Buena Esperanza Sub Single Family Homes For Sale in St Augustine - 4 homes

Remarks: Tucked into the heart of historic Lincolnville, this thoughtfully updated cottage offers the kind of charm and walkability that make St. Augustine so special. From morning coffee on the front porch to evenings spent strolling downtown for dinner, galleries, or the waterfront, this is a home that naturally connects you to the lifestyle people come here seeking. Inside, the 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom layout was intentionally designed to make the most of its 745 square feet, creating a space that feels both functional and inviting. The flow lives comfortably, with natural light and character throughout. Recent updates and seller improvements provide added confidence and peace of mind for future owners. Features include a transferable termite bond, stainless steel crawl space enclosure, off-street paved parking with a Level II EV charger, 2021 roof and heat pump, updated water heater, new 2026 gutters, 2026 outdoor shower, and complete 2026 HVAC ductwork replacement beneath the home. For buyers looking for flexibility, the property has also performed well as a part-time short-term rental with strong guest reviews and ratings, offering the option for personal enjoyment, investment potential, or both. Back on the market following substantial recent improvements, this home offers a renewed opportunity for buyers who may have missed it the first time. Additional improvement details and transferable warranty information are available in the MLS attachments. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, weekend retreat, or investment opportunity, this home offers a move-in ready opportunity in one of St. Augustine's most beloved historic neighborhoods.

Listing is courtesy of: GREAT EXPECTATIONS REALTY (904-823-3456)

Listing Agent: Amanda Edwards (904-814-2115)

Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Saint Augustine beauty located in historic Lincolnville. Built in 2014, this home captures both the historic charm of St. Augustine and the modern conveniences of today. The elevated main house has two bedrooms upstairs. The primary bedroom has its own private access to the large upstairs balcony providing the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee. Adjacent to each bedroom is a private half bath and shared shower area. The open concept downstairs is the perfect place for entertaining. The living room has plenty of natural light with several large windows. The living area flows directly into the dining and kitchen area. Quartz counter tops, stainless steel appliances and large kitchen island makes the kitchen both functional and beautiful. This property comes with a detached garage. Above the garage is a spacious studio apartment with a full bathroom and kitchenette. Perfect for visiting guests, a home office or potential rental income. There is plenty of off street parking which will accommodate multiple vehicles. Enjoying the outdoors is easy to do from either of the two inviting and spacious porches. This property has been beautifully landscaped with maintenance free faux grass and beautiful slate pavered walkways. Conveniently located near downtown, it is an easy stroll or bike ride to experience local restaurants, art galleries, quaint shops and historic landmarks. Less than 3 miles to Anastasia State Park and the beach. This home offers the best of Florida living in the "Ancient City" of beautiful Saint Augustine!

Listing is courtesy of: THE KEYES COMPANY (386-428-5723)

Listing Agent: Debra Head (904-891-8725)

Remarks: Located in the heart of St. Augustine’s sought-after Historic Lincolnville District, this 1930 Craftsman-style residence is priced below appraised value, creating a compelling opportunity for investors, short-term rental operators, or buyers looking to secure a character-rich home with immediate built-in value. Offering a rare combination of historic character, modern livability, and investment potential, this property stands out in one of the city’s most walkable and desirable neighborhoods. Spanning 1,708 square feet, the home features three generously sized bedrooms and two full bathrooms, including a primary ensuite—an uncommon and highly desirable feature for a home of this era. Classic architectural details, a 2019 metal roof, updated 2021 windows, and an inviting covered front porch all contribute to the home’s charm, functionality, and long-term appeal. The open floor plan creates an easy flow between the main living areas and the spacious kitchen, which includes a pantry for added functionality. A separate laundry room provides everyday convenience, while the rear deck, fenced front and backyard, and mature shade trees enhance the outdoor living experience. With no HOA or CDD, the property offers flexibility and freedom, including strong short-term rental potential, subject to applicable local regulations. Just minutes from Historic Downtown St. Augustine, dining, entertainment, cultural landmarks, and local amenities, this Lincolnville home delivers authentic Old City character with modern comfort and income-producing possibilities in an exceptional location.

Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY ATLANTIC PARTNERS (ST. AUG) (904-797-7442)

Listing Agent: Frank Perez-Andreu (904-501-9896)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Welcome to this beautifully renovated Lincolnville cottage, where historic charm meets modern peace of mind. This fully furnished 2-bed, 1-bath home has been thoughtfully updated and is ready to serve as a primary residence, vacation retreat, or income-generating short-term rental. The inviting covered front porch (with gutters) sets the stage for morning coffee or evening conversation while keeping deliveries dry. Step inside to an open, light-filled living space and a chef-inspired kitchen boasting quartz countertops, soft-close cabinetry, farmhouse sink, custom pantry, and stainless-steel appliances including a French-door refrigerator, Fisher Paykel dishwasher drawer, and air-fryer range. The split bedroom layout offers privacy, while the stylish bath features granite finishes, a custom glass barn-door shower, and preserved Carrara marble flooring. Recent upgrades provide comfort and confidence: a durable metal roof with more than 27 years of life remaining, 200-amp electrical panel (2021), HVAC (2016), full plumbing re-pipe, water heater (2021), and a newly built front porch with gutters. Inside and out, every major component has been cared for. The oversized one-car garage includes laundry, water softener, and room for storage or larger vehicles. A newly built 8x12 powered shed expands the possibilities, ideal as a home office, creative studio, or guest overflow. Entertain outdoors on the back deck overlooking the spacious fenced yard with fire-pit. Zoned RS-2, this home offers flexibility for its next owner. Beyond the property, you’re immersed in the best of St. Augustine—the nation’s oldest city. Walk to historic downtown shops, restaurants, and cultural sites, or enjoy nearby parks, trails, and the community recreation center with pool, playground, and ball fields. Freedom Park, just blocks away, offers 10+ acres of green space along the San Sebastian River with picnic areas and a meditation garden. From history and culture to convenience and modern updates, this Lincolnville gem captures it all. All information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Listing is courtesy of: SIMPLY REAL ESTATE (386-677-0870)

Listing Agent: Deana Frechette (386-804-5562)