Acreage & Unrec Homes for Sale in Sarasota - 5 homes

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Gulf-to-Bay elegance meets relaxed coastal sophistication in this elevated, sailboat-access waterfront retreat, ideally positioned within one of Siesta Key’s most exclusive gated enclaves. Set in a rare peninsula neighborhood offering true Gulf-to-Bay living, this Caribbean-inspired residence delivers exceptional privacy, sweeping water views, and direct boating access with no bridges to the Intracoastal Waterway. With the newly reopened Midnight Pass just minutes away, access to the Gulf is effortless, making this an extraordinary opportunity for boaters and beach lovers alike. Surrounded by mature tropical landscaping and located on a quiet dead-end street, the home enjoys both Gulf views and a tranquil basin setting with a private dock. Inside, a vaulted-ceiling great room anchors the main living level, filled with natural light and framed by sliding glass doors that open to expansive covered terraces on both the east and west sides—perfect for sunrise mornings and sunset evenings overlooking the water. The open-concept kitchen is designed for entertaining and everyday living, featuring premium appliances including a Sub-Zero refrigerator and generous workspace. The primary suite is located on the main living level, offering terrace access and serene water views, while additional guest accommodations provide flexibility for family and friends. Above, a rooftop observation deck—accessible via spiral staircase—offers breathtaking 360-degree vistas spanning the Gulf, bay, and coastline, creating a truly unforgettable vantage point. Thoughtfully constructed on pilings with storm-conscious design, the home blends timeless island style with peace of mind. The ground level provides covered parking for multiple vehicles, abundant storage, and space for kayaks, paddleboards, and beach gear. An elevator shaft is already in place for future installation, and pool plans are available. With deeded beach access just steps away and a private dock at your back door, this is one of the few properties on Siesta Key where you can enjoy the beach in front and your boat behind. Beach, boating, privacy, and views converge in this exceptional offering—capturing the essence of Gulf-to-Bay living on Siesta Key. From morning experiences along the shoreline to breathtaking sunsets over the Gulf, every day on Siesta Key feels like a vacation. And when you're ready to explore beyond the island, downtown Sarasota is just a short drive away, offering world-class dining, arts and culture, including the Ringling Museum, Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall, and St. Armands Circle.

Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY (941-364-4000)

Listing Agent: Judie Berger (941-928-3424)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Take a look at this 1600 sq ft 3 bedroom, 2 bath home. This home is currently set up as a 2/1 with an additional 1/1 mother in law suite, but can be turned back into a 3/2. Stay in one side and rent out the other, or use for a weekly Airbnb since it's in the city limits. Plenty of room for a pool, or large patio in the backyard! All major updates have been completed: new PGT vinyl impact windows, new roof, new AC, new electrical service, and new hot water heater. Both sides have access to the laundry room. Big backyard and within biking distance to Pinecraft, Locklear Park, and the Legacy Trail. Come check out this home before it's gone!

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-366-8070)

Listing Agent: Caitlin Dennis (941-250-5804)

Remarks: A rare opportunity to own 1.2 acres in the heart of Sarasota. Country style living but Close to everything — airport - UTC downtown - St Armand’s - - Beaches - Museums - Galleries - Theatre - schools - medical - churches This property located in Desoto Acres was built in 1972 - and in 2017/2018 the old Florida cottage was completely gutted down to the studs - new plumbing , new electric, new walls,ceilings, roof, brick wood burning fireplace , New Halo 5 whole house water filtration system , New kitchen with appliances And new bathrooms both with walk in showers A cozy but spacious primary suite plus a study/den. And - 2 baths A unique cottage whether you live there or make it a vacation home Or Mother in law suite - and if you want to add a bigger residence Plenty of space Enter in the front door into the Living Room Which has a rustic feature wall and wood burning fireplace and opens to the Dining area and Kitchen The spacious Master suite bath has a clawfoot tub Double vanity and walk in shower . The guest bath With a walk in shower is Adjacent to the kitchen . Off the kitchen is a panel door that Opens to a large Laundry/Pantry/ Storage room French doors Off the kitchen open to a bonus room —- Which also has a rustic feature wall . This room could be an office or den Or add a closet Or armoire and make it a second bedroom From this room a glass panel door opens to the covered back patio and the caged solar heated pool. There is a fenced area for a pet too An access door opens to the back of the property Which had a barn a shed a covered building for RV or Boat plus 2 other buildings This Property offers plenty of space A great in town convenient private location Your very own piece of paradise To build on and just enjoy the privacy and nature.

Listing is courtesy of: W.I.T. REALTY LLC (941-330-5080)

Listing Agent: Nathan Dunham (941-330-5080)

Remarks: Location, Location, Location! West of Trail - Just minutes to Siesta Key Beaches. 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 2 Stall Garage, Split Foor Plan. In a quiet neighbohood with no HOA's. Minutes to the White Sand Beaches of Siesta Key! Minutes to the Crescent Beach; all within walking distance to Shopping, Dining, Sand and Beach.

Listing is courtesy of: WATERSIDE REALTY GROUP, INC (239-330-4548)

Listing Agent: Diana Musk (231-730-8044)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Three-bedroom, three-bath Heritage log home with 8" slow growth eastern pine logs on just under 5 acres. Featuring a resort-style saltwater pool with waterfall, underwater lighting, in-pool seating, and propane fire pit, all overlooking a spacious 20’ x 40’ covered lanai. High ceilings, private office, and expansive wraparound porch enhance the home’s charm and functionality. New air conditioner 2026, Water Heater 2022, Pool and Garage 2021. Set on 4.5 fully fenced acres with automatic ornamental driveway gate, the property includes a 4-car detached garage, barn from 1952, carport, pond, and a 25 kW whole-home generator with a 500-gallon buried, owned propane tank. Zoned for horses and livestock, Enjoy peaceful country living in Sarasota with convenient access—approximately 15 minutes to I-75, 25 miles to Siesta Key Beach, 22.5 miles to Lido Beach, 22 miles to St. Armands Circle, 13.5 miles to Waterside Lakewood Ranch, and 17.5 miles to UTC Mall.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-366-8070)

Listing Agent: Ian Mcpherson (941-320-0999)