Polynesian Gardens Homes for Sale in Sarasota - 7 homes

Remarks: Renovated in 2025 and offered fully furnished, THIS FREE STANDING VILLA ON SIESTA KEY IS TRULY TURN KEY-ideal as a personal retreat or a high-demand seasonal rental. Nestled in the highly desirable Polynesian Gardens along the Intracoastal Waterway, this villa offers a rare combination of privacy and convenience. One of only ten villas overlooking the expansive community pool, enjoy your own private entrance just steps from the fresh air terrace and screened lanai. Positioned at one of the highest elevations in the community, it adds both appeal and peace of mind. Unwind in your private outdoor oasis with lush tropical landscaping and a cozy LP gas fire pit—perfect for relaxing evenings. NEW ROOF 2024, NEW HVAC SYSTEM 2023, WATER HEATER 2025, PROGRAMMABLE NEST THERMOSTAT, PROGRAMMABLE AND REMOTE ENTRY TOUCH KEY LOCK, REMOTE CAMERA SYSTEM, AND NEW GUTTERS 2025. Spend your days fishing or watching dolphins and manatees from the community dock/fishing pier on the INTRACOASTAL WATER WAY. Walk to local favorites including dining, shopping, coffee spots, and nightlife at Captain Curt’s, plus nearby grocery stores and marina access. Just across the street is world-famous Siesta Key Beach with its cool, powdery white quartz sand beach. Bike, golf cart, or take the free trolley to The Village for even more to explore. This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath villa with covered carport and screened lanai lives like a single-family home, offering spacious outdoor living with the ease of low-maintenance, lock-and-leave convenience. RENTAL HISTORY IN ATTACHMENTS. ENJOY THE ULTIMATE SIESTA KEY LIFESTYLE--MOVE IN, RENT OUT, OR SIMPLY RELAX.

Listing is courtesy of: MORRIS REALTY AND INVESTMENTS (352-435-4663)

Listing Agent: Jo Leen Howe (352-267-0770)

Remarks: Rarely available direct bayfront 2/2 maintenance free villa in Polynesian Gardens. Magnificent views of the Intracoastal/Little Sarasota Bay. Watch the manatees and boats go by from your paved patio directly on the water. Spacious 2 bedrooms/2 full baths with very large great room. Updated kitchen and baths with new cabinetry, granite and stainless-steel appliances. Plenty of closet space. Garage with plenty of storage plus an extra driveway allows for 2 parking spaces. Newer washer/dryer in garage. Beautiful landscaping. Community has a heated pool, clubhouse and fishing pier. Close to shops, dining and America's #1 Beach - Siesta Key. Free trolley stops directly in the front of the community on Midnight Pass Road. Two pets allowed any size.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)

Listing Agent: Helene Hyland (941-685-2274)

Remarks: Welcome to your dream villa! This spacious coastal villa retreat on Siesta Key boasts 2-bedrooms and 2-bathrooms and offers 1,575 square feet of comfortable, open-concept living space, perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. Step inside to a freshly painted interior featuring a modern, neutral palette that complements any décor. This wonderful detached-villa is in a serene location just across the street from million-dollar residences on the Bay and offers low-maintenance living with a luxurious feel. It is high and dry and has never flooded. This villa has an impressive list of updates including a new Barrel Tile Roof and complete Air Conditioning System. The large open dinning/living room area has bamboo flooring and sliding glass doors leading to your retractable awning-covered paved patio. A separate office area with built in desk and shelving and the potential for adding a sleeper sofa. A spacious primary bedroom with en-suite bathroom has a walk in closet and separate storage area. The second bedroom is roomy, light and pleasant ideal for either family or guests. The kitchen was completely remolded in 2016 and has a built in pantry, shaker cabinets with pullout shelving and a breakfast nook. Don’t miss this move-in ready gem with big-ticket upgrades already done! Polynesian Gardens is ideally located and provides a tranquil and unique Siesta Key escape for owners and guests alike. Relax and enjoy the tropical palms, large heated pool and peaceful intracoastal pier that provide a relaxing Siesta Key experience. Either take a short walk or take the free trolley which stops directly in the front of the community to world famous Siesta Key Beach, local restaurants, shopping, boat and fishing charters and rentals for all outdoor and water activities. Additional Features: •New Barrel Tile Roof. •This home features a spacious carport, offering sheltered parking and added storage potential. •Laundry room with full-size washer & dryer. •Quiet, well-maintained community. •Community amenities included; landscaping, exterior maintenance, cable tv, water, intracoastal pier and large heated pool. *The Polynesian Gardens Home Owners Association has plans in effect to paint the exterior of this Villa at no cost to the owner. Potentially the new owner will have their choice of colors. The unit is VACANT!

Listing is courtesy of: WATERSIDE REALTY LLC (941-346-7454)

Listing Agent: Dean Hall (941-726-7197)

Remarks: Outstanding remodeled and updated freestanding 3/3 villa in private and beautiful Polynesian Gardens. New ceramic tile flooring throughout. Spacious with large rooms plus 259 extra square feet in glassed in lanai/Florida room which can be used as a family room. office or man cave. The updates include a new addition to the villa of approximately 330 additional square feet and a beautiful second primary suite/third bedroom with an ensuite bath and a laundry room with new washer/dryer and cabinet and closets. 3 bedrooms are split from each other. Primary bedroom has an ensuite bath with a shower and extra shelving for toiletries, large walk-in closet and a set of sliders to the Florida room. Guest bedroom is large enough for two queen size beds plus large closets. Guest bathroom is right outside of guest bedroom and has a tub/shower with updated vanity with dual sinks. Combo living/dining area with easy access to updated kitchen with pantry and cabinetry galore. New appliances. Living/dining room is large and has a coat closet. New sliding glass door adds sunshine and light and leads to the large private paved side yard and back yard. Large enough for gardening, patio furniture and a barbeque. This villa has been replumbed and the drainpipes were replaced in the entire house in 2017. The roof was replaced by the Association in 2020. New roof on the addition and transition to the existing roof in 2026 Exterior has been freshly painted. New landscaping. Installation of a new 5' high white vinyl fence in the front and rear with a gated storage space. Solar security lights on the rear fence. Many more improvements too numerous to list but available on a feature sheet. Polynesian Gardens is an active community with a clubhouse, heated swimming pool and a newly built fishing pier. Yet the location and setting of Polynesian Gardens allows its owners to enjoy a relaxed coastal lifestyle. The Siesta Breeze free trolley stops in front of the community and will take you to Siesta Village for shopping and eating out, to Turtle Beach and to world renowned Siesta Key beach, America's #1 Beach, known for its powdery white quartz sand. Close to Sarasota's downtown area and cultural centers, there are many venues for entertainment and education. Rentals are allowed and are always in demand. Own your own piece of Paradise.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)

Listing Agent: Stephen Clementi (912-704-2116)

Remarks: Welcome to your New Home, minutes from the world-renowned Siesta Key Beach, consistently ranked as one of the #1 beaches in the U.S famous for its powdery white quartz sand and crystal-clear Gulf waters. This impeccably remodeled turnkey furnished home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the best of coastal living within the charming Polynesian Gardens community. This, home offers a refined take on island living, featuring a new roof, new AC, and impact-rated windows and doors for style, comfort, and peace of mind. Designed with a light, coastal aesthetic, the open-concept layout is both inviting and functional. At the heart of the home, the designer kitchen showcases custom white cabinetry, brand-new stainless appliances, and a tile backsplash, complemented by a dining area seamlessly positioned adjacent to the kitchen and perfect for effortless entertaining or relaxed everyday living. The home features a spacious primary suite with a beautifully appointed ensuite bath, along with a guest bedroom and full guest bathroom, offering privacy and comfort for family and visitors. The living space extends into an enclosed, expanded lanai, creating a versatile indoor-outdoor retreat to enjoy year-round. A rare highlight is the oversized private garden, offering a lush, tropical setting with exceptional privacy, an uncommon feature that truly sets this villa apart and enhances the feeling of a private coastal escape. Residents of Polynesian Gardens enjoy a resort-style lifestyle with amenities including a community pier on the intercoastal, a heated pool, and clubhouse. Beyond the community, enjoy effortless access to the vibrant energy of Siesta Key Village, known for its beachside restaurants, bars, live music, and boutique shopping, as well as the relaxed charm of Crescent Beach village. This property also offers a proven rental history with strong year-round bookings, making it an exceptional opportunity for both personal enjoyment and income potential. Whether you’re spending the day boating along the Intracoastal, enjoying the white quartz sands of Siesta Key Beach, or unwinding in your own private garden retreat, this exceptional villa captures the essence of luxury coastal living. Perfectly positioned near Siesta Key Village and the Gulf beaches, this turnkey remodeled property presents an incredible opportunity as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or income-producing investment

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (888-883-8509)

Listing Agent: Jayne Appleyard (941-681-5042)

Remarks: Totally renovated and updated villa with one bedroom and one full bath plus a bonus room and a large glassed-in lanai. This property is located in beautiful Polynesian Gardens close to the community pool and clubhouse. Extra-large great room and primary bedroom. Bonus room large enough for a queen size bed. Extra-large glassed-in lanai. New appliances, new kitchen cabinets, new tile floors throughout. Impact glass in entry door, PGT impact windows and plantation shutters. Too many improvements to list. List of improvements available. The free Siesta Breeze trolley stops in front of the main entrance providing quick access to the #1 Beach at Siesta Key plus Siesta Village, South Siesta Village and Turtle Beach. Fishing pier also available on Intracoastal.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)

Listing Agent: Helene Hyland (941-685-2274)

Remarks: A $500K price reduction - don't wait! A rarely available bayfront opportunity to create your dream retreat on Siesta Key. Experience the allure of waterfront living in this detached bayfront villa, poised for a fresh vision in the desirable Polynesian Gardens community on Siesta Key. One of only 11 exclusive bayfront residences, this end-unit villa offers sweeping, unobstructed views of the Intracoastal Waterway from nearly every room, where sunrises paint the sky in breathtaking hues. Go outside to your expansive private waterfront deck, where you can unwind to the sights of boats gliding by, playful dolphins in the distance, and the peaceful rhythm of the bay. A natural beachfront at your doorstep invites you to dip your toes in the water and embrace the tranquil coastal lifestyle. Professionally remediated following Hurricane Helene, this residence is a blank canvas, ready for transformation. With a spacious two-bedroom, two-bath layout that exceeds the size of many three-bedroom villas in the community, the potential for a luxurious, customized retreat is limitless. Enjoy the privacy and convenience of your own garage and private entrance, delivering the feel of a single-family home, yet with the ease of villa living. The location is unbeatable, just minutes from the world-famous Siesta Beach, renowned for its soft quartz sands and mesmerizing Gulf waters, where mango-hued sunsets cap off each day. Centrally located on the island, you're moments from the vibrant dining, boutique shopping, and lively atmosphere of Siesta Key Village and South Siesta Village, and just a short drive to downtown Sarasota’s cultural arts scene, theaters, and fabulous dining. This is a rare opportunity to reimagine and create your custom bayfront sanctuary in one of Siesta Key’s sought-after communities. Don’t let this one-of-a-kind coastal gem slip away.

Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY (941-364-4000)

Listing Agent: Judie Berger (941-928-3424)