Displaying: For Sale
Location: Lake Mary
Property Type(s): Single Family
Living Area Square Feet: 1000 to 1499
Do Not Show Listings
Lake Mary - 7 properties found
605 WHITTINGHAM PL, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$414,900279 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6330769
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1310 Built: 1987Monthly Fee: $19 Tax: $4,284 (2024)Community: Greenwood Lakes Unit D-3ASpa: NoSingle Family
Market Analysis: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Nearby Properties: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Taxes:$4,284
Elementary School: Lake Mary Elementary
High School: Lake Mary High
Tax Year: 2024
Middle School: Greenwood Lakes Middle
Remarks: !!NEW ROOF coming May 2026!! Discover a beautifully reimagined residence in the heart of Lake Mary, where thoughtful renovations meet timeless design. 605 Whittingham Place unveils a bright, open-concept layout adorned with exquisite new finishes throughout. From the warmth of luxury vinyl plank flooring to the designer-curated kitchen and elegantly updated baths, every detail speaks to modern sophistication. Soaring vaulted ceilings elevate the great room and kitchen, while an expansive picture window frames serene views of the sparkling pool and private, fenced backyard, an ideal setting for relaxation and entertaining. Comfort and peace of mind come effortlessly with a brand new HVAC system, complemented by updated plumbing. Ideally within Lake Mary’s desired school district, this turnkey home offers access to top-rated education from elementary through high school. A rare opportunity to experience refined living in one of Central Florida’s desirable communities. This prime location places you just moments from boutique shopping, fine dining, top-tier hospitals and major highways, ensuring seamless access to downtown Orlando, world-renowned attractions, pristine beaches and multiple airports.
Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INT'L REALTY (407-333-1900)
Listing Agent: Mel Bernstein (407-810-4726)
814 BRIGHTVIEW DR, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$399,90045 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6392310
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 3/23/2026)
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1467 Built: 1996Monthly Fee: $23 Tax: $2,977 (2024)Community: Chase Groves Unit 9Single Family
Taxes:$2,977
Elementary School: Bentley Elementary
High School: Seminole High
Middle School: Millennium Middle
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Location, Location, Location! Tucked away in one of Lake Mary's most charming neighborhoods, this fully updated Modern Traditional Ranch home is a short stroll from the heart of Downtown Lake Mary; where boutique shopping, award-winning restaurants, Central Park, yoga studios, the Saturday Farmers Market, and the vibrant WineART Wednesday events make this city one of Central Florida's most beloved communities. Inside, the open-concept kitchen anchors the home with quartz countertops, custom cabinets, and a real brick backsplash extending as a dramatic accent wall into the hallway. Smooth high ceilings, recessed lighting, and luxury vinyl flooring flow seamlessly throughout. The spa-inspired primary ensuite stuns with marble flooring and a rain shower, while the second bathroom carries that same elevated standard throughout. A dedicated laundry room just off the kitchen delivers effortless everyday convenience. Outside, a sprawling private back patio featuring a large gazebo and smart exterior lighting sets the perfect stage for entertaining from morning coffee to evening gatherings under the Florida sunsets. Top-rated Seminole County schools, I-4, the 417, and SunRail are all just minutes away. Notable improvements 2024-2020: Bathrooms fully remodeled, freshly painted, luxury vinyl flooring installed, salt based water softener installed. 2021: Backyard patio extended, custom wall unit added in dining/reading area, and laundry room extended with utility sink. 2020:Kitchen fully remodeled, new roof installed, exterior paint, and new garage door installed.
Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (888-883-8509)
Listing Agent: Sebastian Sanchez (321-262-5901)
445 AMETHYST WAY, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$429,50032 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6395654
1 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/27/2026)
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1412 Built: 1986Monthly Fee: $30 Tax: $4,510 (2024)Community: Lakewood At The Crossings Unit 2Spa: NoSingle Family
Taxes:$4,510
Remarks: Welcome home to your gracious Lake Mary bungalow, offering a rare opportunity to enjoy waterfront living on sparkling Eternity Lake within minutes of one of the top small cities in the USA. This completely renovated pool home faces north northwest, providing gorgeous sunrise and sunset lake views from your screened lanai and primary suite. Luxury vinyl solid surface flooring continues throughout the home. Smart systems allow complete armchair control of the thermostat/new AC (2025), pool lighting, irrigation, water heater, master bath fan , Ring doorbell and the garage thermostat. The garage is insulated with temperature regulation provided by a single-zone ductless mini split system. The entry foyer presents a stunning expanse of vaulted, beamed ceiling, premium ceiling fan and stone fireplace surround extending upward to the vault. Beyond the great room is the screened pool and lake. On a chilly Florida evening, the wood burning fireplace provides ambiance and warmth. The charming dining room and adjacent kitchen are freshly renovated featuring shaker cabinetry with wine storage, quartz countertop, Turkish marble backsplash, stainless farm sink with restaurant-style faucet and all appliances new in 2022. A convenient updated powder room completes first floor living. The sweeping second floor staircase leads to two bedrooms and two renovated bathrooms featuring the continuation of luxury vinyl flooring and consistent shaker cabinetry. The primary suite overlooking the lake features a stunning ensuite shower also fitted with the Turkish marble tile, new plumbing fixtures and a full length lighted mirror. This home was renovated for owner occupancy, not for resale. The quality of materials and workmanship create an extraordinary value proposition when considered with the prime location situated near the crossroads of I4, State Roads 429 & 417, providing freeway access to theme parks, beaches, sports venues and airports in Central Florida and beyond. Seminole County and Lake Mary offer school districts coveted by many who research prior to a relocation. This home is near a middle school, high school and the Seminole bike trail. This home will be offered for sale for a limited time. Please schedule your private tour.
Listing is courtesy of: COPPEROOSTER (407-484-4477)
Listing Agent: Candice Southwick (407-484-4477)
170 W CRYSTAL LAKE AVE, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$325,95048 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6387076
REDUCED by $54,000 (14.2%) on 04/24/2026
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1408 Built: 1965 Tax: $3,393 (2024)Community: Crystal Lake Winter HomesSingle Family
Taxes:$3,393
Elementary School: None
High School: None
Middle School: None
Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Located just moments from downtown Lake Mary, this single-story home offers an exceptional opportunity in a highly desirable area. Featuring three bedrooms and two bathrooms, the property provides a spacious layout with over 1,400 square feet of living space. Enjoy the convenience of being close to local restaurants, boutique shops, and the popular Saturday farmer’s market. Situated on a fenced lot with driveway parking, this home is ideal for buyers looking to renovate, invest, or create a personalized space in a prime location close to major roadways and everyday amenities.
Listing is courtesy of: MAINSTAY BROKERAGE LLC (800-583-2914)
Listing Agent: Rochele Minerd (678-263-2640)
642 WHITTINGHAM PL, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$385,00026 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: G5110707
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1432 Built: 1987 Tax: $1,552 (2025)Community: Greenwood Lakes Unit D-3ASingle Family
Taxes:$1,552
Tax Year: 2025
Remarks: Welcome to your dream home in the heart of Lake Mary! This charming two-bedroom, two-bath gem has been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated, making it truly move-in ready. Enjoy peace of mind with a NEW ROOF (2024). Additional major upgrades include HVAC (2018), NEW WATER HEATER (2025), REPLUMBED WITH PVC (2014), and NEW WINDOWS & DOORS (2015)—ensuring comfort and efficiency for years to come. Step inside to a bright, spacious living area with vaulted ceilings and abundant natural light. The stunning Florida room (built 2015) offers the perfect space to relax year-round, adding that extra touch of Florida charm. The home features a desirable split floor plan, providing privacy between the primary suite and guest bedroom. The kitchen is a chef’s delight with stainless steel appliances (2021), ample counter space, a cozy breakfast nook, and even a garbage disposal for added convenience. The primary bedroom serves as your private retreat with an en-suite bath, while the second bedroom is perfect for guests or a home office. Step outside to your fully fenced backyard, a blank canvas ready for entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the sunshine. Gutters in both the front and back add to the home’s functionality and upkeep. And here’s the best part: No HOA! Enjoy the freedom to truly make this home your own without restrictions. You’re just minutes from Topgolf Lake Mary, Sam’s Club, top-rated schools, and a variety of medical specialists. Nearby Colonial TownPark offers fantastic shopping and dining, including local favorite FishBones. This home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and lifestyle. Don’t miss your chance to make it yours—schedule your private showing today!
