Lake Mary Single Family Homes For Rent - 18 homes

Remarks: Dreams Do Come True! Drive through the gates that say prestige. Pool/Spa and landscaping maintenance Included! Live where luxury meets nature in the prestigious guard-gated community of Magnolia Plantation in Lake Mary — a city consistently recognized as one of the safest in America. Situated on a sprawling half-acre corner lot, this stunning single-story estate offers nearly 3,000 square feet of elegant living space featuring 4 bedrooms, a private office/bonus room, and 3 full bathrooms. Built in 2003, the home makes an unforgettable first impression with its circular driveway, soaring ceilings, expansive open floor plan, and exceptional privacy surrounding the pool and outdoor living areas. Experience resort-style living while enjoying the beauty of Florida's natural surroundings. Wake up to sightings of deer, wild turkeys, and native wildlife that frequently roam the community, with the occasional and fascinating black bear sighting adding to the area's unique charm. Inside, you'll find plantation shutters, tile and luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, and spacious living areas designed for both entertaining and everyday comfort. The chef-inspired kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, a center island, breakfast peninsula, abundant cabinetry, and seamless flow into the formal living room, family room, and dining spaces — perfect for gatherings both large and small. The luxurious owner's retreat offers a private escape complete with dual vanities, a relaxing garden tub, separate walk-in shower, and oversized walk-in closets. Three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family members or guests. Step outside to your screened lanai overlooking a sparkling private pool — your own outdoor oasis for year-round relaxation and entertaining. The oversized driveway and 3-car garage provide ample parking and storage space for residents and visitors alike. Included with rent: • Weekly pool maintenance • Professional lawn and landscaping service This is more than a rental — it's a lifestyle defined by luxury, privacy, security, and natural beauty in one of Central Florida's most sought-after communities. Opportunities to lease homes of this caliber in Magnolia Plantation are rare. Welcome home. At today's interest rates, purchasing this home would require approximately $335,000 down just to achieve a monthly payment similar to the current rent of $4,250/month. With only 20% down, ownership costs would exceed $5,300/month. Luxury, convenience, pool service, lawn care, and flexibility make this exceptional lease opportunity one of the best values in Magnolia Plantation.

Listing is courtesy of: INVESTOR'S REAL ESTATE LLC (407-688-4355)

Listing Agent: Freddie Crespo (407-687-0634)

Remarks: Welcome home to this well-maintained single-family residence in a gated Lake Mary community offering fantastic amenities, including a community pool, splash pad, and playground. The home's spacious layout allows for a smooth transition between the living, dining, and kitchen areas, creating a welcoming environment that's ideal for everyday living. Recent improvements include a new HVAC system, dishwasher, stove, and microwave, giving tenants added peace of mind. The kitchen offers abundant cabinet storage and generous countertop space, making meal preparation and entertaining easy. Just beyond the main living area, an enclosed sunroom creates the perfect space to relax while enjoying views of the large, fully fenced backyard. For added convenience, the washer, dryer, and Ring doorbell will remain with the home. The property is ideally situated near top-rated schools, including Seminole Science Charter School (lottery-based enrollment), Galileo School for Gifted Learning, Sanford Middle School (STEM and Pre-IB magnet), and Seminole High School (IB and Academy for Health Careers). Residents also have the benefit of choosing among three elementary schools: Bentley, Crystal Lake, and Wicklow. Enjoy quick access to major roadways including I-4, US 17-92, and 417, as well as Downtown Lake Mary, the Lake Mary business corridor, SunRail, shopping, dining, parks, Neighborhood Walmart, and everyday conveniences. Combining a prime location, desirable community features, and a spacious floor plan, this rental presents an excellent opportunity in one of Lake Mary's sought-after areas. Don't miss the opportunity to see this home in person—schedule your showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (407-305-4300)

Listing Agent: Kelsey Hobson (845-699-9770)

