Eagle Lake Homes for Sale and Rent by Zip Code

Please Click on a city to see properties that are organized by Zip Code for the selected city.






Newest Eagle Lake Homes by Zip Code

  • EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# P4919019

    33839 - EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    1 Day on yellowkey

    $174,900 | Single Family Home | 2 beds | 1.0 baths

    FOR THE UNIQUE. A SPACIOUS PROPERTY WITH A ACCESSORY STORAGE BUILDING, EXTRA RV PARKING, AND ADULT TOY PARKING. ROOF 2018, CENTRAL A/C 2021. FRESHLY RENOVATED HOME. CENTRAL LOCATION TO MAIN ROAD. A MUST-SEE.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: TINA MARIE LLC (407-448-5388)
    Listing Agent: Tina Marie (863-332-2612)

  • 83 N 2ND STREET, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# T3350399

    33839 - T3350399 - 83 N 2ND STREET, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    3 Days on yellowkey

    $179,000 | Single Family Home | 3 beds | 1.0 baths

    This home is ready for a WHOLE make-over. Sporting 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, this home is ACHING for your love, time, and commitment... it has the potential to be SO MUCH MORE. The size of the yard is HUGE, and has everything you need to create your own oasis! Convenient location with nearby amenities, including schools, shopping, and restaurants.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: SOUTHERN COMPASS REALTY (813-418-6797)
    Listing Agent: Joseph Mcguire (813-419-3154)

  • 665 E CENTRAL AVENUE UNIT 1, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# L4927448

    33839 - L4927448 - 665 E CENTRAL AVENUE UNIT 1, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    3 Days on yellowkey

    $259,900 | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.5 baths

    Lots of space inside & out. 2300 +/- square feet of living space sitting on a double lot with Alley space. This 4 bedroom 2 1/2 bath home offers so many options. It has a huge kitchen with granite counters & stainless appliances. Tons of counter space and room to add an island if you want or a table with chairs for extra eating space. A formal living room when you enter a formal dining room off the kitchen, a family room to watch movies or just hang out. The office is central to everything & a bonus room (that could be a bedroom) is a great plus. An inside laundry is a plus as well. The back porch has a kitchen/bar-b-que area that is perfect for entertaining and fun gatherings. This property offers lots of space for lots of activities. Hurry! It won't last long!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (863-687-2233)
    Listing Agent: Fran Williams (863-738-2102)

  • 832 ORLEANS DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# O5997324

    33839 - O5997324 - 832 ORLEANS DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    4 Days on yellowkey

    $285,000 | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    Looking for new construction, but don’t want to wait for the long build times? Welcome home to one of Highland Homes Parker models, designed for a modern lifestyle. The Parker Floor Plan, with it’s Craftsman-style exterior features boast a charming covered front porch. Walk through the front doors to an open concept living space with volume ceilings comprised of a spacious gathering room, dining cafe and kitchen with an oversized counter-height island and ample pantry space. The kitchen features White shaker-style cabinets with premium, low-maintenance laminate countertops finished with a crescent edge finish, stainless steel range, over-the-range microwave, quiet-operation dishwasher, pull-down faucet, Energy-efficient LED recessed lighting, walk-in pantry with tight-mesh shelving, upgraded wood plank tile flooring and a convenient drop zone at garage entry. Relax in your owner's suite with a spacious walk-in closet and private en-suite bath including extra counter space, dual vanities and a decorative tiled shower and a jacuzzi garden tub. The secondary bedrooms share a convenient hall bath and linen closet. This home has many stylish and low-maintenance features: Mohawk stain-resistant carpet in the bedrooms, LED recessed lighting in the kitchen and gathering room, ceiling fans in the bedrooms, prewired cable in the gathering room and bedrooms. There is a built-in pest control system that is accessible from the exterior. All landscaping was designed to be drought resistant with a programmable irrigation system.  With energy-efficient R-30 insulation, foam-injected block insulation, double-pane Low-E windows, and a programmable thermostat, this home was designed to save you on utilities. Enjoy relaxing outdoors on your covered lanai with access from the cafe and from the owner's suite! Located in Normandy Heights newest phase with Low HOA dues and No CDD Fee, this community has easy access to Lakeland, Tampa and Orlando due to the proximity to the Polk Parkway Toll road. The city of Winter Haven offers an array of activities and is home to Legoland, boating on the Chain of Lakes (there are 50 lakes in Winter Haven), enjoying a movie, playing a round of golf or strolling historic downtown with shops, dining and live music!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY AT THE LAKES (407-566-1800)
    Listing Agent: Julie Arnold (352-242-8073)

