Evelyn City Homes for Sale in Tampa - 6 homes

Remarks: ucked into the sought-after Evelyn City pocket of Old Seminole Heights, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath historic bungalow is the kind of home that just feels right the moment you arrive. A quintessential front porch—complete with a porch swing—sets the tone, inviting you to slow down and stay awhile. Inside, timeless character shines with original hardwood floors, a cozy fireplace, and beautifully crafted built-in bookshelves that add both charm and function. The massive kitchen offers an unexpected amount of space for a home of this era—perfect for cooking, hosting, or simply spreading out. Step outside and you’ll find a huge backyard framed by a classic white picket fence, with not one but two private patio areas ideal for entertaining or unwinding. A newer shed adds extra storage without sacrificing style. And the location? You’re just a short stroll to neighborhood favorites like Three Coins Diner and Coasis, making it easy to enjoy the best of Seminole Heights right from your doorstep. Historic charm, great outdoor space, and a walkable lifestyle—this one checks all the boxes.

Listing is courtesy of: BRAINARD REALTY (813-922-2891)

Listing Agent: Chris Zoller (813-997-1501)

Remarks: Multi-Family/Multi-Generational Property with 3 Units! This Seminole Heights Resort style complex provides the option of providing income while at the same time providing much needed living space. Made up of 1.5 lots zoned SH-RS (Seminole Heights Residential Single Family), the Resort feel property includes 3 fully separate living spaces, a Zen Courtyard, a spacious Gazabo, generous covered outdoor Kitchen, and outdoor bathroom. Located in one of Tampa's most beloved neighborhoods, just minutes from top dining, shopping, parks, and everything the city has available! Amazingly there are FOUR tucked-away riverfront parks just a short stroll or bike ride via the Green Artery from your front door. 10-minutes from downtown Tampa! Gardens are featured throughout this property and is a rare blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and exceptional outdoor living-truly. The high-end residences are all fully ready for occupancy with updated kitchens and baths providing all appliances including washers & dryers. Each has separate accesses with programmable locks. A Zen Garden set around a brick courtyard provides views from every unit. A flagstone walkway leads to a gorgeous and inviting entertaining/dining Gazebo steps away from the amazing high end outdoor kitchen. Complete with outdoor lighting, Cat 5 Hurricane Screens, custom-made Bahama shutter, for privacy and protection. The outdoor kitchen provides ample storage for meal prep, serving and cleanup. The adjacent full bath makes it complete - an outdoor entertainment dream! The elevated front porch allows for separate entries to the two main units. Back entries are provided for each of these units a well. A rear entry downstairs unit via a large private screened sun porch leads to an updated kitchen with granite counter tops and fabulous wood cabinets, high end gas stove, pot rack overhead. A custom built light up liquor cabinet is steps away from the open living room with gleaming original wood floors and large bright windows. The large master suite provides ample room for a king-size bed, has an adjoining spacious dressing room with custom closets, large updated master bath, as well as washer and dryer. The upper 2 bedroom/2 bath unit has a rear entry for an additional private access point. In addition to the fully equipped eat-in kitchen and spacious living room, there is a generous panoramic screened porch for outdoor dining and relaxing. The 3 rd unit is a very cute 1 bedroom/1 bath apartment perfect additional occupancy with its own private entry from the garden. Includes a full kitchen and living room. From the moment you step onto the classic front porch and enter inside, the home's authenticity shines through. Original details, like original restored hardwood floors & trim, and enhanced updates, keep everything historic but modernized for today’s living. Includes a Whole Home Generator, parking lot, Porte Cochere, Tankless Hot Water Heaters, Natural Gas with 2 meters, 4 independent Electric Meters, Wired Security System (owned), 180’ Well, full Zoned Irrigation system, Water Softener. This home is a private residence and all showings are by appointment only. Call today. Pre-approval or proof of financing will be required for showings.

Listing is courtesy of: AGILE GROUP REALTY (813-569-6294)

Listing Agent: Chib Anderson (813-625-6520)

Remarks: A Rare Piece of American History: 1950s Lustron Home in Tampa This is an extraordinary opportunity to become the steward of architectural history. Welcome to Tampa’s iconic Lustron home – a favorite on the Seminole Heights Homes Tour and one of only a few remaining in Florida. These remarkable prefabricated enameled steel houses were developed in the post-World War II era by inventor Carl Strandlund’s Lustron Corporation, specifically designed for returning G.I.s. This 1950s treasure remains in pristine condition, just as stunning as the day it emerged from its shipping container and was assembled. Say goodbye to termite worries forever! This home features exterior steel panel construction, interior steel beam wall structure, and steel beam roof construction. Only the garage and addition use traditional wood framing. In Florida’s termite-prone climate, this steel construction is genius – imagine never having to worry about structural termite damage again! The original spacious 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom layout offers exceptional flow for entertaining with a large, open family room seamlessly connected to the dining area and charming pass-through window to the kitchen. The kitchen boasts a stunning oversized enameled sink, abundant cabinet storage, and dedicated space for refrigerator, washer, and dryer. You’ll even find the fascinating original heating system motor as a unique historical feature. A smart rear addition includes a convenient half-bathroom and versatile studio space. Prepare to be amazed by storage solutions – a rarity in homes of this era. Built-in storage throughout, multiple thoughtfully designed closets, and even the main bathroom features an extra-large storage cabinet. The enclosed breezeway between house and garage includes air conditioning, perfect for relaxing. The expansive yard is ideal for entertaining with endless possibilities on this huge lot. This isn’t just a home – it’s a piece of American history you can actually live in. The preservation and condition of this Lustron home is remarkable, offering the perfect blend of historical significance and modern livability. Don’t miss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a true architectural treasure that combines historical significance with practical, termite-free living in the heart of Tampa.