Remarks: For Rent – Beautiful 4 Bedroom, 4 Bath Home with Private In-Law Suite plus a dedicated large /office/den space. Beautifully furnished or unfurnished, the entire home is in the wonderful, gated community of Steeplechase in Lake Mary, FL (20-30 minutes north of Orlando). The standout feature is that 4th bedroom with ensuite bath/shower making a perfect private in-law quarter or guest retreat with its private entrance via the 3rd car garage door. Past the office, the end of a hallway opens to the other 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths with the additional separate 2 car garage entrance. The private primary, spacious suite offers a luxurious retreat with sitting room, spa-inspired bathroom featuring a relaxing Roman jetted tub, a large walk-in shower, and 2 separate large vanities. The other 2 bedrooms with Jack and Jill style, each has its own vanity and sink with a shared shower/WC in between as the second full bath. The 3rd full bath is by covered screened back patio door for your guest's convenience. All bedrooms have walk in closets professionally re-designed with shelves and drawers for maximum organization of those spaces, and also the large kitchen pantry. The interior features elegant porcelain flooring throughout and a welcoming atmosphere with spacious living area. The kitchen has granite countertops and is positioned as a central hub of the home, offering generous workspace and convenient access to the surrounding living areas. With an oversized island, this kitchen serves as the center of great entertainment with family and friends. Additional features include in-home laundry room, furnishings if so desired to make the move-in process simple and convenient. The large, covered back patio extends the living space and provides a comfortable setting for outdoor dining, relaxing with a morning coffee, or gathering while enjoying Florida's year-round sunshine. The surrounding Lake Mary area is known for its well-maintained neighborhoods, convenient amenities, and active lifestyle opportunities. Residents enjoy easy access to shopping centers, grocery stores, parks, golf courses, walking trails, and a wide variety of restaurants ranging from casual local favorites to popular national dining options, and numerous recreational facilities for dining, entertainment, outdoor activities, and community events year-round. Major roadways are easily accessible. Enjoy Florida living year-round with the fully fenced backyard, providing plenty of room for outdoor enjoyment. The impressive front has a 3-car garage and 3 car driveway in addition to a circular driveway for multi car families. Then, the entrance courtyard creates a welcoming first impression and additional outdoor living space. Located in desirable Lake Mary, this home offers convenient access to top-rated schools, shopping, dining, parks, and major highways. Enjoy Florida living year-round with a screened-in back patio overlooking the fully fenced backyard, providing plenty of room for outdoor enjoyment. The charming front entrance courtyard creates a welcoming first impression and additional outdoor living space. Schedule your private showing soon and experience everything this exceptional home has to enjoy.

Listing is courtesy of: LA ROSA REALTY CW PROPERTIES L (407-910-2168)

Listing Agent: M-Lunie Fontaine Pa (786-368-7063)

Remarks: Take a look at this beautiful home, Clean and Move-In Ready, featuring 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, 2 car garage and approximately 1,643 heated square feet. Enjoy the freedom of a virtually maintenance free lifestyle while residing in a great community. Smart Home Tech - $21.95/mo; Washer/Dryer - $35/mo; High Speed Cable/Internet (if applicable by 3rd Party user) $55/mo; Renters insurance reqrd, Pool service (if applicable) is $150/mo, Septic System (if applicable)- $35/mo; Admin Fee - $150 after lease is generated.

Listing is courtesy of: TAH FLORIDA LLC (844-874-2661)

Listing Agent: Laidy Mataushek (407-298-0779)

Remarks: Welcome to this charming 4 bedroom, 2 bath single-family home ideally located in the heart of Lake Mary! Situated just blocks from vibrant Downtown Lake Mary, you'll enjoy easy access to local restaurants, shops, community events, and the popular weekly Farmers Market. This home offers a large, fully fenced backyard with endless possibilities for outdoor living, entertaining, pets, play, or simply relaxing in your own private retreat. The owner will provide a washer and dryer for the tenant's upon renting. With pets welcome and lawn care included, you'll enjoy the benefits of a beautiful yard without the maintenance. The home's convenient location places you just minutes from Lake Mary Elementary School, parks, walking trails, SunRail, and major roadways for an easy commute. Whether you're hosting family gatherings, enjoying the downtown lifestyle, or looking for extra space both inside and out, this property delivers. Rental opportunities this close to Downtown Lake Mary with a fenced yard, pet-friendly policy, and lawn maintenance included are hard to find. Schedule your private showing today! Home is vacant on a combination lock box and available for lease anytime! Rent Spree Application Link : https://apply.link/-IR1ixE

Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY AT THE PARKS (407-629-4420)

Listing Agent: Sheena Tapia (904-607-6402)

