Misty Creek Homes for Sale in Sarasota - 12 homes

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. This is the one * QUALITY BUILT BY CUSTOM HOME BUILDERS, CHRISTNER BROTHERS * A VERY PRIVATE SETTING on ALMOST 1 ACRE and backing to PANORAMIC GOLF COURSE VIEWS in the distance * PRIDE OF ORIGINAL OWNER SHOWS * This IMMACULATE home has been LOVINGLY CARED FOR * NEWER MAIN A/C * NEW HOT WATER HEATER * This Custom Built home features 8 Foot Sliding Glass Doors, and both 10 Foot & 12 Foot Ceilings * This EXECUTIVE FAMILY HOME has been LOVINGLY RENOVATED * Your Large Chef's Kitchen is open to the Family Room and features Custom Solid Wood Cabinets that are extra deep for additional storage * Kitchen also features a SUBZERO Refrigerator , Built-in Oven, Separate Cook-top, Granite Countertops, an Eat-in Nook and a Breakfast Bar * Family Room showcases a beautiful GAS Fireplace and a Wet Bar with an Icemaker * The Primary Retreat is SPACIOUS with TWO Walk-in Closets * Relax in your Spa-style Bath with NEWER Custom Cabinets, a Walk-in Shower, Dual Sinks & Vanity, a Garden Tub - a great way to unwind * 3 Bedrooms PLUS a Den/Office * Formal Living Room and a Formal Dining Room * Volume Ceilings * Split Plan Design * Travertine Flooring in traffic areas * All of this wraps your OUTDOOR OASIS with a 36x12 Covered Lanai and a Caged Pool & Spa with NEWER Pool Finish, GAS Heater and Travertine Pool Deck * Almost 1 Acre * Large Corner Lot * Yard Well for Irrigation * A TRUE 3 Car Garage PLUS Additional Storage * 'A' Rated School District * Conveniently located behind the gates of Misty Creek * Run, don't walk to this INCREDIBLE HOME * This is a FABULOUS Home & Pool for entertaining friends & family or for just relaxing in your slice of paradise * Misty Creek is including 1 month FREE golf membership with the sale of this home * If you have any questions, BOTH Agents live in Misty Creek * Golf membership is NOT mandatory * Low annual HOA fees * Country feel yet minutes to Siesta Key Beach, excellent schools, shopping & dining * Rothenbach Park & New Publix shopping plaza is 5 minutes away * One look & you'll fall in love! *

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Ryan Brown (941-330-7774)

Remarks: Don't let this one get away! * This EXECUTIVE HOME FEATURES PANORAMIC VIEWS OF A SPRING-FED LAKE WITH 217 FRONTAGE ON THE LAKE * A VERY PRIVATE SETTING ON OVER 1/2 ACRE * Stunning Sunrises & Sunsets from your OVERSIZED COVERED LANAI * IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR A QUALITY HOME WITH NOTHING FOR YOU TO DO BUT MOVE IN, THIS IS THE HOME FOR YOU! * NEW HURRICANE IMPACT RESISTANT WINDOWS & DOORS FOR PEACE OF MIND * ALSO, A WHOLE HOUSE GENERATOR with a 500 Gallon Buried Propane Tank * THE CHEF'S KITCHEN HAS BEEN LOVINGLY RENOVATED WITH CUSTOM SOLID WOOD CABINETS, QUARTZ COUNTERTOP, AND A CENTER ISLAND THAT IS THE HEART OF THE HOME, PERFECT FOR ENTERTAINING FAMILIY & FRIENDS * The Kitchen is open to the Great Room featuring Volume Ceiling and 8ft Sliding Glass Doors leading to your outdoor oasis * HEATED SALTWATER POOL + SPA * The NEW PANORAMIC POOL CAGE is perfect for watching the birds, turtles & fish * 3 Bedrooms + a SEPARATE DEN/OFFICE and a Formal Dining Room * The Primary Suite is SPACIOUS with Dual Walk-in Closets * Relax in your THOUGHTFULLY REIMAGINED & NEWLY DESIGNED SPA-STYLE BATH * A few of the recent improvements are NEWER TILE ROOF 2021; NEWER A/C; NEW TILE FLOORS; CUSTOM LIGHTING & FANS and NEW PLUMBING FIXTURES * PAVER DRIVEWAY * 3 CAR GARAGE * CUSTOM LANDSCAPING BY TROYER'S LANDSCAPE DESIGN with EXTENSIVE NIGHT LIGHTING * Private well for irrigation * 'A' Rated School District * Conveniently located behind the gates of Misty Creek * Run, don't walk to this INCREDIBLE HOME * This is a FABULOUS Home & Pool for entertaining friends & family or for just relaxing in your slice of paradise * Misty Creek is including 1 month FREE golf membership with the sale of this home * If you have any questions, BOTH Agents live in Misty Creek * Golf membership is NOT mandatory * Low annual HOA fees & NO CDD FEES * Country feel yet minutes to Siesta Key Beach, excellent schools, shopping & dining * Rothenbach Park & New Publix shopping plaza is 5 minutes away * One look & you'll fall in love! *

