Location: Sarasota , 34242
Do Not Show Listings
5322 CALLE DE LA SIESTA, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$4,900,000128 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4682172
Bed: 9 Bath: 0.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 4437 Built: 1999 Tax: $22,056 (2025)Community: Sarasota BeachSpa: YesMulti-Family 5+
Market Analysis: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Nearby Properties: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Taxes:$22,056
Elementary School: None
High School: None
Tax Year: 2025
Middle School: None
Remarks: 5.9% Seller Financing and Nightly rentals, a unicorn. This 7-unit investment property is unique in that it operates more similar to hotel than a single family vacation rental. It has years of returning guests and it's one of very few elevated properties allowing the former mentioned, nightly rentals. 2-studios, 2-1 bedrooms, 2-2 bedrooms, and a penthouse suite with wrap around balcony. Your guests will enjoy a great pool area, sizable covered space with a grill, on site laundry, and a roof top deck. It's 1 block to both the Village and beach, guests walk everywhere. Park your car in one of the 7 newly pavered spaces and don't start it again until the vacation is over. Now for you the owner, a private office/guest check in, 2 storage areas for linens housewares etc, and a commercial laundry for turnovers. These types never trade, don't let another 20 years pass before this sells again.
Listing is courtesy of: COMPASS FLORIDA LLC (941-279-3630)
Listing Agent: Jason Skowronski (941-812-6090)
5169 OXFORD DR, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,498,80063 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: V4948468
3 Days Off yellowkey (back on 6/8/2026)
Bed: 3 Bath: 3.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1658 Built: 1994 Tax: $15,228 (2024)Community: Siesta BeachSpa: NoSingle Family
Taxes:$15,228
Tax Year: 2024
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. WATERFRONT PARADISE!! Welcome to 5169 Oxford Drive, where this elevated, turnkey-furnished home is perfectly positioned on a stunning canal, offering the ideal opportunity for personal enjoyment or rental income. This beautifully maintained property features 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, along with quick access to open water, making it a dream for boating enthusiasts. Start your mornings with a relaxing cup of coffee or tea in your backyard oasis by the private swimming pool. As the day unfolds, gather with family and friends in the warm, inviting living room while enjoying tranquil canal views. The open-concept layout is designed for effortless living, seamlessly connecting to a chef-inspired kitchen just steps away. Upstairs, you’ll find a spacious bedroom and full bathroom, perfect for guests or added privacy. Downstairs features two en-suite bedrooms, providing comfort and convenience for everyone. Step outside to your own private retreat—ideal for entertaining or unwinding. Spend evenings by the pool, fire up the barbecue, or fish right from your private dock and pier. For adventure, grab your paddleboard and head straight out to the Gulf from your backyard. This home showcases exceptional features and thoughtful upgrades throughout, including: • Durable steel roof • Updated flooring • Indoor laundry • Outdoor grilling area • Private swimming pool • Boat slip • Private fishing pier Located just moments from Siesta Beach, you can easily hop on your golf cart or enjoy a scenic walk to one of Florida’s most beautiful shorelines. This is more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle. Seller is offering a one-year home warranty with a full-price contract. Schedule your private showing today and experience this exceptional property and neighborhood firsthand.
Listing is courtesy of: THE C SMITH REAL ESTATE GROUP LLC (407-705-7797)
Listing Agent: John Chalkias (614-284-2560)
1255 E PEPPERTREE DR #201, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$499,000313 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4661191
2 Days Off yellowkey (back on 6/8/2026)
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1460 Built: 1972 Tax: $5,890 (2024)Community: Peppertree Bay ISpa: NoCondo
Taxes:$5,890
Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
High School: Sarasota High
Middle School: Brookside Middle
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Move in ready AND priced to sell quickly! Don't miss the chance to own this beautifully updated turnkey furnished 2-bedroom condo at Peppertree Bay, available at an unbeatable price! Experience resort-style living in this bayfront and beachside community. The interior boasts an open floor plan with spacious, welcoming rooms, tile and luxury vinyl plank flooring, and a generous 29-foot lanai. Peppertree Bay offers luxurious amenities, including under building parking, private beach access, two heated swimming pools, tennis and pickleball courts, two clubhouses, a fitness center, and a fishing pier. It’s like a vacation every day! When you want a change of pace, leave your car behind and take the trolley to all the wonderful restaurants and shopping Siesta Key has to offer. With onsite management and a rental desk, this Peppertree Bay condo serves as an ideal coastal getaway or a smart investment choice. Don’t let this one get away.
Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-349-3444)
Listing Agent: Mina Johnson (941-404-9347)
144 GARDEN LN, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$815,00082 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4687753
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 6/7/2026)
REDUCED by $60,000 (6.9%) on 04/30/2026
Bed: 4 Bath: 2.5 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1702 Built: 1956 Tax: $11,003 (2025)Community: Siesta Rev OfSingle Family
Taxes:$11,003
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Exceptional opportunity on the highly sought-after North end of Siesta Key, just steps from Shell Beach. This property offers a prime location less than a block to the Gulf, with convenient access on and off the island via the North bridge. Located only 3 miles to Siesta Key’s world-renowned Main Beach, and under 15 minutes to the vibrant dining, shopping, and cultural scene of downtown Sarasota. The existing structure sustained significant hurricane damage and has been remediated, presenting a unique opportunity for a full renovation or redevelopment. Due to current FEMA guidelines, the property is best suited for a comprehensive remodel bringing the home up to current code, or as a teardown to maximize the full potential of the lot. Zoned RSF2 with weekly rentals permitted, this property is ideal for those looking to create a luxury coastal retreat, a high-performing income-producing vacation rental, or both. The unbeatable location places you in the heart of Siesta Key’s laid-back yet vibrant beach lifestyle, surrounded by world-class beaches, boating, dining, and entertainment. Whether you envision building your dream home or capitalizing on strong rental demand, this is a rare chance to secure a premier lot in one of Sarasota’s most desirable coastal neighborhoods.
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)
Listing Agent: Shane O'Neill (949-230-2616)
6005 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #S6, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$889,00065 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4690166
REDUCED by $31,000 (3.4%) on 05/04/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1672 Built: 1966 Tax: $8,727 (2025)Community: Provincial GardensVilla
Taxes:$8,727
Remarks: Make this beautifully decorated and extensively updated, maintenance-free, open floor plan, free-standing villa your very own piece of paradise. Offering two spacious bedrooms and bathrooms, a flex (den) space, a full size washer and dryer, and your very own lush private patio oasis, all designed with comfort and style in mind. Can be sold with most of the furniture if desired. No need to compromise between bay or beach access, with deeded access steps away from your Siesta Key retreat. Added peace of mind comes from no flooding or storm damage sustained from past storms, with the community located on one of the higher elevation points on the Key. Some of the many updates include an extensive renovation to replace the old 1960s cast iron drain lines under the property’s slab with all-new PVC lines. Once completed, designer selected wood look tile flooring was added throughout the majority of the home. This intrusive, time-consuming, and costly project has already been completed, putting a new owner at ease regarding future concerns and major costs. The roof and A/C are new as of 2025. The primary bathroom has been completely updated, along with new hardscaping and landscaping. Handpicked light fixtures and ceiling fans have been installed, along with brand new solid core doors throughout the home to reduce noise from room to room. New coastal colors and tones have been added to the interior, along with wider doorways and all new appliances within the past two years. The residence invites plenty of natural light into the home, with multiple windows and sliding glass doors enhancing the appeal of the split floor plan. The primary and guest suites are located on opposite sides of the villa, providing ample space and privacy for all. The kitchen features an abundance of soft closing cabinets, granite countertops, a large pantry, and stainless steel appliances. Throughout the villa, you will find plenty of built-in storage closets, crown molding, as well as both a walk-in shower (primary) and a soaking tub (guest). Open your three sliding glass doors to create a seamless extension of your living space into your private tropical sanctuary, complete with an outdoor shower. The guest suite also includes its own personal outdoor space. When you are ready to venture out and enjoy your surroundings, there is an endless list of options to keep you busy. Enjoy your morning coffee while watching the sunrise and wildlife at the community’s bay front park with a new seawall. Here, you will find a kayak launch with two storage racks specifically for your use. Head out on the water kayaking/paddle boarding among dolphins and manatees, or enjoy boating, jet skiing, or fishing for dinner. The community’s bay front park also includes a day dock for residents’ use. Ready to break a sweat or make new friends? Head to the public pickleball courts just a ten minute walk away. Prefer to take things a little slower? Choose between relaxing on the beach with the sand between your toes or reading a book by the pool, with deeded access to the beach and one of the largest heated pools on Siesta Key via Aloha Kai across the street Chairs provided at the beach and pool. Catch the free trolley to enjoy a casual lunch, happy hour, or a fine dining dinner. End your days watching the sunset over the Gulf with your drink of choice. Owners can rent their property on a monthly basis with three weekly rentals permitted a year (outside of Jan-March) and can have one small pet.