Remarks: Welcome to Griffin Park, one of Lake Mary's most desirable communities! This well maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath single-family home offers the perfect combination of modern design, comfort, and convenience. Step inside to an open-concept floor plan featuring luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout the main living areas, soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and a spacious living and dining area that flows seamlessly into the gourmet kitchen. The kitchen features white shaker cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a gas cooktop with designer range hood, built-in oven and microwave, subway tile backsplash, and an oversized center island that's perfect for entertaining or casual dining. Upstairs, you'll find three spacious bedrooms, including a private primary suite with plenty of room to unwind. Outside, enjoy the charming Craftsman-style curb appeal with attractive board-and-batten accents and welcoming front porch. Griffin Park offers a beautifully maintained neighborhood atmosphere with sidewalks, parks, and community amenities, all just minutes from the best Lake Mary has to offer. Located in the heart of Lake Mary, you'll be just moments from Publix, Target, shopping, dining, entertainment, and quick access to I-4, making commuting to Orlando, Sanford, and surrounding areas a breeze. If you're looking for a stylish, move-in ready home in one of Central Florida's premier communities, this is one you won't want to miss!

Listing is courtesy of: ORLANDO INLAND REALTY LLC (407-284-7684)

Listing Agent: Kathryn Stieger (407-284-7684)

Remarks: Stunning 4BR/3BA Executive Pool Home on Premium Corner Lot in Lake Mary!Experience the perfect blend of privacy and luxury in the highly desirable Reserve at Lake Mary community. This exceptional single-story estate features a light, bright open floor plan with a 3-way split bedroom layout, offering maximum peace and privacy for family and guests. At the heart of the home, an oversized great room overlooks your private outdoor oasis and connects seamlessly to a spacious kitchen with a breakfast bar and dining nook. Step through the sliders into a massive, screened-in lanai featuring a spectacular pool with custom water features and LED lighting, all set within a fully fenced backyard with no side neighbors. The oversized master suite serves as a true retreat, boasting direct pool access, a large walk-in closet plus a secondary closet, and a spa-like bath with a whirlpool corner tub and separate walk-in shower. Strategically located less than a mile from Lake Mary Prep and the Lake Mary Sports Complex, you will enjoy effortless access to I-4, the 417, top-rated schools, championship golf courses, and premier dining—all just a short drive from Central Florida’s best attractions and beaches. Applicants must pass a credit and background check. Pet-friendly policy allows up to 2 pets (60 lbs weight limit per pet).

Listing is courtesy of: 407 PROPERTIES (407-545-2594)

Listing Agent: Steven Simpson (407-545-2594)

Remarks: Welcome to this fully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home situated in a beautiful and peaceful neighborhood. This stunning property boasts brand new Luxury Vinyl Flooring throughout, fresh paint, and a newly updated kitchen with elegant quartz countertops, a large kitchen island, and brand new stainless steel appliances. The modernized bathrooms feature sleek ceramic tiles, and you'll also enjoy the convenience of a new washer and dryer. With a spacious 2-car garage and located in a safe, family-friendly community, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. Centrally located, you're just minutes away from shopping, dining, and entertainment. Don't miss the opportunity to make this beautiful home yours! Tenant pays for utilities. Last month's rent and one month security due at signing. No Smoking allowed.

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (888-883-8509)

Listing Agent: Sanjeev Malik (321-297-3009)

Remarks: ***TENANT OCCUPIED, PLEASE SCHEDULE SHOWING*** Welcome to your dream home in Lake Mary, Florida! This beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home, boasts 1,165 sqft of living space and is move-in ready. The open interior layout gives the home a clean and modern look. Luxury vinyl flooring adds a touch of elegance and durability to the home's main living areas. Both bathrooms have updated fixtures and finishes, ensuring your daily routine is comfortable and stylish. The screened-in patio is perfect for relaxing or entertaining, and fenced-in backyard provides plenty of privacy and space for outdoor activities. Located in the heart of Lake Mary, this home is just a short drive away from local shops, restaurants, and entertainment options. Plus, the community offers access to top-rated schools and beautiful parks. Don't miss out on this opportunity to own a beautiful home in a great location!