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Ryan Brown (941-330-7774)

Remarks: This is the one * Location, location, location * This EXQUISITE EXECUTIVE HOME features PANORAMIC VIEWS of a VERY LARGE LAKE with GOLF COURSE IN THE DISTANCE * These are MUST SEE VIEWS * No homes behind you! Very private setting on almost 1/2 acre * 3 Bedrooms & 2.5 Baths * PLUS Den/Office * NEW A/C JUST INSTALLED MAY 2026 * LARGE THOUGHTFULLY REMODELED Chef's Kitchen with granite counter-tops opens to Breakfast Nook & Family Room featuring a Fireplace * Formal Dining Room * Formal Living Room * RENOVATED BATHROOMS * Master Suite boasts Sitting Area, dual sinks, tub & separate walk-in shower * Split plan design * Volume ceilings * Crown molding * GORGEOUS Travertine Pool Deck * Pool & Spa * BIG Covered Lanai * Paver brick driveway * Home is ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing in your slice of paradise * Side load 2 car Garage & golf cart garage * Gated community * Misty Creek is including 1 month FREE golf membership with the sale of this home * If you have any questions, Listing Agent lives in Misty Creek * Golf membership is NOT mandatory * Low annual HOA fees * Country feel yet minutes to Siesta Key Beach, excellent schools, shopping & dining * Rothenbach Park & New Publix shopping plaza is 5 minutes away * One look & you'll fall in love! *

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Ryan Brown (941-330-7774)

Remarks: Don't let this one get away! * Location, location, location * A-RATED SCHOOL DISTRICT * This EXECUTIVE FAMILY HOME BOASTS A VERY PRIVATE SETTING BACKING TO A 62 ACRE PRESERVE - no neighbor to the rear! * PREMIUM ESTATE-SIZED Lot is almost 1/2 Acre * It's a special opportunity to live in the sought after GATED NEIGHBORHOOD of MISTY CREEK * ROOF 2015 * NEW A/C 2019 * ALMOST ALL APPLIANCES ARE 2 YEARS OLD * Volume ceilings * Split plan design * Spacious Primary Suite with a Spa-style Bath featuring a walk-in shower, tub & dual sinks * Formal Living Room & Formal Dining Room * Chef's Kitchen with granite counter-tops is open to the Family Room with a GAS Fireplace * A great home for entertaining or simply relaxing in your slice of paradise * CUSTOM POOL & SPA * OVERSIZED COVERED LANAI * VERY PRIVATE SETTING * Custom landscaping * Yard irrigation with private yard well * Gated neighborhood with 24/7 security * Misty Creek Country Club is including 1 month free golf membership with the sale of this home * Membership to Golf & Country Club is NOT mandatory * LOW HOA FEES! * Country feel yet 5 minutes to the NEW Publix shopping plaza & Rothenbach Park * Short 15 minute drive to Siesta Key Beach or UTC Mall * A-RATED SCHOOL DISTRICT * One look & you'll fall in love!