Listing is courtesy of: VINTAGE HOMES REALTY (813-758-7444)

Listing Agent: Michelle James (813-417-2217)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. This is easily one of the most captivating and unique homes you’ll find in Tampa—full of character, warmth, and thoughtful detail at every turn. Set on an elevated double lot in the heart of Seminole Heights, this 1920s Craftsman bungalow sits along a charming, tree-lined street with wide sidewalks and a welcoming neighborhood feel. Located in historic Evelyn City, the setting is as special as the home itself, with FOUR tucked-away riverfront parks just a short stroll or bike ride from your front door. From the moment you step onto the classic front porch and enter inside, the home’s authenticity shines through. Original details like rich restored hardwood floors, wood-paneled doors, glass and brass hardware, and detailed trim create a timeless foundation, while carefully selected updates keep everything feeling fresh and functional. The kitchen is both beautiful and practical, featuring warm wood cabinetry with beadboard accents, stone countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a standout gas range with double dishwashers—perfectly blending style with everyday usability. The layout offers two light-filled secondary bedrooms, a charming vintage-style guest bath, and a private primary suite complete with a cozy sitting area, access to a screened porch and garden, and a spa-like bath with dual vanities and a steam shower. Step outside and the property truly transforms into a private retreat. The backyard is lush and immersive, surrounded by mature bamboo and tropical landscaping that creates a peaceful, secluded atmosphere. The pool has been completely redone and now serves as a stunning focal point, featuring a freeform design with a heated spillover spa, natural stone decking, and a serene, resort-like feel. A dining gazebo and multiple lounging areas make it perfect for entertaining, while a dedicated astroturf dog run adds everyday convenience. Additional features include a garage/workshop, a convenient pool bath, ample off-street parking, and a whole-house generator for peace of mind, along with the added benefit of a newer roof. Rounding out the property is a detached two-bedroom, one-bath apartment with its own washer and dryer—ideal for guests, rental income, or a private workspace. This home is a rare blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and exceptional outdoor living—truly a standout property in one of Tampa’s most beloved neighborhoods, just minutes from top dining, shopping, parks, and everything the city has available!

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX COLLECTIVE (813-438-7841)

Listing Agent: Steven Burk (813-816-5388)

Remarks: Ready to sell! Northeast Seminole Heights bungalow showcasing historic charm with updated features and modern comforts throughout… covered front entryway introduces the main living room with gleaming hardwoods, high ceilings and enhanced trim / crown molding; it connects to a dinette with great natural light as well. The eat-in kitchen is just beyond with 42” cabinets, stone counters and a butcher block center island. Front guestroom is currently being used as an office and is next to the second bedroom; both offer good closet space and utilize the hall bath with tub and stone tilework. The owner’s suite is off the back wing with en suite bath, an oversized shower and 5x13’ walk-in closet with cedar flooring. The back yard is fully fenced and its garden oasis elicits a nostalgic peace – customize as desired for entertaining others or yourself… Roof replaced in 2025, HVAC in 2023, plumbing / electric updated in 2012. Enjoy walkability plus quick access to local hotspots like Coasis, Three Coins Diner, Mekenita Cantina, Rooster & The Till, The C House, Trophy Fish, Front Porch & Bart’s Tavern, the Seminole Heights General Store, Nori Nori Craft Handrolls & Wicked Oak BBQ to name a few… ten minutes to Downtown Tampa too! Enjoy your own piece of timeless history.

Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS TAMPA CENTRAL (813-865-0700)

Listing Agent: Amy Greenfield (813-777-6104)

Remarks: Welcome to the timeless charm of this beautiful 2-bedroom, 2-bath Craftsman bungalow located in highly desired Old Seminole Heights. From the moment you arrive; you’re greeted with amazing curb appeal: the classic Craftsman elevation, driveway to the porte-cochère carport and large inviting screened front porch all set the stage for everything buyers love about historic Height's living. Inside, this home shines with authentic 1920s character while also having major system updates including roof, AC system, plumbing and electric offering peace of mind without sacrificing historic charm.  The gorgeous solid hardwood floors flow through the main living spaces and all 2 bedrooms. The house also showcases beautiful crown molding, historic rope-sash windows many of them with beautiful stained glass, giving an arty feeling throughout the home.  Also, built-in shelving around the brick fireplace provides the warmth and craftsmanship you’ve been looking for.   As you walk through the iconic interior columns that elegantly define the space while maintaining an open, connected flow, you enter the warm and inviting dining space with large windows that let in tons of natural light. The Master bedroom overlooks the backyard, giving a sensation of a peaceful retreat with a convenient master bath with a walk-in shower. The second bedroom is spacious with an adjacent second full bath, also with a walk-in shower.  The kitchen is bright, spacious, and functional with a farm feeling. Towards the back of the kitchen you will find the laundry area inside of the home. Step outside to a wooden deck and a backyard private retreat, complete with lush greenery, flagstone paving and used-brick pathways.  It’s the perfect space for entertaining, relaxing, and gardening. The backyard also contains a single garage size utility building that is perfect for a workshop or storage. This home provides unbeatable convenience- just minutes to Armature Works, Downtown Tampa, Channelside, Water Street, I-275, Ybor, Raymond James Stadium, Busch Gardens, and some of the best local restaurants, bars, and shops. The owner also has the next-door empty lot available for purchase in case you want to add outdoor space to your home or build additional living space. You can Check this lot in MLS TB8468862

Listing is courtesy of: MC HOMES REALTY INC (727-432-2181)

Listing Agent: Maria Herrera (727-623-5312)