Listing is courtesy of: JASON MITCHELL REAL ESTATE FLO (754-307-0607)
Listing Agent: James Tassell, Pllc (941-726-0723)
5790 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #506, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,200,00099 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4686142
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1335 Built: 1979Monthly Fee: $1,647 Tax: $10,130 (2025)Community: Gulf & Bay Club Ph 1Condo
Taxes:$10,130
Remarks: Gulf-front views at the Gulf & Bay Club, resort living on Siesta Key! Ideally on the fifth floor of the A Building in Gulf & Bay Club, this expansive two-bedroom residence showcases sweeping Gulf views and the signature lifestyle only Siesta Key ownership provides. With 1,335 square feet of interior living space and private lanai, this property delivers coastal elegance and remarkable comfort in one of Sarasota’s loved beachfront addresses. An open floor plan with tranquil Gulf/beach views. New luxury vinyl wood flooring through main living space and comfortable carpet in both bedrooms. Designed for effortless entertaining, the open living and dining areas connect seamlessly to a stunning Gulf-facing view, ideal for sunset gatherings or quiet mornings with ocean breezes. The new updated kitchen pairs functionality with style, offering solid wood cabinetry, stone counters, a center island and all new stainless appliances. The primary suite is a private retreat, complete with walk-in closet, lanai access, and a luxurious updated en-suite bath featuring dual vanities and a large shower. The guest suite is a generously sized bedroom which provides privacy for family and visitors. An additional feature is a spacious laundry room. The Gulf & Bay Club on Siesta Key delivers unmatched amenity experience. The building boasts an array of amenities designed to elevate everyday living, including on-site management for added convenience. Two electric vehicle charging stations that are available, three large heated pools with Wi-Fi including one lap pool, 800 feet of private soft white sandy beach, six tennis courts including one Har-Tru court, six pickleball courts, basketball/racquetball/pickleball courts, shuffleboard court, organized seasonal golf for men and women, State-of-the-art fitness center, including free weights and yoga room, six dry saunas, hot tub, two clubhouses, library with books, bar, pool table and TVs. Numerous social activities during season, and the world-famous Siesta Key Beach directly on the beautiful Gulf of Mexico, featuring spectacular sunsets. This property serves as a tranquil retreat in an exceptional location whether you're seeking a permanent residence or a vacation getaway.
Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY (941-364-4000)
Listing Agent: Lisa Gullick (941-364-4000)
6204 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #205, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$775,000162 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4676979
REDUCED by $4,000 (0.5%) on 04/12/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1173 Built: 1979Monthly Fee: $1,243 Tax: $6,173 (2025)Community: Siesta Dunes BeachCondo
Taxes:$6,173
Remarks: Welcome to your slice of paradise at Siesta Dunes Beach Community. This beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath end-unit is located on the second floor and is offered turnkey furnished, making it ideal as a vacation getaway, investment property, or full-time residence. Being an end unit, the condo is filled with extra natural light and offers a charming peek-a-boo ocean view to remind you just how close you are to the beach. Enjoy peace of mind with recent upgrades, including a newer AC, newer roof, and brand-new impact windows (2025). The unit includes a covered parking space and the community provides private beach access and beach chairs, so you’re ready to enjoy the Siesta Key lifestyle from day one. With weekly rentals allowed, this property offers excellent rental potential in a highly desirable beachfront community. Whether you’re relaxing on the sand or generating income, this Siesta Dunes condo checks all the boxes for coastal living which will not disappoint.
