Displaying: For Sale
Location: Keystone Heights
Property Type(s): Single Family
Beds: 4 to 4
Do Not Show Listings
Keystone Heights - 8 properties found
7480 PARADISE DR, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$332,000351 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC530687
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1752 Built: 1967 Tax: $2,431 (2024)Community: Lawrance Developing CosSingle Family
Market Analysis: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Nearby Properties: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Taxes:$2,431
Elementary School: None
High School: None
Tax Year: 2024
Middle School: None
Remarks: Enjoy lakefront living at its finest with this beautifully updated property on Paradise Lake, just minutes from downtown Keystone Heights. The 3-bedroom, 1-bath main home offers 1,080 sq ft of comfortable space, featuring new carpet, an open-concept kitchen and living room, a screened porch, large lakeside deck, and laundry/utility room. Recent upgrades include new interior paint (2025), a remodeled interior (2020), new appliances (2019), a new septic system (2019), and a new well pump (2018). Outside, enjoy 110 feet of serene water frontage on over half an acre with a floating dock perfect for swimming or fishing. A detached 2-car garage includes a fully equipped 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment above (672 sq ft), ideal for guests, rental income, or a mother-in-law suite. Conveniently located with easy commutes to Starke, Orange Park, and Palatka, this versatile property is perfect as a full-time residence, vacation retreat, or investment opportunity.
Listing is courtesy of: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY (352-475-1269)
Listing Agent: Trey Fields, Iii (352-222-9251)
628 BETHEL DR, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$479,9004 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4691852
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 5/1/2026)
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2362 Built: 1960 Tax: $3,315 (2025)Community: Keystone Christian ColonySingle Family
Taxes:$3,315
Tax Year: 2025
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Lakefront luxury on sought-after Lake Brooklyn! This immaculately remodeled 4BR/2BA home has been thoughtfully updated from top to bottom with no expense spared. Practically everything about this home is brand new within the last few years. Enjoy a widened driveway, oversized carport, and boat/RV storage. Spacious living room features a wood-burning fireplace, separate access to the massive back deck, and stunning lake views through expansive picture windows. The kitchen is a dream with 5-burner gas stove, stainless appliances, and beautiful granite counters. The spa-like primary suite includes a huge tiled walk-in shower and a 2-person Jacuzzi tub with lighting kit. The finished 4th bedroom/office/in-law suite offers a Murphy bed and mini-split. There's also a detached finished shed with electric, internet, and window AC. Fully fenced backyard with majestic oaks and Spanish moss. Covered gazebo at the original water's edge for relaxing and enjoying lake life. Welcome home!
Listing is courtesy of: EPIQUE REALTY, INC. (888-893-3537)
Listing Agent: Walter Key (757-635-3645)
6240 PAYNE RD, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$549,00011 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC539740
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2952 Built: 1996 Tax: $3,249 (2025)Community: Lawrence Developing CompanysSingle Family
Taxes:$3,249
Remarks: Beautifully updated 4 bedroom, 3 bath brick home situated on 2.44 acres at the end of a quiet dead-end road, offering privacy and space while still providing modern comfort. With just under 3,000 square feet of heated and cooled living space, this home has been thoughtfully refreshed with new flooring, fresh paint, and updated light fixtures throughout. As you enter the home, you're welcomed by an additional flex space that would make the perfect office or could easily be converted into a 5th bedroom. The kitchen features new countertops, a new sink, double ovens, a new dishwasher, and a walk-in pantry, making it both functional and inviting. The spacious primary suite includes its own private bathroom with a double vanity, walk-in shower, and garden tub. Bedrooms two and three share a Jack and Jill bathroom with a double vanity and tub/shower combination, while the fourth bedroom is located on the opposite side of the home with its own bathroom that also serves as a guest bath. Additional upgrades include a new roof installed in February 2026 and a new water softener added in March 2026, along with two water heaters for added convenience. Step outside to enjoy your own private oasis featuring an inground pool and outdoor shower, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. This property offers the ideal combination of updated living, functional layout, and peaceful surroundings.
Listing is courtesy of: CB ISAAC REALTY (352-475-2199)
Listing Agent: Ronald Blake (352-235-1644)
6286 1ST AVE, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$360,00010 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC539794
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1988 Built: 1994Monthly Fee: $3 Tax: $3,469 (2025)Community: Postmasters Retirement VillageSingle Family
Taxes:$3,469
Remarks: Welcome to Keystone Heights living at its best! This beautifully remodeled turn-key 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 1,988 sq ft of comfort, charm, and flexibility. Step outside to your private retreat with a sparkling pool, fenced backyard, fruit trees, crepe myrtles, storage shed, and chicken coop. Bring your boat or jet skis--Lake Hutchinson, a spring-fed lake with sandy beach access through the HOA for just $30 annually, is just a stone's throw away. Updates include kitchen cabinetry, light fixtures, wood-look tile flooring, updated windows, plus a 4-year-old roof and HVAC and updated water heater. Centrally located for an easy commute to Gainesville, Jacksonville, and Middleburg. The house holds more character and beauty than a lens could capture. Schedule your showing today.