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Ryan Brown (941-330-7774)

Remarks: ONE OF A KIND PRIVATE SETTING & HOME * NEW ROOF 2023 * THIS 3861+-SQFT EXECUTIVE HOME FEATURES PANORAMIC VIEWS of a VERY LARGE LAKE with INCREDIBLE SUNSETS * PREMIUM ESTATE-SIZED LOT IS OVER 3/4 ACRE * A TRUE 4 BEDROOM + a SEPARATE DEN/OFFICE * 3.5 BATHS * Family Room & Living Room * This LARGE HOME is a special opportunity behind in the sought after GATED NEIGHBORHOOD of Misty Creek * Volume Ceilings * 8ft Sliding Glass Doors * 3 Car Side-load Garage * All this wraps your OUTDOOR LIVING with CAGED SALTWATER POOL & SPA and an expansive Covered Lanai * This is a FABULOUS POOL HOME, perfect for entertaining or simply relaxing in your slice of paradise * Yard Well for irrigation * Beautiful views! * Gated community with 24/7 security * Misty Creek is including 1 month FREE golf membership with the sale of this home * If you have any questions, Listing Agents live in Misty Creek * Golf membership is NOT mandatory * Low annual HOA fees * Country feel yet minutes to Siesta Key Beach, excellent schools, shopping & dining * Rothenbach Park & New Publix shopping plaza is 5 minutes away * 'A' RATED SCHOOL DISTRICT * One look & you'll fall in love! *

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Glenn Brown (941-342-6464)

Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac behind the gates of Misty Creek, this beautifully designed four-bedroom home offers stunning views of the 18th hole and lake from one of the community’s most desirable settings. A paver brick driveway and impressive curb appeal welcome you to this exceptional property. With the primary suite and private office on the first floor, and three additional bedrooms plus a large bonus room upstairs, the layout offers both comfort and flexibility. A grand entry with soaring cathedral ceilings opens to elegant living spaces featuring a fireplace with mantel, decorative built-in shelving, and sliding glass doors overlooking the lanai, pool, golf course, and water. Designed for entertaining, the kitchen features granite countertops, built-in double ovens, dual sinks, abundant cabinetry, a walk-in pantry, an expansive breakfast bar, and additional dining space — all overlooking the golf course and lake. Pocket sliding glass doors seamlessly extend the kitchen and living areas onto the expansive paver lanai, creating effortless indoor-outdoor living. The outdoor kitchen and bar, heated pool and spa, and pool bath make this home ideal for entertaining or relaxing in a private resort-style setting. A dumbwaiter provides convenient access from the kitchen to the upstairs bonus room. The spacious first-floor primary suite features private lanai access and a luxurious bath with a soaking tub, dual-head shower, separate vanities, water closet, linen closet, and dual walk-in closets with custom organizers. Upstairs includes a Jack-and-Jill suite with hardwood flooring, an additional bedroom, and a large bonus room complete with a wet bar, refrigerator, abundant cabinetry, washer and dryer, storage closet with shelving, and sliding glass doors leading to a private balcony with sweeping views of the golf course, lake, and the natural beauty of Misty Creek, where deer and native birds are often seen from this peaceful vantage point. The versatile bonus room offers endless possibilities and would make an ideal in-law suite, playroom, home gym, media room, or private guest retreat. Designed with exceptional storage throughout, the home offers large closets, custom built-ins, a walk-in pantry, and additional storage areas. The spacious first-floor laundry room includes abundant cabinetry, folding counter space, and a stand-up deep freezer. Additional features include a spacious side-load 3-car garage with EV charging capability, a three-zone HVAC system for enhanced comfort and efficiency, and a newer tile roof.

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Samantha Callaway (630-865-3189)

Remarks: Welcome to the Preserve at Misty Creek Subdivision, a gated community. This is a Custom Built Home by Canon Builders. It features... split plan, 4 Bedrooms (Large master suite)...3 Bathrooms (newly renovated)... Island Kitchen with granite countertops and bar-top seating... Family Room...Living Room...Dining Room...Breakfast Nook Area...Large Office...Laundry Room...Pool/Spa with Travertine deck...spacious 3 Car Garage. This home backs up to a beautiful water view of Misty Creek with a large Oak tree shading the back yard. Other upgrades include new tile and wood floors throughout along with a recently replaced tile roof. MISTY CREEK is an upscale subdivision and golf community. Golf membership is not required. Low HOA fees. A fabulous location. Best school system. A very relaxing and desirable community. Just a short distance to the famous Siesta Key Beaches and only a few minutes from shopping and restaurants. This home is available immediately and owners motivated to sell since they have already moved to another location. MORE FACTS: Properties in Misty Creek fall under the highly rated Sarasota County School District, which consistently maintains a top-tier "A" rating overall from the Florida Department of Education. The Bus Stop is one block away from this house. A Publix shopping plaza is less than a mile from the subdivision. Rothenbach Park is just a mile away which includes: Bicycling · Grills · Outdoor Fitness Equipment · Picnic Shelter / Pavilion · Playground · Restroom · Paved Walking Trail. Misty Creek is a wildlife preserve with beautiful deer, birds and even bunnies throughout. The irrigation system works off of a well, keeping your water bills low. This home has City water and sewerage.

