Magnolia Plantation Homes for Sale in Lake Mary - 5 homes

Remarks: Extensively renovated and impeccably maintained, this exceptional one-story residence offers the rare opportunity to enjoy truly turnkey living. Set on a beautiful homesite with water and conservation views, the home combines timeless style with the confidence that comes from knowing the major improvements have already been completed. From the roof and HVAC system to the kitchen, primary bath, and outdoor living spaces, every update has been carefully selected to enhance both comfort and long-term value. A substantial investment in recent improvements ensures years of worry-free ownership. Highlights include a stunning kitchen renovation with new appliances and whole house wood flooring (2020), a luxurious primary bath remodel (2024), new barrel tile roof (2024), fresh exterior paint (2024), professional landscaping and tree replacement (2024), and a resurfaced PebbleTec pool (2018). Major mechanical upgrades include a Trane XV18 multi-zone HVAC system with Reme Halo whole-home air purification (2023), hybrid water heater (2018), A.O. Smith whole-house water softener (2022), and a Pentair variable-speed pool pump (2025). Upon entering, this open-concept one-level home immediately showcases striking views of the water and conservation beyond. The spacious family room and well-appointed kitchen serve as the heart of the home, offering an inviting gathering space for everyday living and entertaining alike. Expansive sliding glass doors open seamlessly to the covered lanai and sparkling pool, creating the perfect indoor-outdoor Florida lifestyle. Owners will appreciate the dedicated home office, formal dining room, and thoughtfully renovated floor plan that provides both privacy and comfort for family members and guests. Outdoor living is equally impressive, featuring a sparkling pool and spa enhanced with elegant travertine coping, lush landscaping, landscape lighting, and breathtaking views of the water and conservation area beyond. Additional features include: EV charging station in the garage Zodiac Caretaker in-floor pool cleaning system Invisible fence Crown molding and impressive trim work throughout New trees and professional landscaping Located within Magnolia Plantation, one of Lake Mary’s premier guard-gated communities, and zoned for highly regarded Seminole County schools, residents enjoy an exceptional lifestyle with amenities including a waterfront picnic area, playground, tennis courts, and open recreational fields, all within a beautifully maintained neighborhood setting. This is a rare opportunity to own a truly turnkey home where virtually every major component has already been updated, allowing the next owner to simply move in and enjoy the exceptional views, privacy, and lifestyle that Magnolia Plantation has to offer.

Listing is courtesy of: CHARLES RUTENBERG REALTY ORLANDO (407-622-2122)

Listing Agent: Kathy Stoner (407-312-9672)

Remarks: Experience luxury resort-style living in the heart of Lake Mary. Situated in the most desirable community of Heathrow, this impressive residence offers the perfect combination of space, comfort, and entertainment. Featuring 6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, this expansive home includes flexible living spaces designed to accommodate today’s lifestyle. One of the bedrooms has been transformed into a fully equipped private fitness room, complete with a full weight set, treadmill, and additional workout equipment — creating the ultimate in-home gym experience without ever leaving the house. Inside, you’ll find spacious living and entertaining areas filled with natural light and an inviting layout ideal for both everyday living and hosting guests. Step outside into your own private tropical retreat featuring: Resort-style grotto pool Exciting waterslide Outdoor fire pit Expansive patio and lounge areas Beautifully landscaped backyard designed for entertaining Additional highlights include: Large primary suite with spa-inspired bathroom Multiple flex spaces for office, media, or recreation Excellent indoor/outdoor flow Mature landscaping and exceptional curb appeal Privately Gated and 24 hour security monitored community Located minutes from top-rated Seminole County schools, premier shopping, dining, entertainment, and major highways, this home offers both luxury and convenience in one of Central Florida’s most sought-after locations. This is more than a home — it’s a private lifestyle retreat designed for entertaining, wellness, and unforgettable memories.

Listing is courtesy of: DALTON WADE INC (888-668-8283)

Listing Agent: Rick Castro, Jr (407-717-0177)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. From the moment you enter, you’re drawn to sweeping views of the resort-style pool and peaceful, tree-lined backdrop. Nearly every rear-facing window and door was thoughtfully positioned to capture these lush, green views—filling the home with natural light while creating a sense of privacy and retreat. The layout is both functional and inviting, featuring a three-way split floor plan. A secondary bedroom offers its own ensuite bath, while two additional bedrooms share a Jack and Jill. A versatile fifth bedroom—currently dedicated as an office—sits near an oversized powder bath and the owner’s suite. The elegant owner’s suite includes a sitting area, dual walk-in closets, a spa-inspired bath, and private access to the lanai and pool. A separate bonus room with its own outdoor access adds flexibility for a game room, guest retreat, or studio. At the heart of the home, the gourmet kitchen flows into the family room where Two full walls of sliding glass doors open completely and tuck away, seamlessly blending indoor elegance with Florida’s outdoor lifestyle. Outside, the setting feels peaceful and expansive. A screened lanai, solar-heated pool, summer kitchen, and firepit are surrounded by mature trees, creating the perfect space for both quiet moments and unforgettable gatherings. Located within Magnolia Plantation, a 24-hour guard-gated community with parks, playgrounds, tennis courts, and top-rated Seminole County schools. Low HOA of $183 per month includes neighborhood amenities. A true dream home offering space, comfort, and a private retreat—just minutes from everything.