Listing Agent: Christine Green (941-914-2463)
1350 N PORTOFINO DR #107, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$373,900301 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4662545
REDUCED by $1,000 (0.3%) on 05/17/2026
Bed: 1 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 780 Built: 1969 Tax: $2,300 (2024)Community: Siesta Harbor IiSpa: NoCondo
Taxes:$2,300
Remarks: SIESTA HARBOR...55+...BEAUTIFUL CANAL & Intercoastal Water Way VISTAS with boats slowly IDILYING By and YOU HAVE BEACH ACCESS. BRING YOUR BOAT up to 30' because it only costs $1,000 ANNUALLY to berth your boat at your home! BUT WAIT till you see this TOTALLY RENOVATED BEAUTIFUL 1 bedroom 2 full bathroom condo! NEW, NEW, NEW...everything is new...Ceramic tile flooring, baseboards, interior doors & hardware, impact windows throughout, Popcorn removed and new texture ceilings, New electric plugs and switches, new kitchen with floating cabinetry, Quartz counters, new appliances, High end and modern lighting fixtures throughout, updated bathrooms also with floating vanities, incandescent lighting mirrors, new shower, New hot water tank, HVAC is only 2 years old, etc. You have plenty of storage as the bedroom has 2 closets (one is walk in), linen closet, Hall coat closet, pantry closet AND just outside your front door is a storage room for your bikes etc.! Amenities include a beautiful pool overlooking the water, shuffleboard, rec center, pier for boat watching and gatherings, tandem boat docks, fitness center FREE laundry on 2nd, 3rd and 4th floors PLUS FOB access to the beach across the street @ Crescent Arms. ALSO you have one DESIGNATED covered carport parking spot #537 with plenty of guest parking. Outdoor grilling SPOT. Rental friendly but no pets except authentic guide dogs. PRICED BELOW MARKET AT $373,900 Please consider a pre-approval from Buddy Moore / Owner of Moore Mortgage here in Sarasota...Buddy will pay for your appraisal (a $650 value) AND get you a GREAT RATE!
Listing is courtesy of: VUE REALTY, LLC (941-269-8400)
Listing Agent: Scotty Ledford (941-400-7360)
1269 DOCKSIDE PL #115, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$825,000264 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4656792
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1217 Built: 1982 Tax: $6,667 (2024)Community: Harbour TowneSpa: YesCondo
Taxes:$6,667
Remarks: This spacious condo has easy access to Siesta Key Beach and a DEEDED 25-FOOT BOAT SLIP WITH A LIFT!! There is water and electric to the slip (#38). Yes, this is a rare opportunity to have both your boat and a nearby world-famous beach in a nicely laid out two-bedroom, two-bath turnkey furnished condo. The master bedroom has views of the harbor while the guest room has a peaceful garden view. This condo features tile flooring throughout with both HVAC and appliances that are only a couple of years old. The roof was replaced in November 2021, and the unit has a one-car garage with storage above as well as a dedicated parking space in front. In addition, this unit has one of the few private outdoor decks in the community. Harbour Towne offers fantastic amenities, including a clubhouse, heated pool, spa, and tennis/pickleball courts. Enjoy the village by day or evening for great dining, shopping and live music. A complimentary trolley runs by the complex on a regular schedule in season. This is a great place to live and play! Look no further, this is where your fun-filled life begins.
8773 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #102G, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$550,000197 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4674136
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1303 Built: 1981 Tax: $3,925 (2025)Community: Island Reef 11 Ph 1 & 2Spa: NoCondo
Taxes:$3,925
High School: Riverview High
Remarks: Welcome to Island Reef, a fantastic Beach to Bay Luxury Resort-Style Complex on South Siesta Key. This rarely available first floor condo offers it's owners the ultimate in convenience with easy parking at the front door. Step out your back glassed lanai to the pool and tennis /pickleball courts, and beautiful courtyard. This 2 bedroom/2 bathroom condo is fully furnished and has been used as a vacation home and part-time rental. There is an open floor plan with split bedrooms, a glassed lanai, kitchen dinette, inside laundry, and a pass-through kitchen to the Living and Dining area. Recent updates include luxury vinyl plank through-out, and tile floors in the lanai. New area rugs and coastal furnishings create a comfortable, easy-care setting. There is ample storage with full-wall closets in the guest bedroom, a walk-in closet in the Master Bedroom, and a linen and entry closet and large storage room off the foyer. Amenities at Island Reef are second to none. Enjoy a swim or aerobics class in a choice of 2 heated pools. The updated clubhouse can be reserved for personal use and is the site of the many social events. Other amenities include; a game room, library, fitness room, dock, beach frontage, pickleball and tennis courts, shuffleboard, kayak and bike storage and an active social program. There is an inhouse rental program and on-site manager. If you want to head to the Siesta Key Beach, the SK Village, and beyond, you can pick up the free Trolley from the Island Reef Entrance. Walk to Turtles Restaurant or Turtle Beach Park or rent a boat from the nearby Marina. If you have always wanted to live in Paradise, here is your opportunity at a great price! This unit is SOLD AS-IS. The dock is in the process of being rebuilt and will be done in June. There is a short waiting list for those who would want to rent a dock.
Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (888-883-8509)
Listing Agent: Carolyn Francis (941-400-0083)
1248 NORTHPORT DR, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$2,500,000243 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4668459
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.5 Gar: 3 Liv Area Sq Ft: 3250 Built: 1959Monthly Fee: $293 Tax: $13,819 (2025)Community: Royal Palm HarborSpa: NoSingle Family
Taxes:$13,819
Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Siesta Key, island living at its best. Welcome to your waterside home where you’ll enjoy a carefree, tropical lifestyle all year long. This home has been nicely maintained along with an extensive addition completed in 2015. The original home included two guest bedrooms with adjoining Jack and Jill bath plus a primary suite. The 1,200-square-foot addition included an oversized en suite with double sinks and vanity area, walk-in closet, three-headed walk-in shower plus a wall of linen closets. The addition also included a flex room used as an office, plus a 22-by-20-foot pantry/laundry area. A truck-friendly spacious garage with room to accommodate four vehicles and 8-foot high garage door was also part of the expansion. New can lighting installed in living room, dining area and kitchen in 2016 along with a new generous-sized kitchen island. The entire home has low maintenance polished concrete flooring that flows seamlessly throughout. Walls of sliding glass doors surround the oversized screened-in lanai and oversized pool. It’s easy to open up the entire house to the great outdoors when entertaining friends and family. For the boating enthusiast, the home sits on a canal with direct access to the Intracoastal Waterway and offers a 27-foot dock equipped with a 10,000-pound boat lift plus a dual jet ski lift. This home exemplifies the best of island living and don’t forget, world famous Siesta Key Beach is only a short distance away.
Listing Agent: Peg Davant (941-356-4552)
5673 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #201, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$465,00021 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4694956
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1012 Built: 1975 Tax: $5,128 (2025)Community: White Sands VillageCondo
Taxes:$5,128
Remarks: Seller is offering a $5,000 flex credit — apply it toward a mortgage rate buydown to lower your monthly payments, or use it as an appliance package credit. Your choice, your move. Welcome to Unit 201 at White Sands Condominium — a bright, airy coastal retreat perfectly positioned on iconic Midnight Pass Road, Siesta Key. This spacious 1,012 sq ft, two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo is your gateway to the laid-back island lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Whether you choose to walk, cycle, or simply stroll, the world-famous Siesta Key Beach — voted the #1 beach in the USA — is just moments from your front door. Step inside and feel immediately at home. Generous natural light floods the open living spaces, beautifully complemented by wood-look flooring that runs throughout the unit, giving it a polished feel with all the ease of coastal living. The thoughtful layout offers two full bathrooms plus a convenient in-unit washer and dryer, so laundry day never interrupts island day. A dedicated storage closet rounds things out, giving you that extra breathing room that makes everyday life so much easier. When the sun starts to dip and the breeze picks up, step out onto your private covered lanai — the ideal spot to mix a cocktail, host friends, or simply let the Siesta Key evening wash over you. Sheltered and spacious, it extends your living space outdoors in true Florida fashion, and is the kind of feature you'll use every single day. Beyond your front door, White Sands offers a wonderful sense of community. Take a dip in the sparkling community pool, or take advantage of the community boat docks — available on a first-come, first-served basis — perfect for those who love life on the water. And with your own deeded covered parking spot, convenience is always part of the package. This is more than a condo — it's a front-row seat to everything that makes Siesta Key one of Florida's most sought-after addresses. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a vacation escape, or a smart investment, Unit 201 checks every box.
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-366-8070)
Listing Agent: Ed French (747-272-6070)
6415 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #705, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$584,500122 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4683086
REDUCED by $15,300 (2.6%) on 04/13/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1287 Built: 1975 Tax: $3,669 (2025)Community: AnchorageSpa: NoCondo
Taxes:$3,669
Remarks: Welcome to the best location on Siesta Key. The Anchorage is located on the corner of Stickney Point and Midnight Pass. It’s all about convenience and living the good life. Walk to bars, restaurants, the beach. You can walk across the street and rent a boat. Speaking of boats you can dock your boat on our giant seawall for $10.00... yes...ten dollars a month. Your new condominium is an open floor plan with living room/dining room combo. All three rooms have hurricane sliding doors. The main bedroom is very large and the master bath has a walk-in shower. The guest bedroom has 2 double beds with a tub/shower! You also have one covered parking space underneath the main building valued at $25,000.00. We have a beach easement to Siesta Key beach! Our Seawall was replaced in 2019. The building and grounds are in wonderful shape! The Anchorage has so many amenities to offer owners and renters, including an Olympic-size heated swimming pool, Fitness Center, Lighted Pickleball & Tennis Courts, Clubhouse, BBQ & Picnic Areas and Kayak Storage! There is a trolly that you could take to Siesta Key Village to enjoy more shopping, entertainment and dining options. The Anchorage is very conveniently located near Stickney Point Bridge to give you easy access to the mainland, including downtown Sarasota!