Listing is courtesy of: BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC (804-656-5007)

Listing Agent: Steven Koleno (804-656-5007)

Remarks: LAKE VIEWS! 4BR/3BA + Living room & dining room, huge family room. Kitchen with island. 3 car garage. Whole house water softener. Pool & deck area w/ 2 lanais. FSBO Fully Furnished..

Listing is courtesy of: JACK KELLER INC (727-586-1497)

Listing Agent: John Keller, Iii (727-586-1497)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Tucked away at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, across from dedicated preserve land and within the gates of The Preserve at Misty Creek, 8311 Flagstaff Way offers a rare blend of relaxed Florida living and near proximity to all Sarasota has to offer. Set on nearly half an acre of beautifully landscaped, lakefront property, this residence feels like a retreat—where mornings begin with tranquil water views and evenings unfold under the soft glow of your own outdoor fire pit. Spanning nearly 2,900 square feet, this single-story home has been carefully improved and maintained over the years, creating a move-in-ready experience with both style and substance. Inside, volume ceilings, crown molding, and an abundance of natural light create a warm and open atmosphere. The kitchen and family room flow seamlessly together, anchored by a fully remodeled kitchen featuring solid wood cabinetry, stone counters, updated lighting, and stainless-steel appliances including a wine refrigerator. The home has seen extensive interior enhancements, including updated flooring, bedroom carpeting, interior painting, and refined finishes throughout. Both the kitchen and bathrooms have been tastefully remodeled, increasing the value of the home. Major systems and functional upgrades provide peace of mind. The property features NEW TILE ROOF 2024, two newer air conditioning systems, updated electronic heat assembly, and a variety of mechanical improvements that reflect careful ownership. Additional updates include refrigerator, garbage disposal, washing machine and dishwasher, along with improvements to lighting both within the home as well as outdoors. Hurricane resistant PGT windows ensure peace of mind. Step outside and the lifestyle truly comes to life. The screened, heated pool and spa overlook the lake, framed by updated and sealed pool pavers and a refreshed enclosure. A newer pool heater, motor, and actuator ensure everything operates seamlessly. The outdoor living space has been expanded with a custom patio and fire pit area for entertaining or simply unwinding. The grounds have been thoughtfully maintained and enhanced, including irrigation system updates and landscape improvements, to maximize both usability and aesthetics. Additional exterior improvements include garage upgrades with new door components and opener. Located in an X flood zone and built with solid block construction, the home combines durability with comfort. The side-entry garage includes a workshop space, adding functionality for hobbies or storage. Living in Misty Creek means enjoying a 24-hour guard-gated community with LOW HOA fees, SPACIOUS LOTS, and OPTIONAL golf membership. Sidewalk-lined streets for walking and cycling, a peaceful animal preserve setting, and access to fishing and bird watching create a lifestyle that is simultaneously active and serene. Luxury of top-rated schools, including The Classical Academy, are nearby. With just a short drive to the pearlized quartz sand of Siesta Key Beach, a multitude of dining options, and cultural amenities including theater, galleries, ballet, opera, circus and live music, this home offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience. 8311 Flagstaff Way is more than just a home—it’s a property that has been continually improved, carefully cared for, and thoughtfully elevated to offer its next owner a truly effortless Florida lifestyle. Listing agent resides in this phenomenal community!

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-366-8070)