Listing is courtesy of: THE LISTING REAL ESTATE MANAGEMENT (407-792-5900)

Listing Agent: Jobe Peterson (407-792-5900)

Remarks: Welcome to 3609 SIMONTON PLACE, a Breathtaking Modern Residence Nestled in the Exclusive Gated Community of Banyan Pointe in the HEART of LAKE MARY, Florida. Discover the Epitome of Luxury Living in this Meticulously Designed Neighborhood Enclave, Featuring only 33 homes, each a Masterpiece Showcasing the Distinctive Charm of Key West Style Architecture. Vibrant Colors, Front Porches, and Dramatic Sloped Roof Lines Greet You, Creating an Immediate Sense of Curb Appeal and Elegance as You Arrive. The Primary Owner's Suite and two additional bedrooms are located on the SECOND floor. This Stunning Home is Perfectly Designed to Harmonize Family, Friends, Pleasure, Privacy, and Peace Within its Carefully Crafted an Extensively Remodeled Interior. Boasting 3,605 Square Feet of Living Space, This Residence Offers 4 Generous Bedrooms, 4 Bathrooms, a Bonus Room, an Oversized 2 Car Garage, and a Swimming Pool with a Screened Enclosure. The Primary Owner's Suite is on the SECOND Floor includes Additional Space for a Private Office or Craft Room, Adding a Touch of Versatility to Your Living Experience. Step Inside to Discover a Home that has Undergone a Complete Transformation, from a Brand NEW ROOF and Flooring to Fresh Interior and Exterior Painting. The Kitchen and Bathrooms Have Been Stylishly Remodeled, and the Home Features a New HVAC and a New State of the Art WiFi Enabled Water Heater. Enjoy Energy Efficiency with New Upgraded Windows to both East and West Exposures, and Energy- Saving LED Lighting. The Entire Home has Been Fortified with Spray Foam Insulation Injected into both the Concrete Block and Attic, ensuring Comfort and Sustainability. Every Inch of this Residence is Adorned with Brand-New, High Quality Finishes, Promisinga Luxurious Touch Everywhere You Look and Touch. Now is Your Chance to Experience the Epitome of Modern Luxurious Living. Schedule Your Private Appointment to See First Hand the Grandeur of 3609 SIMONTON PLACE. Welcome Home to a Lifestyle of Unparalleled Elegance! RENT INCLUDES WEEKLY POOL AND WEEKLY LAWN MAINTENANCE. Walk or Bike to Greenwood Lakes Middle or Lake Mary High School. PLEASE NO PETS and NO SMOKING. RENTERS INSURANCE REQUIRED PRIOR TO MOVING IN. Credit and background check will be done on all applicants 18 Years and Older. Home will be ready unfurnished.

Listing is courtesy of: LPT REALTY, LLC (877-366-2213)

Listing Agent: Lorinda Orozco, Pa (407-562-8757)

Remarks: Rental Single Family Pool Home in conviently located Lake Mary. Close to shopping centers and restaurant and to major highways I4 and 417. This beautifu home has a private, screened, built in pool (pool maintenance is included in the rent), along with a nice size backyard to entertain friends and family. It features four bedrooms 2.5 baths (the garage is converted into a 4th bedroom) or use it as a play/bonus room. Fresh paint throughout the home and ceramic tile floors throughout the first floor and wood laminate on all upstairs bedrooms and hallway.

Listing is courtesy of: LOKATION (954-545-5583)

Listing Agent: Andrea Levin (407-383-1731)

Remarks: A MUST SEE!!! This 4 bedroom 2.5 bathroom home, in the center of Lake Mary with 2 car garage, fenced backyard, spacious Family Room with a wood burning fireplace is a place to call home! Master bedroom on the first floor, 3 bedrooms on the second.

Listing is courtesy of: WEICHERT REALTORS HALLMARK PRO (407-585-0500)

Listing Agent: Azim Manji (407-342-3548)

Remarks: Well Maintained 2Bed/2Bath Home in Lake Mary with Pond View! Very Clean Property, Move in Ready!, 2 Car Garage, Pond View, No Rear Neighbors, Large Backyard, Screened in Patio, Walk-In Closet, Double Sink Vanity, Granite Countertops, Tile Flooring, Freshly Painted!, Fireplace, Ceiling Fans in many rooms, CONVENIENT to: Major Roads, Shopping, Schools, CONVENIENT To: Greenwood Lakes Middle, CONVENIENT To: Lake Mary High, All kitchen appliances INCLUDED, Washer/Dryer Included. The deposit amount is based upon the application results. Pets: OK (Dangerous Pets are not permitted, Pit Bulls, etc.) Priced $2,099.00 for the first 4 months, $2,199.00 for the remaining 8 months (Average: 2,167.00/mo). AVAILABLE: NOW