  • 729 E LAKE AVENUE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# P4918924

    33839 - P4918924 - 729 E LAKE AVENUE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    10 Days on yellowkey

    $298,000 | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 3.0 baths

    Don't miss out on this beauty. Situated on an oversized, beautifully landscaped lot. New Roof 2021. Freshly painted. Features 4 bedrooms, Bonus room could be 5th bedroom, 3 baths, inside laundry. All appliances included, also washer and dryer. Very long driveway, perfect parking for guests. There is an exhaust fan in the attic that is temperature controlled. Great location. Hurry, won't last long.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: SUN N LAKES REALTY, LLC (863-326-6147)
    Listing Agent: Beverly Giardinieri (386-235-9695)

  • 655 E EAST BAY AVENUE PLAIN, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# O5991856

    33839 - O5991856 - 655 E EAST BAY AVENUE PLAIN, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    37 Days on yellowkey

    $239,000 Reduced | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    Tenant Occupied! Please do not disturb without prior notice! No inspection, As is! Excellent deal with 4BR/2BA located in Eagle Lake near a park. There is a two-car garage. All sizes are approximate.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: NB ELITE REALTY (844-444-6237)
    Listing Agent: Melika Assadi (407-455-2119)

  • 391 S 3RD STREET, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# P4918544

    33839 - P4918544 - 391 S 3RD STREET, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    46 Days on yellowkey

    $319,000 Reduced | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 3.0 baths

    REDUCED! Desirably located on a corner lot, this home has a unique floor plan with several rooms that may be used as additional bedrooms, a den, office space, etc. With a pool and an extra lot, this would make a great home to host guests. Come see it today!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: TOWN & COUNTRY REAL ESTATE (863-293-1141)
    Listing Agent: Emily Muscarella (863-978-7180)

  • 156 LAGO COVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# L4926650

    33839 - L4926650 - 156 LAGO COVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    53 Days on yellowkey

    $700,000 | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 3.0 baths

    If you have been looking high and low for a rare piece of architectural history, check out this BEAUTIFUL HISTORIC LAKEFRONT home built in 1917. Take a step back into a more simple time seeing what this vintage estate has to offer. This stunning property sits on a sprawling 1.54 acres of land with a long grassy driveway leading you straight into unobstructed lakefront views of Eagle Lake, a 647 acre, sandy bottom lake with incredible sunset views and amazing fishing. The property is very secluded and surrounded by orange groves. Imagine taking off in your seaplane for a quick, scenic trip over the beautiful Polk County and landing right in your backyard only a few steps away from your own front door. Recent updates to the home include a new lifetime metal roof installed in 2016, updated electrical, and both AC units have been serviced regularly. There was also a separation installed dividing the two floors creating a private and spacious upstairs apartment with its own separate entrance. The upstairs apartment showcases beautiful French doors that open up into an incredibly spacious living room with a wood burning fireplace, one of 4 working fireplaces in the home. Additionally, the upstairs apartment has its own private kitchen, bathroom, and extra rooms for living or storage space. This extra space could also be used for additional income by renting out to companies like Airbnb or VRBO. In the separate downstairs living area, the specialty and original regional pine dark hardwood floors give a warm feel that flows through the entire room, accompanied by a stone fireplace, accentuating the historic story this home has to offer. The back screened in porch follows the entire length of the house, perfect for watching sunrises or sunsets over Eagle Lake, sitting in an oak tree shaded swing, or just enjoying the fresh breeze on a quiet summer afternoon. A detached 3 car garage sits separately from the house where you can store your favorite collector cars and all your water-play toys. The entire site has irrigation throughout to keep your landscaping looking great year-round. Take advantage of this rare opportunity to own your very own 100 year-old historic lakefront home and request your private showing TODAY!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY SMART (863-577-1234)
    Listing Agent: Casandra Vann (863-221-4982)

  • 87 LAKE MCLEOD DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# T3343097

    33839 - T3343097 - 87 LAKE MCLEOD DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    53 Days on yellowkey