Listing Agent: Lynne Zettergren (860-384-3132)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. OVERSIZED LAKE LOT with gorgeous views!! This spectacular 4 bedroom, 3 bath Misty Creek home is waiting for you! This luxurious pool home is situated in a wonderful golf course community with fantastic views of a serene lake. Mature landscaping greets you as you walk up the impressive facade of this also 1/2 acre property. Many wonderful updates include 2025 ROOF, gutters, downspouts, HVAC replaced in 2022 which has a transferrable warranty and UV light, Bosch refrigerator is a few months old, dishwasher 3 years old, some 2025 interior painting, NEW laminate flooring, carpet, NEW 2025 pool cage with a huge panorama screen and pool pump 2025. As you walk in the front doors, you are greeted with impressively high ceilings of the living area and full VIEW of the pool and LONG RANGE LAKE through the panorama view screen. The tastefully done interior is pure elegance. To your left is the formal dining area where you are sure to have lots of memories with friends and family as you entertain them in your beautiful house. On through the Chef’s kitchen, you are greeted with sleek stainless steel appliances and plenty of countertops and cabinetry where you are sure to hone your skills as a Masterchef! This is the heart of your home that features an informal dining area as well as the main living area which overlooks the scenic pool and lake. The master bedroom overlooks the wonderful view of the pool and lake. The master bedroom will not disappoint with it’s high ceilings, carpet flooring and large walk-in closet. The master bathroom  has ceramic tile flooring, a fantastic bath, a walk-in shower, his and hers vanity sink, linen closet and separate water closet. The secondary bedrooms are perfect for your loved ones with a den that can be converted to a fifth bedroom as well or a mother in law suite or gameroom.  This new fully screened extended lanai with a private pool and spa allows you to relax your stresses away and also has new pavers. Take a splash in your pool and create beautiful memories with friends and family as you all enjoy the stunning lake view. There are some electric hurricane shutters on this home as well as a whole house backup GENERATOR which was replaced in 2022 that also has a buried gas tank that conveys with the property. Plenty of parking with a 3 car garage and larger driveway.   You do not have to be a member of the golf club to enjoy living in this beautiful home on this oversized lake lot.  Great location and close to everything Sarasota has to offer including Siesta Key beach, shopping, restaurants and more.

Listing is courtesy of: GULF SANDS REALTY, LLC (941-343-7275)

Listing Agent: Cynthia Brock (941-400-6237)

Remarks: Welcome to this bright and beautifully updated home in a private guard-gated Golf community in Sarasota. Featuring three bedrooms, plus an office/den, two bathrooms, a full size laundry room, and a spacious three car garage, this residence offers comfort, style, and privacy. Step inside to soaring high ceilings and an open, light-filled layout designed for effortless living and entertaining. The custom chef's kitchen is the centerpiece of the home, showcasing elegant quartz countertops with plenty of space for cooking and gathering. KitchenAid appliances including two convection ovens, induction cooktop, professional series full size refrigerator and freezer and so much more. Throughout this split-plan home you'll find luxury vinyl flooring, combining durability with a sleek, contemporary look. Large windows and sliding doors invite natural light while offering partial lake views and a peaceful setting. Enjoy the Florida lifestyle outdoors with your private pool perfect for relaxing or entertaining in a tranquil, secluded backyard. Located within a secure guard-gated neighborhood, this home provides both privacy and convenience, with easy access to Sarasota's beaches, dining, shopping and Rothenbach Park.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-383-6411)

Listing Agent: Fernanda Girard (941-504-4327)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Quality Built by ARTHUR RUTENBERG HOMES * Very private setting on almost 1/2 ACRE * PANORAMIC VIEWS of VERY LARGE SPRING-FED LAKE with GOLF COURSE IN THE DISTANCE * These are MUST SEE VIEWS * No homes behind you on this PREMIER STREET IN MISTY CREEK * Large RAY ROTH KITCHEN with wood cabinets * Kitchen opens to Family Room with built-in cabinets & wet bar * 4 Bedrooms & 3.5 Baths * PLUS DEN/OFFICE * Formal Living Room & Formal Dining Room * Master Suite features walk-in shower & garden tub as well as his & her closets * Split plan design * Volume & vaulted ceilings * Beautiful Pool with NEWER Pool Cage & Screens * Big Covered Lanai is ideal for entertaining or simply relaxing in your slice of paradise * 2 car side-load Garage PLUS Full GOLF CART GARAGE * NEW ROOF IN 2016 * NEW A/C in 2016 is a 5 ton Trane * Gated community with 24/7 security * Misty Creek is including 1 month FREE golf membership with the sale of this home * If you have any questions, Listing Agent lives in Misty Creek * Golf membership is NOT mandatory * Low annual HOA fees * Country feel yet minutes to Siesta Key Beach, excellent schools, shopping & dining * Rothenbach Park & New Publix shopping plaza is 5 minutes away * One look & you'll fall in love! *

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP (941-954-5454)

Listing Agent: Ryan Brown (941-330-7774)