Beneva Oaks Single Family Homes For Sale in Sarasota - 4 homes

Remarks: Welcome to 3709 Beneva Oaks Way, an extraordinary estate nestled within the gated enclave of Beneva Oaks, where timeless elegance meets modern luxury on a private, lushly landscaped one-acre sanctuary just minutes from Sarasota’s renowned beaches, shopping, and dining. Completely reimagined in 2021 by esteemed Luxury Home Builder, Vertical l Design+Build and award Winning Interior Design Firm, Trade Mark Interiors, this impeccably curated residence features comprehensive upgrades including all-new pool equipment and heating, whole-house re-plumbing and re-wiring, advanced HVAC ducting with automated controls, a ground-level I-joist floor system, designer lighting an automated landscape lighting, new flooring, alarm system, fresh sod and landscaping, two new septic systems, and a brand-new roof in 2024 for lasting peace of mind. Celebrated for its exceptional design, the home has been featured in Martha Stewart Living, House Beautiful, and Southern Living, with award-winning kitchen, living room, and primary bath recognized by Florida Design Magazine’s Seaglass Design Awards, SRQ Magazine’s Home of the Year, and Best Overall Renovation Honors. Grand double doors open to a breathtaking interior defined by soaring ceilings, walls of glass, and an open-concept layout designed for both refined entertaining and everyday comfort. The dramatic living room showcases exquisite designer lighting and a striking marble fireplace, while the chef’s kitchen is a true showpiece with top-tier Thermador appliances, six-burner gas cooktop, double wall ovens, convection microwave, Fisher & Paykel dishwasher drawers, Bosch dishwasher, dual farmhouse sinks, pot filler, ice maker, wine refrigerator, and an oversized island with bar seating that flows seamlessly to the outdoor living areas. An expansive game room with an old-world, five-star-hotel-inspired bar sets the stage for unforgettable evenings, complemented by a stunning dining room adorned with statement lighting and elegant Japanese-inspired wallcovering. The primary suite is a private retreat with a sitting area, direct pool and spa access, and a spa-inspired bath featuring a soaking tub, walk-in shower, dual vanities, custom cabinetry, and hand-selected antique marble and limestone flooring with radiant heat. Outdoors, the resort-style pool and expansive entertaining areas create a serene oasis for alfresco dining and relaxation, while four generous guest suites with walk-in closets and full bath access providing exceptional comfort. Completing the estate is an oversized three-car garage with workshop, abundant storage, and the ultimate man cave—making this remarkable residence a rare offering that embodies impeccable design, craftsmanship, and elevated living.

Listing is courtesy of: SARASOTA TRUST REALTY COMPANY (941-366-1619)

Listing Agent: Renee Preininger (941-400-4235)

Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. In the gated, exclusive community of Beneva Oaks, this two-story residence is a Sarasota gem that offers a rare combination of privacy, space and convenience. One of Sarasota’s sought-after neighborhoods, Beneva Oaks is an enclave of just 49 uniquely designed custom homes, each on spacious half-acre to one-acre homesites, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, safety and prestige. With majestic 100-year-old oaks and towering palms, this community is one of Sarasota’s hidden treasures, offering an abundance of space and a park-like setting while being just minutes from the heart of town. On the northern edge of Palmer Ranch, this home provides easy access to Interstate 75, Siesta Key Beach, Gulf Gate’s vibrant restaurant and shopping district, and a new Publix. A great place for a growing family, it also sits in the highly rated school districts of Gulf Gate Elementary, Sarasota Middle School, and Riverview High School, and the top high school in Florida, Pine View School for the Gifted, is 15 minutes away. Inside, the first floor offers a spacious living room, kitchen, dining area and half bath. The attached office and bedroom with adjacent full pool bath are ideal for use as an in-law or au pair suite. Upstairs, the expansive primary bedroom boasts a sitting area, walk-in shower, soaking tub and dual pedestal sinks, creating a serene retreat. Three additional guest bedrooms and a full bath complete the second level. The outdoor living space is a private oasis as French doors lead to an elevated deck with new railings illuminated by solar lights, stepping down to a sparkling blue pool surrounded by pavers. The backyard enjoys scenic, serene views, backing up to Matheny Creek and a green space easement for added privacy. Energy efficiency meets sustainability with environmentally friendly solar panels, keeping electric costs low. County water and septic ensure predictable utility expenses, and a buried 120-gallon propane tank fuels the gas stove. Additional features include a speaker system, fiber-optic high-speed internet, original Spanish tile and luxury vinyl plank flooring, and charming stained-glass accents in the front entry and stairwell. This is a rare opportunity to own in one of Sarasota’s distinguished neighborhoods, where estate-sized properties, lush landscapes and an unbeatable location create a special place to call home. Zillow flood information is incorrect, and per FEMA and the Sarasota GIS flood maps no buildings intersect flood zones. Flood insurance is NOT required. The structure is entirely within zone X, with a finished floor elevation of 23 feet. The edge of the lot bordering the creek is in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 16.4 feet.

Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY (941-364-4000)

Listing Agent: Katy Mcbrayer (941-400-2406)

Remarks: This home truly has it all - space, privacy, layout made for everyday living and entertaining! This is a rare opportunity to own a private, estate-sized home on over an acre in Sarasota—quietly tucked inside the gated community of Beneva Oaks at the end of a cul-de-sac. Set back from the road and surrounded by towering oak trees, the property offers a sense of peace, space, and privacy that makes it easy to feel at home the moment you arrive. Built in 1980 by a professional builder for his own family, the home was intentionally created to fully enjoy the beauty, shade, and tranquility of the property—something that can be felt throughout the home. With more than 5,200 square feet of living space, the interior offers a versatile layout designed to bring people together while still allowing room to spread out. A welcoming foyer with a graceful spiral staircase sets the tone, opening to multiple living areas ideal for hosting holidays, celebrating milestones, or enjoying everyday moments with family. The formal dining room provides a beautiful setting for special gatherings, while the eat-in kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring double ovens, a separate Sub-Zero refrigerator and freezer, and views of the lush backyard. The main-level primary suite offers a peaceful retreat, complete with a sitting area and a renovated spa-style bathroom with a freestanding soaking tub and custom walk-in shower. A first-floor office with custom built-ins and surround sound adds flexibility for working from home or creative use. Upstairs, four additional bedrooms, two full baths, and a flexible bonus space provide extra room for guests or hobbies. Three bedrooms open onto a screened balcony, while an additional open balcony invites quiet moments to unwind and take in the surrounding greenery. Outdoor living is an extension of the home itself, with a screened lanai, resurfaced saltwater pool, Trex decking, and paver walkways creating a setting for both entertaining and everyday relaxation. The backyard is bordered by city-owned green space beyond the rear wall, enhancing privacy and reinforcing the feeling of a natural retreat. Thoughtful updates throughout include new flooring, renovated bathrooms, four zoned air-conditioning systems, tankless water heaters, updated irrigation with a private well, a replaced septic system, a newer roof, and maintained fencing. A circular driveway and three-car side-entry garage completes the property Thoughtfully designed, surrounded by nature, and brimming with comfort…your new home awaits!

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-383-6411)

Listing Agent: Ryan Skrzypkowski (941-328-8307)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Tucked within the prestigious, gated enclave of Beneva Oaks, where centuries-old live oaks line meandering streets, this masterfully renovated home on a ½ acre lot offers incredible 2025 updates and a wonderful 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath, 1-story floor plan providing both grandeur and comfort across the expansive space. A circular drive framed by lush landscaping leads to the elegant entry of this modern residence, where refined upgrades blend seamlessly with timeless architectural features. Inside, travertine floors flow through the main living areas, while new designer carpet enhances the comfort of the bedrooms. The heart of the home is the extraordinary new eat-in kitchen featuring gleaming quartz countertops, crisp white wood cabinetry, stainless appliances including an induction cooktop, wide plank porcelain tile floor, and a custom tile backsplash. Accents like gold hardware, designer lighting, crown molding, and wide baseboards add the feel of luxury, while four sets of French doors connect the interior seamlessly with the lush exterior surroundings. An elegant dual-sided wood-burning fireplace with brick and tile surround and quartz and travertine hearths anchors the living and sitting areas, creating inviting spaces for conversation or quiet moments. With multiple entertaining areas designed for both intimate gatherings, grand-scale events or even a game of pool, the home's layout flows effortlessly from indoors to the screened lanai with paver deck, where a heated pool enhanced by Iconic Pools with sparkling new glass tile surface invites year-round enjoyment. The spacious primary suite, is a sanctuary unto itself, offering three walk-in closets with custom closet systems, and an extraordinary spa-inspired bath with bespoke tile work, frameless glass shower, gold fixtures, and a quartz-topped dual-sink vanity that exudes luxury. Two additional guest bedrooms enjoy new carpet, large closets, and generous natural light, while the newly redesigned guest bath impresses with design-forward flooring, quartz dual-sink vanity, and clean, modern finishes. The 4th bedroom can also be used as in-law suite, enjoying its own private French door entry and full bath with walk-in shower. The office with a custom built-in loft, closet, and a front facing window is ideal as a workspace, study, play, or creative escape. A chic updated powder bath adds further convenience. The thoughtfully designed laundry room features quartz countertops, utility sink, abundant cabinetry, and front-load GE Whirlpool washer/dryer. The oversized 2-car garage and beautifully landscaped grounds complete this exceptional property in one of Sarasota’s most serene and sought-after neighborhoods. Located in a top rated school district, X flood zone and within close proximity to Sarasota's dining, shopping, culture, and the pristine Gulf of Mexico beaches, this exceptional property offers an unparalleled combination of design and craftsmanship in one of Sarasota’s best-kept secret neighborhoods, presenting a rare opportunity to experience refined Florida living at its finest!

Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-951-6660)

Listing Agent: Lenore Treiman (941-356-9642)