Listing is courtesy of: ORLANDO REALTY & PROPERTY MGNT (407-641-5782)

Listing Agent: Jay Myers (407-641-5782)

Remarks: 4/2.5 Corner Unit Two Story Single Family Home, 2 Car Garage, Family Room, Living Room, Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen with Appliances Included: Stove, Refrigerator, and Dishwasher, Upstairs Inside Utility Room with Washer and Dryer Hook Ups, Master Bathroom has Garden Tub, Tile and Carpet Flooring Throughout, Walk-In Closets, Open Patio, Tenant Responsible for Lawn Fertilization, Community Pool, Playground, NO PETS, NO SMOKING, Year Built: 1992, 2124 Sqft.

Listing is courtesy of: LEGENDS REALTY (407-333-1010)

Listing Agent: Tina Lopez (407-333-1010)

Remarks: Welcome to this stunning home in the guard-gated community of Heathrow, located within the desirable Keenwicke subdivision. Recent renovations include designer-updated bathroom counters, fresh interior paint, and a beautifully remodeled kitchen. The heart of the home is the open kitchen, complete with a bar overlooking the eat-in area and a spacious Great Room that seamlessly connects to the screened patio—perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The main living areas feature gorgeous wood-like tile flooring that combines style with durability. The primary suite is tucked away at the back of the home, providing a peaceful retreat with a large walk-in closet and a luxurious en-suite bath featuring dual sinks, a soaking tub, and a separate walk-in shower. Down the hall, you’ll find three additional bedrooms, a second full bathroom, and a separate laundry room. Just around the corner, Lake Sawyer Park offers scenic walking paths, a dock, basketball courts, baseball fields, soccer fields, a playground, picnic areas, and the clubhouse. With its prime location close to major shopping, top-rated restaurants, and easy highway access, this home offers both luxury and convenience. Schedule your showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: ALVES AND HOWELL REALTY (407-750-2171)

Listing Agent: Gabriel Mantovani (407-637-9878)

Remarks: Welcome to your next home, sweet home, in beautiful Lake Mary, Florida! This Charming house, Available May 15, 2025, offers a cozy retreat with 1,39 square feet of well-planned living space. With three bedrooms and two bathrooms, this residence provides a blend of comfort and style. Enter to discover a spacious kitchen, where you can cook up culinary delights while enjoying views of your serene surroundings. After a long day, retreat to the primary bedroom, featuring a garden tub perfect for soaking away your worries. The split-plan layout of the home ensures privacy and space efficiency, perfect for both entertaining and quiet relaxation. Situated in a vibrant community, your new home is conveniently located near local amenities. Enjoy grocery runs to the nearby Walmart Neighborhood Market or spend sunny afternoons at Grove View Park, both situated less than a mile away.

Listing is courtesy of: WEICHERT REALTORS HALLMARK PRO (407-841-0888)

Listing Agent: James Rice (321-247-0583)

Remarks: Amazing 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house in Lake Mary. Amenities included: central air, central heat, dishwasher, Luxury Vinyl floors, stainless steel appliance, updated kitchen, updated bathroom, washer dryer, laundry in building, and yard. This property is ready for immediate occupancy, subject to HOA approval. Excellent Seminole county schools in the neighborhood. Minutes away from shopping, restaurants and businesses .Minutes away from I-4, 417 and 429

Listing is courtesy of: DALTON WADE INC (888-668-8283)

Listing Agent: Chandramohan Narayana Swamy (407-687-0287)

Remarks: 3/2, 2 Car Garage, Single Family Home, Family Room with Fireplace, Living Room/ Dining Room Combo, Eat in Kitchen with Appliances Included: Stove, Refrigerator, Microwave, Dishwasher and Disposal, Wood Laminate and Carpet Throughout Home, Inside Utility Room with Hookups, Screened Patio, Fenced Backyard, Pets Okay Upon Owner Approval, NO SMOKING, Year Built: 1987/ 1655 Sqft.

Listing is courtesy of: LEGENDS REALTY (407-333-1010)

Listing Agent: Tina Lopez (407-333-1010)