    $375,000 | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Imagine yourself living in this 4 bedroom/2 bedroom spacious spotless home on over 1/3 of an acre in the Lake McLeod community - where boating activities are welcome! With incredible lake views from your extended front porch, sit outside after dinner to enjoy the magnificent sunsets! Walking through the front door brings you into the welcoming living room and dining room with views of the soaring great room and kitchen/eating area. The kitchen features pull-out shelving, cabinets galore, a separate delightful eating area with access to the backyard, 2 sinks - one in the island and the other facing the great room so there is always room for additional assistance in the kitchen! Having 2 pantries is a huge plus - enjoy stocking up on staples and sale items! The split floor plan provides for 3 bedrooms and the laundry room on one side complete with a full bathroom having a dual sink; the opposite side spotlights the owners' suite. It includes 2 walk-in closets and a spa tub and separate shower. Don't forget the additional features of this home - a front and rear irrigation system, A/C system with UV light for air purification, water conditioning unit, incredible back porch, amazing fenced back yard for get-togethers, cookouts and fun, and more. Bring your boat, jet ski, bicycles and live the life. All you need to do is unpack and enjoy!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: TOMLIN, ST CYR & ASSOCIATES LLC (813-636-0700)
    Listing Agent: Janice Katz (813-335-5548)

  • 273 Street GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# G5049164

    33839 - G5049164 - 273 Street GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    62 Days on yellowkey

    $310,000 Reduced | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    Beautiful DR HORTON home is now on the market MOVE IN READY HOME! The home has a spacious open floor area, having the family room, kitchen, and dining area create a very nice flow to the house. This home has a walk-in closet in the master, with the other rooms separated from the master to create more privacy. Sellers are very Motivated. Come see it and let's celebrate the New Year in your new home.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: GATAP REALTY (352-978-5459)
    Listing Agent: Marisol Ortega (352-978-5459)

  • 277 ST. GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# L4923515

    33839 - L4923515 - 277 ST. GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    217 Days on yellowkey

    $275,000 Increased | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    Nearly new home situated in a nice quiet neighborhood. Nestled on a cozy lot with a private fenced backyard. Has everything a buyer could want and need.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY SMART (863-577-1234)
    Listing Agent: Gate Arty (863-680-9988)

  • 1121 SECOND DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# L4923237

    33839 - L4923237 - 1121 SECOND DRIVE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    228 Days on yellowkey

    $334,440 Increased | Single Family Home | 4 beds | 2.0 baths

    New construction home with 2005 square feet on one-story including 4 bedrooms , 2 baths, and an open living area. Enjoy an open kitchen with white shaker-style cabinets, Samsung stainless steel appliances, a walk-in pantry, and a spacious island, fully open to the dining café and gathering room. The living area, laundry room, and baths include luxury wood vinyl plank flooring, with stain-resistant carpet in the bedrooms. Your owner's suite is complete with a walk-in wardrobe and a private en-suite bath with dual vanities, a tiled shower, and a closeted toilet. Plus, enjoy a covered lanai, 2-car garage, custom-fit window blinds, architectural shingles, energy-efficient insulation and windows, and a full builder warranty. SOCIAL DISTANCING AND/OR MASKS REQUIRED IN ALL MODELS ***Please note - Virtual Tour showcases the home layout; colors and design options in actual home for sale may differ. Furnishings and décor do not convey!

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: CAMBRIDGE REALTY OF CENTRAL FL (863-797-4999)
    Listing Agent: George Lindsey, Iii (863-797-4999)

  • 458 Street GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL - MLS# S5050580

    33839 - S5050580 - 458 Street GEORGES CIRCLE, EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839
    253 Days on yellowkey

    $285,000 Increased | Single Family Home | 3 beds | 2.0 baths

    GREAT FOR INVESTORS! Welcome to your new dream home in Winter Haven, FL! Home is close to Legoland and located in the Normandy Heights Community. This home is called the Aria Model built by DR Horton. It's a one-story home that features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms with an open floor plan. The kitchen has a perfect space for a breakfast table. The dining room is open to the family room and gives spectacular views of the back yard and also has a breakfast bar area. Low HOA. This home is located in a beautiful well-kept and quiet community! -- MOTIVATED SELLER - BRING ALL OFFERS.

    Contact Yellowkey Agent

    Listing is courtesy of: LA ROSA REALTY INTERNACIONAL LLC (407-429-7398)
    Listing Agent: Magly Boscan (352-681-0336)



Data is updated at least once a week by Sunday nights. Some properties that appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have been sold and may no longer be available. The data relating to real estate for sale/lease on this web site come in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the multiple listing service (MLS) in which this real estate firm (Broker) participates. Data can be retrieved from any one of the following MLS’s: Greater Fort Lauderdale REALTORS®, South Broward Board of REALTORS®, MIAMI MLS, JTHS MLS, Space Coast Association of REALTORS®, My Florida Regional MLS, Florida Gulf Coast MLS, "©2022 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved." The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the MLS’s database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker’s logo or name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. The Florida Association of Realtors® and its cooperating MLSs do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing.