Displaying: For Rent
Location: Longboat Key
Property Type(s): Single Family
Living Area Square Feet: 1500 to 1999
Do Not Show Listings
Longboat Key - 6 properties found
640 BROADWAY ST, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$5,500158 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4673491
REDUCED by $1,750 (24.1%) on 04/29/2026
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1500 Built: 1940Community: Longbeach Rev Of R P Jordans SubSpa: NoSingle Family
Market Analysis: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Nearby Properties: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Taxes:
Elementary School: None
High School: None
Tax Year:
Middle School: None
Remarks: HOT off-season specials for May through end of August. Step into living history in the heart of Historic Longbeach Village. This exceptional property occupies land that was part of Civil War veteran Thomas Mann’s 144-acre homestead, where in 1891 he built the island’s first permanent residence just steps away. This serene corner lot is where Longboat Key truly began! Fully rebuilt and elevated in 2025 to the highest modern standards after the 2024 storms, this turnkey coastal residence offers unmatched peace of mind and contemporary luxury. The light-filled, open-concept interior features vaulted ceilings, a gourmet kitchen with new stainless-steel appliances and quartz countertops, and two beautifully appointed spa bathrooms with premium fixtures and rainfall showers. The primary suite indulges with a king bed, wet bar, mini-fridge, and a windowed en-suite bath, while the second bedroom provides a comfortable queen bed. A dedicated home office is your third bedroom, with its full-size Murphy bed/desk. The private tropical backyard serves as a tranquil oasis, complete with a serene lily-pad pond, fire pit, and mature landscaping. Delivered fully furnished with beautiful coastal décor and equipped with high-speed fiber internet, the home is ideal for immediate personal enjoyment, remote work, or proven vacation-rental income. Grandfathered Village zoning permits short-term rentals. Enjoy an unparalleled lifestyle just a short walk from Whitney Beach, historic fishing docks, bay kayak launches, and waterfront dining. Longboat Key Club, St. Armands Circle, and downtown Sarasota’s world-class amenities are only minutes away. Rarely available: authentic historic significance, a total top-to-bottom 2025 rebuild, and the quintessential Village address. Move-in ready
Listing is courtesy of: LPT REALTY, LLC (877-366-2213)
Listing Agent: Christina Vescovo (314-743-7111)
701 BROADWAY ST, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$14,400159 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4673262
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1650 Built: 1920Community: WendySpa: YesSingle Family
Remarks: This charming single-story residence is a meticulous rebuild with an open-concept great room featuring high ceilings, abundant natural light, and a gourmet kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances and a gas range. The private, fully fenced backyard offers a lagoon style heated swimming pool, separate hot tub, lush tropical landscaping, and the soothing sound of swaying palms. Completely reimagined 1920 historic bungalow, originally serving as a temporary US Post Office after a hurricane. Serene Village location with no public parking ensures exceptional peace and privacy. Ample boat/RV parking on site and deeded bay access steps away. Walk to Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Pub; minutes by car or bicycle to St. Armands Circle and Lido Beach. Offered fully furnished for a minimum 28-day rental period. Two king suites with dual closets each plus queen sleeper sofa in the main house. Ideal snowbird retreat or extended-stay executive residence. There is also a sweet one bedroom apartment above the garage with a queen bed, queen sofa & beautiful balcony overlooking the pool Available now—just two blocks from Whitney Beach and one block from Sarasota Bay and public boat ramp access.
613 BUTTONWOOD DR, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$17,500298 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4655401
Bed: 3 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1871 Built: 1967Community: Longboat Shores RevSpa: YesSingle Family
Remarks: Available for season 2026 Looking for a 3 month rental. Newly renovated, this beautiful home features a split floor plan with generously sized bedrooms and walk-in closets, all enhanced by a charming coastal flair. The kitchen—truly the heart of the home—is fully equipped with everything you need to prepare delicious home-cooked meals. Enjoy your morning coffee or an evening cocktail in the cozy coffee-bar area. Head outside to the brand new beautiful pool and spa. One end features a soaking or sunbathing area, then step into the crystal clear deep end. Plenty of new stone pool deck on the offered lounge chairs to bask in the Florida sun. Welcome to peaceful Buttonwood Harbour, composed of 50 homes in one of Longboat Key's oldest and sought-after communities. Situated in the middle of Longboat Key, it is walking distance for most, to Publix, the Shoppes of Bay Isles, Tennis, post office, and CVS. Full of friendly neighbors and a favorite place for nature lovers. Boaters and fisherman will be happy with accessibility to the BHA boat ramp for launching and ability to dock your boat at the house during your stay, even utilize the kayak storage if you decide to rent them. No bridges from Buttonwood Harbour out to Sarasota Bay's open waters. Enjoy the day at Bayfront Park, 1.4 miles from the house. Amenities found at Bayfront Park include a 1,350 square foot indoor Recreation Center, a playground, a basketball court, shuffleboard courts, a multi-purpose open field, 3 dedicated pickleball courts, a tennis court, picnic tables, restrooms, and parking for a Town public beach access located across the street. The Bayfront Park Recreation Center is a public recreation facility run by the Town of Longboat Key. You will also find a dog park for your fur babies.
