1170 WHIDDON AVE, CEDAR KEY, FL 32625
    29 Days on yellowkey

    $250,000 | Single Family Home | 2 beds | 2.0 baths

    This Cedar Key property presents a rare opportunity for buyers looking to rebuild or reimagine a coastal home in one of Florida’s most unique waterfront communities. Previously impacted by storm damage, the property is now positioned for potential repair or reconstruction under current FEMA and local guidelines. Based on guidance from local officials, rebuilding may be possible depending on the scope of work and overall project cost relative to the structure’s pre-storm value. This creates a unique opportunity for buyers to design and execute a project that fits within those parameters—whether restoring the existing footprint or creating a thoughtfully updated coastal retreat. The value calculation is based on the structure only (excluding land), giving buyers a clear framework to explore renovation or rebuilding options. Due to FEMA regulations and the 50% rule, buyers are encouraged to work with the City of Cedar Key, contractors, and design professionals to fully understand allowable improvements, elevation requirements, and permitting options. If you’ve been looking for a project with flexibility, upside, and the ability to create something truly your own, this is an opportunity worth exploring.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: HOME ENV REALTY

  • 00 CLAYTON RD, CEDAR KEY, FL - MLS# OM716937

    Cedar Key High School-LV - OM716937 - 00 CLAYTON RD, CEDAR KEY, FL 32625
    124 Days on yellowkey

    $839,000 Reduced | Single Family Home | 2 beds | 1.0 baths | 6 gar

    Retire in Seclusion | Off-Grid Legacy Estate in Tiger Island Sportsman’s Club 60 Acres of Privacy, Sustainability, and Authentic Old Florida Living Discover a rare opportunity to retire in true seclusion with this extraordinary 60-acre legacy estate, tucked deep within the exclusive Tiger Island Sportsman’s Club—a private 7,200-acre hunting and conservation community surrounded by the protected wilderness of the Lower Suwannee National Wildlife Refuge. This is more than a home—it’s a lifestyle defined by privacy, independence, and a deep connection to nature. With only a handful of full-time residents and large acreage parcels, life here is quiet and unhurried, where days can pass without seeing another vehicle and the night skies remain untouched by city lights. Thoughtfully developed over six years, this turnkey retreat is offered fully furnished and ready for immediate enjoyment. At the heart of the property is “The Treehouse,” a beautifully crafted post-and-beam cabin built in 2021. Offering approximately 1,000 square feet, the home features two bedrooms and one bath, with a third bedroom and bath already dried-in for future expansion. A versatile loft provides additional space for guests, storage, or recreation, while vaulted ceilings and 22 oversized triple-pane windows bring in natural light and frame the surrounding landscape. Designed as a true forever home, the cabin blends rustic character with long-lasting durability, including a 75-year silicone-coated metal roof. A screened 10-by-20-foot porch overlooks active wildlife corridors, creating the perfect place to relax and take in the peaceful surroundings. Below, a spacious 1,200-square-foot covered area offers endless possibilities for equipment storage, a workshop, entertaining space, or even an outdoor kitchen. The land itself is equally impressive, featuring established feed plots, a network of trails, and easy vehicle access throughout. Nearly 25 miles of private roads wind through the community, ideal for ATV riding and exploring. The property is rich with natural beauty, including a mature forest with more than 30 species of trees, one of the largest and deepest ponds in the community, and scenic creek frontage behind the cabin. The location also provides natural protection and has remained unaffected by recent storm flooding, offering additional peace of mind. Whether you envision a private retirement retreat, a family legacy property, or a seasonal escape for hunting and outdoor recreation, this one-of-a-kind estate offers the space, privacy, and freedom to live life on your terms. Unplug, unwind, and experience the quiet beauty of Old Florida—untouched, unspoiled, and truly rare.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS CORNERSTONE RE

  • 16791 SANDRA ST, CEDAR KEY, FL - MLS# GC534959

    Cedar Key High School-LV - GC534959 - 16791 SANDRA ST, CEDAR KEY, FL 32625
    208 Days on yellowkey

    $525,000 | Single Family Home | 2 beds | 2.0 baths | 1 gar

    WHY DREAM OF A VACATION ON THE COAST OF FLORIDA WHEN YOU CAN OWN A PIECE OF PARADISE If you’ve been considering a home in the Sunshine State of Florida this is the perfect time to turn that dream into reality. This exceptional property was custom constructed in 1988 by skilled local builders and craftsmen. The home showcases solid woodwork throughout and dramatic vaulted heart-pine beams that anchor the main living area. It offers two generously sized bedrooms and two baths designed for comfort and functionality. Expansive covered porches wrap around the entire home, providing access to three 12-foot sliding glass doors that flood the interior with natural light and coastal breezes. You’ll feel like you are in a glamorous, well-appointed treehouse that says…Relax and enjoy life! Bubbling jacuzzi time is a bonus. On the ground level, you’ll find a versatile garage/game room, an attached workshop, and two covered carports. The fenced backyard offers a safe haven for pets. This thoughtfully designed and solidly constructed residence stands out even among the most impressive homes in Cedar Key. Adding to its appeal, the property includes three platted and buildable 1/3-acre lots. One lot holds the home, while the front lot extends to within approximately 50 feet of the Gulf. Those final feet are owned by the City of Cedar Key and designated as conservation land—ensuring protected water views for generations to come. While the property could be subdivided into separate parcels, it is currently offered as one expansive homesite, presenting endless possibilities. This extraordinary property boasts a main living elevation of 13 feet above sea level, supported by substantial concrete pillars rising an additional 9 feet. The result? Superior storm protection—rare for the island—and breathtaking sunrise and sunset views that never disappoint. Cedar Key itself is a cluster of small islands along the Gulf Coast, north of Tampa and south of Tallahassee. Once a historic fishing village, it is now home to roughly 800 residents—a blend of longtime locals, clam and oyster farmers, and small business owners. The island is beloved for its natural beauty, water activities, outstanding local restaurants, and welcoming community. Your friends can fly in for lunch utilizing the community’s 2303 foot asphalt runway, take time to kayak with the dolphins, reserve a seat for a sunset boat tour, explore the many islands. There is a reason UF set up a biological research station in the fascinating town. Life here moves at a deliberately relaxed, Old Florida pace. Come experience this rare, one-of-a-kind property—and bring your dreams home.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: UNITED COUNTRY SMITH & ASSOCIATES - NEWBERRY