Listing Agent: Sunshine Callahan (407-353-9931)
901 BERESFORD WAY, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$370,00067 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6385809
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/14/2026)
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 3 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1389 Built: 1992Monthly Fee: $93 Tax: $4,269 (2024)Community: Colony CoveSingle Family
Taxes:$4,269
Remarks: Some homes just feel different the moment you walk through the door—901 Beresford Way is one of them. Perfectly positioned on a peaceful corner lot, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence offers a bright, open, and modern aesthetic that is truly move-in ready. From the crisp, neutral exterior to the manicured lawn and mature shade trees, every inch of this property says "welcome home". Step inside and the home rises to meet that first impression with a sprawling open floor plan that flows seamlessly from the sun-drenched foyer into a massive living room (17'0" x 20'9"). The kitchen is a true centerpiece, featuring a generous footprint with ample counter space and cabinetry, designed for both casual morning coffee and the nights when everyone ends up staying late. The split floor plan ensures maximum privacy, placing the spacious primary suite away with its own massive walk-in closet and a spa-like en-suite bath. On the opposite side of the home, two additional guest bedrooms share a second full bath, offering real-life functionality for a home office, gym, or guest retreat. Added convenience is found in the spacious 3-car garage, providing ample room for vehicles and storage. But the real magic happens out back. Sliding glass doors lead you to a private, oversized brick-paver patio that runs the length of the home—the perfect setting for year-round outdoor living. The space is fully enclosed by a classic wood privacy fence, creating a secluded sanctuary for quiet afternoons or weekend BBQs. The location is the final mic drop. You are in the heart of the Colony Cove community, a hidden gem in Lake Mary known for its tranquil, yet active lifestyle. With low HOA fees, residents enjoy incredible value and a high quality of life. The HOA takes care of essential maintenance, including the community pool and playground, and offers access to other local amenities such as fishing and sidewalks. You are also moments away from the upscale shopping and dining of Colonial TownPark, the Saturday Lake Mary Farmers Market, and the prestigious Heathrow area. For outdoor enthusiasts, the 14-mile paved Seminole Wekiva Trail is nearby, along with top-tier golf courses and city parks. With effortless access to I-4 and the 417, the world-famous theme parks, downtown Orlando, and Atlantic coast beaches are all within easy reach. ***Seller’s preferred title is BCHH - See preferred offer terms - Please allow 2 business days for a response to our offer.***
Listing is courtesy of: ELEGANT REALTY LLC (407-985-2840)
Listing Agent: Wayne Mottley (407-741-3804)
173 E FLOYD AVE, LAKE MARY, FL 32746
$290,00088 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: O6379877
2 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/13/2026)
Bed: 3 Bath: 1.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1052 Built: 1940 Tax: $3,042 (2025)Community: Crystal Lake Winter HomesSingle Family
Taxes:$3,042
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Welcome to this one of kind charm located in the heart of Downtown Lake Mary. This 3 Bedroom 1 Bathroom home exudes warmth and the Home-Sweet-Home kind of vibe. Stepping through the front door, original hardwood flooring greets you and leads you throughout this beautiful home. The modestly sized living room is the centerpiece leading you to the common areas of the home as well as down the hallway bringing you to the 3 bedrooms. Lying just beyond the living room is the kitchen area, featuring solid wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, accompanied by tile countertops, providing great space for you to cook and prep your everyday meals. Making your way through you will find yet another fantastic entertainment space in the family room, perfect for your typical friendly gatherings or just a comfy space for you to relax. The laundry room rests adjacent to the family room, as well as providing access to your vast backyard space ready to host your weekend BBQ's. The location of this peach of a home cannot be overstated. Located within close proximity to Downtown Lake Mary, local restaurants and establishments, as well as being just down the road from the SunRail Station you can be in Downtown Winter Park and/or Downtown Orlando in no time at all providing absolute convenience. This is an incredible opportunity to own this beautiful home. See the potential this home offers and make it yours!
Listing is courtesy of: KELLY PRICE & COMPANY LLC (407-645-4321)
Listing Agent: Nicholas Giovanetti (321-239-7622)
Please select an email frequency other than None since you have chosen for us to email you with changes that match your search.