Sugar Mill Plantation Homes for Sale in Flagler Beach - 3 homes

Remarks: Welcome to 32 Audubon Lane, an exceptional estate home located in the exclusive estate section of Sugar Mill Plantation in Flagler Beach. This is a rare opportunity to own a residence that offers both impressive scale and timeless presence, along with the privacy and sophistication expected in one of the area’s most distinguished communities. Spanning more than 5,000 square feet, this thoughtfully designed three-story home is ideal for both comfortable everyday living and elevated entertaining. The main residence features 3 spacious bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and 2 half baths, along with a versatile third-floor space that can easily serve as an additional bedroom, media room, or private retreat. Rich architectural details are showcased throughout, including extensive custom woodwork, elegant tray ceilings, and plantation shutters that bring warmth, character, and refinement to every room. A stunning staircase creates a grand focal point and sets the tone from the moment you enter. The formal dining room offers a sophisticated yet welcoming setting, complete with a charming window seat that adds both beauty and function. The chef’s kitchen is equipped with premium appliances, including a Viking dual stove with microwave and warming drawer, Sub-Zero refrigerator, and Fisher and Paykel double drawer dishwasher. It opens seamlessly to an additional living area where a cozy fireplace and well-appointed bar create the perfect backdrop for intimate evenings or larger gatherings. The primary suite is a private retreat, highlighted by its own balcony that offers a peaceful place to unwind. One of the secondary bedrooms features its own en suite bath, along with an adjoining sitting area that feels like a private lounge overlooking the surrounding neighborhood. step outside to a private courtyard designed to feel like your own personal resort. This outdoor oasis features a pool, spa, fireplace, and fully equipped summer kitchen, all thoughtfully arranged to create a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. Beyond the pool, an enchanting garden adds an extra sense of privacy and tranquility. Adding even more flexibility, the over-the-garage apartment is fully equipped with its own bedroom, bathroom, kitchen, stackable washer and dryer, living area, and ample storage. Ideal for guests, extended family, or private accommodations, this space enhances both the home’s functionality and value. With its inviting front porch, expansive layout, and carefully curated indoor and outdoor living spaces, this remarkable estate offers a rare combination of privacy, versatility, and coastal elegance in Flagler Beach.

Listing is courtesy of: SIMPLY REAL ESTATE (386-677-0870)

Listing Agent: Tammy Dunn (386-212-4296)

Remarks: Old Florida charm meets modern luxury in this stunning estate home located in the sought-after Sugar Mill Plantation community, with easy access to beautiful downtown Flagler Beach. Surrounded by lush landscaping and majestic oaks, this residence offers both timeless elegance and contemporary comfort. Step through custom double steel entry doors into a dramatic two-story foyer with travertine floors and a grand chandelier. The formal dining room boasts rich Cypress wood floors, crown molding, custom trim work, and expansive windows overlooking a private side yard. The completely remodeled gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, featuring a Sub-Zero cabinet-front refrigerator, Wolf appliances, double oven, Cambria quartz countertops, gas range, two beverage fridges, built-in coffee/espresso system, and pantry closet. A charming breakfast nook with wood ceiling details, French doors, and large windows offers picturesque views and abundant natural light. The family room showcases travertine flooring, vanishing sliders to pool with electric shades, and additional access to the covered lanai through French’s doors. A private office with Cypress wood floors, custom built-ins and bay window for your private workspace. Downstairs completed with custom grand half bath perfect for guests, and picture-perfect laundry room with cabinetry, sink, and outdoor access. Upstairs, the primary suite features vaulted ceilings, Cypress wood floors, French doors to a private tiled balcony overlooking the preserve, custom walk-in closet, and a renovated spa bath with clawfoot tub, dual quartz vanities, linen tower, and walk-in tile shower. Bedroom 2 is set up like a junior suite- a spacious guest suite with bay window, crown molding, ensuite bath with soaking tub and walk-in showers, Plus another oversized bedroom 2 with wood floors, walk-in closet, and serene views. Additional bathroom 3 upstairs with tile tub/shower. All bedrooms upstairs, grand in size and private. The outdoor living space is an entertainer’s paradise with an electric heated pool, travertine decking, outdoor shower, fenced yard, and complete privacy surrounded by mature trees. Anchored on the end of the cul-de-sac with preserve tree lines. Additional highlights include: NEW ROOF 2024, 2-car garage with Shark coating floors, Whole-house water filtration system, under stair wine storage and additional upstairs storage closet, Crestron smart home automation (audio, lighting, blinds, garage, security cameras), Landscape lighting & irrigation system, Whole-house generator plug, 90-gallon hybrid hot water heater (2024), Septic serviced June 2025. With Cypress wood floors, travertine tile, Cambria quartz countertops, and custom crown molding throughout, this home blends refined craftsmanship with modern upgrades. Sugar Mill Plantation is renowned for its tranquil streets lined with sweeping oaks, offering a true Old Florida setting, just minutes from Flagler Beach’s shops, restaurants, and sandy shoreline. Experience timeless Old Florida charm blended with modern luxury in one of Flagler Beach’s most beautiful communities—this home truly has it all.

Listing is courtesy of: VENTURE DEVELOPMENT REALTY,INC (386-366-0091)

Listing Agent: Elizabeth Kargar (386-585-2904)

Remarks: Step into a piece of Old Florida history with this stunning 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom retreat nestled within the revered Sugar Mill Plantation, a tranquil haven cherished for nearly 200 years. This exceptional home, boasting over 3,000 square feet of living space and is enveloped by majestic oak trees, creating a serene and picturesque setting. Experience the perfect blend of historic charm and modern convenience with extensive updates completed within the last seven years. Peace of mind is paramount with high-impact windows throughout including the back and sliding glass door. Kitchen and bathrooms have been updated with countertops, vanities, and cabinets. Other updates include gutters, a screened-in lanai and a patio cover, fixtures, sprinkler system control with a new irrigation pump, whole-house circuit breaker, and garage door. Never worry about power outages with a whole-house generator and a 250-gallon propane tank, and rest easy knowing a termite bond is in place. Situated on over half an acre of lush, oak-studded land, this property offers ample space for outdoor living and features a delightful garden – perfect for nature enthusiasts. The home also uses water from nearby Volusia County and is in one of the lower property tax areas of Flagler County, meaning your water and property tax rates are lower than the rest of the county. Enjoy the best of both worlds with a peaceful, historic setting and convenient access to modern amenities. Located less than 15 minutes from the beach, and with shopping and restaurants nearby, this home offers the ideal Florida lifestyle. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of Old Florida charm with all the modern comforts. Schedule your private showing today and experience the tranquil beauty of Sugar Mill Plantation.

Listing is courtesy of: REAL BROKER, LLC (855-450-0442)

Listing Agent: Brady Nelson (517-303-1414)