Listing is courtesy of: CHARLES RUTENBERG REALTY ORLANDO (407-622-2122)

Listing Agent: Kara Grebler (321-696-9943)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Arthur Rutenberg-designed custom residence nestled on an extraordinarily private homesite in guard-gated Magnolia Plantation. No neighbors on 2 sides make for a tranquil setting at this exceptional one-level 4 bedroom, 3 bath property. Showcasing an expansive outdoor living experience, highlighted by a 664-square-foot wraparound lanai complete with a built-in summer kitchen, entertaining friends and family is a breeze. Seamless indoor-outdoor living is achieved with two walls of sliding glass doors that fully retract at a 90-degree angle, opening the home to the inviting lanai. The custom-designed pool is perfect for both lap swimming and leisure, featuring an extended length and a beach-style entry ideal for relaxing and sunbathing. The spacious owner’s suite is a private retreat, boasting a 12-foot tray ceiling, walk-in closet, surround sound wiring, and direct access to the lanai and pool. An adjoining exercise room or home office is conveniently located off the luxurious bath area. At the heart of the home lies a beautifully appointed custom kitchen, complete with rich cabinetry, a center island, granite countertops, updated stainless steel appliances, and a generous walk-in pantry. Additional highlights include a living room fireplace, elegant etched glass entry doors, and architectural details such as varied ceiling heights, columns, and arched passageways. Impeccably maintained and presented, this home reflects pride of ownership throughout with recent updates including replaced HVAC(2022/2023), water heaters(both 2023), water softener(2023), and much more. Adjacent to the natural beauty of the Wekiva Forest, Magnolia Plantation offers a serene, private setting far removed from the pace of city life. Residents enjoy a host of amenities, including tennis courts, two parks with covered pavilions, a sports field, and frequent community events that bring neighbors together. Known for its generous homesites and wide, tree-lined streets, this community provides a sense of space and tranquility while remaining conveniently close to shopping, dining, top-rated schools, and more—without the congestion of the I-4 corridor. This property may be under audio/visual surveillance.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (407-333-8088)

Listing Agent: Frank Benevento (407-492-5153)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Save Big: 1% lender credit (based on loan amount) toward closing costs or rate buy-down with seller’s preferred lender. Ask for details! Discover a beautifully upgraded single story residence in one of Lake Mary’s most desirable communities. This meticulously maintained 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom home beautifully combines comfort, functionality, and modern upgrades, all set against a backdrop with conservation and water views, ensuring privacy with no direct rear neighbors. As you cross the threshold and enter this beautifully designed home, you’ll immediately notice the stunning hard maple wood flooring that flows seamlessly throughout the common spaces and bedrooms, giving a fresh and modern feel. The formal dining room is positioned to the right and serves as an exceptional setting to host holiday dinners. A dedicated home office, thoughtfully designed with built-in shelving and ample storage solutions, makes it a perfect sanctuary for productivity or creativity. This versatile space enhances the overall functionality of the home, accommodating the needs of today’s remote work lifestyle. Venturing into the central hub of the home, the updated kitchen stands out as a true masterpiece. With its generous island perfect for meal prepping, it features a state-of-the-art cooktop and a built-in oven, ensuring that your culinary endeavors are met with ease. The layout promotes a seamless flow into the inviting family room, ideal for family gatherings. A highlight of the home is the Florida room, which boasts a cozy fireplace and dual ceiling fans, providing a comfortable space for relaxation year-round. The primary suite serves as a private retreat, complete with a sitting area featuring its own fireplace, direct access to the pool deck, and a spa like en-suite bath equipped with double sinks, heated towel bars, a soaking tub, and a luxurious walk-in shower. Two secondary bedrooms share a beautifully updated three piece guest bathroom, while an additional bedroom and a third updated bathroom with a walk-in shower are conveniently situated near a spacious flex room. This flex room offers travertine flooring and allows for the perfect setup for a game room or a cozy home library with oversized chairs and books for reading. Outdoor living is thoughtfully designed with an expansive screened pool deck designed for both dining and lounging, making it ideal for gatherings or relaxing afternoons. A saltwater pool provides refreshing swims in the warm sun, while the accompanying heated spa offers a soothing retreat at any time of the year. Whether you're hosting a lively summer barbecue or enjoying a quiet evening under the stars, this space is designed for year-round enjoyment and comfort. Recent updates include a gas pool heater (2 years old), a whole-house generator that is serviced annually, providing reliability during power outages, and both HVAC systems have been replaced within the last three years, plantation shutters, tray ceilings, and crown molding. Located within the Magnolia Plantation gated community with 24-hour guard security, residents have access to tennis courts, a playground, and a park. The community is home to the world-famous Mike Bender Golf Academy and is conveniently located just a short golf cart ride away from some of the top-rated courses in Central Florida.Conveniently situated near I-4 and a quick 10-minute ride, provides access to the 417 and 429.

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (407-305-4300)

Listing Agent: Kathryn West (321-277-1999)