Listing is courtesy of: CW REALTY (904-964-3948)
Listing Agent: Brenda Thornton (904-364-8266)
5949 SE COUNTY ROAD 21B, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$405,000403 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC529415
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/23/2026)
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1951 Built: 2025 Tax: $276 (2024)Community: Indian Lake Ranch Phase 1Single Family
Taxes:$276
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Under Construction. Exceptional New Construction on a beautifully sized half-acre lot. This thoughtfully designed home blends modern comfort with the charm of country living, surrounded by mature trees and open skies for a private, serene setting. Inside, the living room and primary bedroom feature elegant tray ceilings that add an elevated feel. The primary bathroom is finished with luxury wide tile that extends seamlessly up the shower walls, creating a cohesive and upscale design. Granite countertops complement the kitchen and baths, while durable vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home for both style and easy maintenance. With all new systems, finishes, and construction, this home offers the peace of mind that comes with new construction.
5955 SE COUNTY ROAD 21B, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$410,000298 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC532356
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1981 Built: 2025 Tax: $276 (2024)Community: Indian Lake Ranch Phase 1Single Family
Remarks: Under Construction. Be the First to Call This Home! This beautiful new construction home sits in the heart of Melrose, FL. This home offers the perfect opportunity to secure your place in a brand-new residence before it's complete. Featuring 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms. With 1,981 h/c sq ft. Enjoy modern craftsmanship, open-concept layout, and thoughtful design throughout. With construction well underway, now's your chance to customize select finishes and truly make it your own (depending on the build timeline.) Set on a spacious half-acre lot in a peaceful setting, you'll love the blend of country living with easy access to local shops, lakes, and dining. Don't miss this rare chance to own new in the charming Melrose community and in Florida's best lake region!
6306 BAKER RD, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$389,000171 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC535460
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/13/2026)
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1906 Built: 1960 Tax: $1,027 (2024)Community: Sehema BeachSingle Family
Taxes:$1,027
Remarks: Welcome to your dream retreat on beautiful Lake Geneva! This spacious four-bedroom, two-bathroom home sits on 1.13 acres of serene, lakefront property, offering the perfect blend of comfort, style, and outdoor living. Located on Lake Geneva, one of Keystone Heights’ most desirable areas, this property provides peaceful privacy with stunning water views. Inside, you’ll find a recently remodeled kitchen and bathroom, showcasing modern finishes, updated fixtures, and a refreshed contemporary design. The open-concept living spaces are bright and inviting, ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing while taking in the tranquil lake scenery. Step outside to enjoy direct access to Lake Geneva—perfect for boating, fishing, paddleboarding, or unwinding at sunset. The expansive lot offers ample room for outdoor activities, a storage shed, and a workshop for all of the outdoor enthusiast! Move-in ready and made for lakefront living, this Lake Geneva gem is a rare opportunity. Come experience the beauty and space this property has to offer!
Listing Agent: Calee Hinson (386-406-0119)
1353 CHATAUQUA WAY, KEYSTONE HEIGHTS, FL 32656
$439,00070 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: GC537812
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 3248 Built: 1955Community: Lakeview HlndsSingle Family
Taxes:
Tax Year:
Remarks: This home has it all, location & plenty of space. 4 bedroom 3 bath home boast over 3200 SF of living space with views of lake geneva. Completely remodeled in 2023. Large open kitchen, large living space, great size bedrooms, huge great room/game room and decks off each of the living areas great for entertaining family & friends. All 3 bathrooms have been updated to provide that modern fresh feeling. This home offers lots of character and a great home for entertaining. Grab a cup of coffee or a good book and sit out on 1 of 3 porches with views of lake geneva or watch the gorgeous sunsets. This roomy lot is great for pets and plenty of room for your toys. Roof (2023) AC (2023) HW Heater (2023) Septic pumped (2026). Don't miss your opportunity to own this great home only 1/2 mile to down town keystone, 20 min to gainesville. Give us a call for your private tour.
Listing is courtesy of: UNITED COUNTRY SMITH & ASSOCIATES - NEWBERRY (352-463-7770)
Listing Agent: Niki Thomas-Schnyder (352-494-4298)
Please select an email frequency other than None since you have chosen for us to email you with changes that match your search.