Listing is courtesy of: PRECISE REALTY CORP (941-400-0374)
Listing Agent: Jennifer Le Blanc (941-400-0374)
500 SCHOONER LN, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$11,5501154 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4561269
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1657 Built: 1964Community: Country Club ShoresSingle Family
Remarks: Booked January, May-June 8th, October, and Dec 2026 through April 15th 2027, May 2027. There is 2 week minimum stay required. Charming, waterfront Longboat Key surprise! This 2 bedroom 2 bath house is sure to impress. Total renovation will bring you delight upon entering. Every detail was thought out from kitchen to bathrooms. Fun, chic, beach inspired decorating with the fun, splattered octopus theme to bring a smile to anyone. Plenty of dishware, gadgets, cooking equipment for the gourmet chef in you all. Outdoor living could be your everyday enjoyment while sipping wine by your private heated pool and on cool nights curl up at the fire pit. Sit back and relax with many seating areas and full outdoor dining table in this cozy beach themed oasis in Country Club Shores. Quiet sought out neighborhood on south end of Longboat Key with beach access between LBK Club and Beach Place. It is fully equipped with everything you will need to feel at home while enjoying the sights and comforts that Longboat Key has to offer. Just minutes to St Armand’s Circle or Lido Beach for shopping, fine dining or laying at the public beach with all your favorite people. Longboat is known for their waterfront golf, fine dining and luxury resorts. In fact, its 12 miles of white sand beaches have helped to make this a luxury Gulf Coast resort community. There are numerous Activities and Attractions in the Sarasota/Bradenton/Siesta area. -Just a few of the many treasures and cultural events are Benderson Park, Mote Marine Aquarium, Ringling Museum of Art, fishing charters out of Marina Jack's, Florida's Largest Wildlife Rescue / Rehabilitation Center with the Pelican Man, Selby Botanical Gardens, and the Van Wezel.
2823 GULF OF MEXICO DR, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$10,000209 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4667245
Bed: 3 Bath: 3.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1744 Built: 1952Community: Coquina BeachSingle Family
Remarks: Summer 2026 is available for June, July, and August! Call today! Welcome to beachfront paradise on Longboat Key! This outstanding location offers a rare opportunity to enjoy coastal living with breathtaking views of the shoreline. Nestled along the pristine shores of Longboat Key, this three-bedroom, three-bathroom home invites you to experience the ultimate beachfront lifestyle. Relax under the sun, unwind to the sound of waves just steps from your door, sip your morning coffee with panoramic ocean views, and take in unforgettable sunsets — all from your own slice of paradise. Located directly on the beach, this property offers a true coastal tropical oasis. You're just minutes from Publix for all your grocery needs, and only 1.5 miles from the Longboat Key Bayfront Park, where you can enjoy pickleball, tennis, shuffleboard, basketball, a playground, swings, and scenic walking paths. Looking for shopping and dining? St. Armands Circle is just a 5-mile drive away, offering a celebrated selection of restaurants and boutiques. June, July, August, November, and December are available! Rates are: $10,000 for June, $10,000 for July, $10,000 for August, $10,000 for November, and $10,000 for December. Taxes apply. Call today and book your stay!
Listing is courtesy of: CELLA'S REAL ESTATE INC (941-952-8649)
Listing Agent: Michael Cella (941-952-8649)
616 LYONS LN, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228
$4,80037 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: TB8491342
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.5 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1755 Built: 1972Community: Sleepy Lagoon Park 2Spa: NoSingle Family
Remarks: Come and enjoy a little piece of Paradise! This beautiful canal front home is located in the idyllic and picturesque Longboat Key. A charming mid-century style cottage nestled in one of Longboat Key's most private and serene settings. This spacious 2 bedroom + Bonus room, 2.5 bathrooms with outdoor shower residence offers 1,755 square feet of luxurious living space perfect for those seeking a tranquil beach lifestyle. Recently impacted by Hurricane Helene, the home has undergone professional remediation and renovation including kitchen, bathrooms and pool. The living area boasts an open floor plan with a cozy corner wood-burning fireplace that adds a warm touch, creating the perfect setting for snug evenings during the cooler winter months. The kitchen has been completely remodeled and equipped with all new cabinets, quartz countertops and appliances, offering plenty of space for culinary adventures. The master suite includes a cedar walk-in closet, an extra linen closet, and direct access to the pool area. In addition to the 2 bedrooms, there is a bonus room that could be made into a bunk room perfect for the little ones or teenagers to make their own retreat. Lyons Lane is renowned for its tranquility and privacy, with lush mangroves lining the opposite side of the street, creating a natural, peaceful ambiance. This unique setting offers the best of both worlds: a serene retreat just moments away from the pristine beaches, boutique shopping, and fine dining that Longboat Key is famous for.
Listing is courtesy of: ROOST REALTY INC. (813-326-2569)
Listing Agent: Steve Barthelemy (813-943-2841)
Please select an email frequency other than None since you have chosen for us to email you with changes that match your search.