Old Mill Run Sub Homes for Sale in Tavares - 3 homes

Remarks: Set on a full acre in a quiet, well-kept community where every lot is at least an acre, this one offers the kind of room and quiet that's getting harder to find this close to town. The roof is 2025. There's a new Wave water treatment system, full sprinklers, a barn-style shed, and a screened breezeway that connects the home to the garage so you're never caught in the rain hauling groceries or heading out to the car in the morning. Inside, the layout opens up around a stone fireplace and a kitchen built for people who actually cook: granite counters, an island with seating, a wall of cabinets, and a pantry that earns its keep. Vaulted ceilings keep the main living space feeling tall and bright, and wood floors run through most of the home. The primary suite has its own slider to the back, a soaking tub, separate vanities, and a walk-in closet that actually fits a wardrobe. Additional bedrooms are spread thoughtfully so guests, kids, or a home office aren't tripping over each other. Out back, a generous screened porch with three sets of sliders and ceiling fans wraps along the rear of the home. It's the kind of space where mornings start with coffee and evenings stretch long. Beyond it: open lawn, mature oaks, and a fully fenced yard with room to breathe. Down the street, the community clubhouse is a destination in itself, a stone barn with a working water wheel out front, a comfortable lounge upstairs, and a game room with ping pong and more. The kind of shared amenity that actually gets used. Then there's the location, which is the quiet flex. Tavares, America's Seaplane City, is just minutes away, with Wooton Park on Lake Dora, the seaplane base, and a downtown lined with waterfront restaurants where you can watch planes land while you eat. Mount Dora is fifteen minutes the other direction: a historic downtown with no chain restaurants allowed, more than twenty independent spots packed into a three-block stretch, antique shops, art galleries, the Lakeside Inn, and Renninger's antique center on the edge of town. Lakeshore Drive connects the two through six miles of oak-canopied lake views, a road locals bike on weekends. Combined with Eustis, these three towns form Lake County's "Golden Triangle," the heart of an area that built its identity around water, antiques, and small-town downtowns that still feel like small-town downtowns. Roof 2025. Acre lot. Quiet street. Lanai you'll live on. Two of the best small towns in Central Florida fifteen minutes apart, and you're between them. The list is short because the house speaks for itself. SELLER IS OFFERING ADDITIONAL LOT FOR SALE.

Listing is courtesy of: REAL BROKER, LLC (855-450-0442)

Listing Agent: Jessica Warman (407-619-5324)

Remarks: You don’t want to miss this beautifully maintained pool home set on a sprawling, oak-canopied acre lot in one of Tavares’ established executive communities. From the circular driveway to the mature landscaping, the setting offers privacy and presence. The oversized homesite provides space that’s increasingly hard to find, with natural shade from towering oaks and a peaceful backyard retreat. Inside, the home reflects pride of ownership throughout. The layout offers generous living areas, a cozy wood-burning fireplace, a vaulted ceiling with exposed beams in the living room, and a fully air-conditioned sunroom overlooking the pool — adding flexible living space perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or everyday enjoyment. Significant updates provide peace of mind: Roof replaced in 2019, Saltwater pool system added in 2021, New hot water heater installed in 2025. The screened pool area is designed for true Florida living, with an oversized deck and plenty of room to entertain or unwind in a private setting. Located just minutes from downtown Tavares and convenient to Mount Dora and major roadways, this home offers the balance of privacy, functionality, and accessibility that buyers are looking for. If you’ve been searching for a well-maintained home with solid updates, space to breathe, and true Florida character — this is one you don’t want to miss. Even better — the seller will consider including the golf cart, generator, and garage freezer with an acceptable offer, adding additional value and convenience for the next owner. Now at an improved price, schedule your showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER VANGUARD EDGE (800-948-0938)

Listing Agent: James Armstrong, Iii (800-948-0938)

Remarks: Welcome to this meticulously maintained estate, where grand-scale architectural lines and soaring vaulted ceilings create an authentic foundation for flexible, modern living. The opportunities here for multigenerational living and the creation of fully contained areas shout from the two wings that lead from the two storey great room. This home boasts oversized rooms and versatile living space that provide the scale and flexibility required for multiple generations to coexist comfortably. Timeless elements; wood, brickwork, tile and natural stone, add warmth and soul to this classic home. Nestled within mature trees on over 2.5 acres; this corner lot home provides exceptional privacy while still included in the beautiful community of Old Mill Run. Currently presented as 5 large bedrooms; 4.5 bath plus gym, office, dining, great room, huge open plan kitchen and additional living area. The sellers have maintained this home with care and continual investment including new water heater (Jan 2026), Roof (2017), full new kitchen, fitted with soft close cabinetry and black stainless steel appliances and a walk-in pantry and electrical panel (2021), HVAC (2021). Water Well & pump (2024). The septic system is a double size and was last serviced in 2023. The home boasts an in-ground pool with waterfall and a new, non slip deck and pump / heater. The deck provides ample space for entertaining and valuable shade for evening dining. Sellers have invested in refinished pathways and epoxy garage floors. The oversize triple garage provides ample space for workshop, storage and vehicles and a 220 hook-up for car charging. The storage within the home is extensive with very large laundry room; with hook-up for washer, space for dryer and large amounts of cabinetry and a laundry sink. The exterior has sweeping grounds with mature trees; which are lit and beautifully maintained. There is a fenced garden area beyond the pool screen and a brick fire pit for those cooler Florida evenings.

Listing is courtesy of: OLYMPUS EXECUTIVE REALTY INC (407-469-0090)

Listing Agent: Tanya Pannett (352-216-5704)