Listing is courtesy of: DELUCA REALTY INC (941-487-7162)
Listing Agent: Anthony Deluca (941-685-6001)
6415 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #306, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$595,800191 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4667533
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1287 Built: 1975Monthly Fee: $1,263 Tax: $6,921 (2024)Community: AnchorageCondo
Taxes:$6,921
Remarks: Welcome to one of the best locations on Siesta Key. The Anchorage is located on the corner of Stickney Point and Midnight Pass. It’s all about convenience and living the good life. Location is fantastic! Wait until you see the grounds! You have the best of both worlds. Your new condominium is a 2 bedroom 2 bathroom split plan with brand-new hurricane sliding doors. Inside you have abundant natural light and a spacious combo kitchen/dining room/living room setting offering a move-in-ready condition. What truly sets The Anchorage apart is its canal-front dockage with first-come, first-serve boat slips, providing direct access to Sarasota Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway. For boating enthusiasts, this is an exceptional value, $10.00 per month boat slip fee. This is crazy insane ridiculous pricing for a boat slip…offering a rare opportunity to enjoy waterfront living and boating convenience without the premium price or waitlists typically found on Siesta Key. The building is solid concrete! This is a perfect investment for rental opportunities. Weekly rentals are allowed. The building and grounds are in wonderful shape! The Anchorage has so many amenities to offer owners and renters, including an Olympic-size heated swimming pool, Fitness Center, Lighted Pickleball & Tennis Courts, Clubhouse, BBQ & Picnic Areas and Kayak Storage. If you have a boat, The Anchorage also offers free dockage along the Seawall! There is a trolly that you could take to Siesta Key Village to enjoy more shopping, entertainment and dining options. Your new condo has its own carport. The Anchorage is very conveniently located near Stickney Point Bridge to give you easy access to the mainland, including downtown Sarasota!
1224 MOONMIST CIR #S-3, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$749,00053 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4690713
REDUCED by $40,900 (5.2%) on 05/20/2026
Bed: 3 Bath: 3.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1949 Built: 1968 Tax: $4,925 (2025)Community: Polynesian GardensSpa: NoCondo
Taxes:$4,925
Remarks: Outstanding remodeled and updated freestanding 3/3 villa in private and beautiful Polynesian Gardens. New ceramic tile flooring throughout. Spacious with large rooms plus 259 extra square feet in glassed in lanai/Florida room which can be used as a family room. office or man cave. The updates include a new addition to the villa of approximately 330 additional square feet and a beautiful second primary suite/third bedroom with an ensuite bath and a laundry room with new washer/dryer and cabinet and closets. 3 bedrooms are split from each other. Primary bedroom has an ensuite bath with a shower and extra shelving for toiletries, large walk-in closet and a set of sliders to the Florida room. Guest bedroom is large enough for two queen size beds plus large closets. Guest bathroom is right outside of guest bedroom and has a tub/shower with updated vanity with dual sinks. Combo living/dining area with easy access to updated kitchen with pantry and cabinetry galore. New appliances. Living/dining room is large and has a coat closet. New sliding glass door adds sunshine and light and leads to the large private paved side yard and back yard. Large enough for gardening, patio furniture and a barbeque. This villa has been replumbed and the drainpipes were replaced in the entire house in 2017. The roof was replaced by the Association in 2020. New roof on the addition and transition to the existing roof in 2026 Exterior has been freshly painted. New landscaping. Installation of a new 5' high white vinyl fence in the front and rear with a gated storage space. Solar security lights on the rear fence. Many more improvements too numerous to list but available on a feature sheet. Polynesian Gardens is an active community with a clubhouse, heated swimming pool and a newly built fishing pier. Yet the location and setting of Polynesian Gardens allows its owners to enjoy a relaxed coastal lifestyle. The Siesta Breeze free trolley stops in front of the community and will take you to Siesta Village for shopping and eating out, to Turtle Beach and to world renowned Siesta Key beach, America's #1 Beach, known for its powdery white quartz sand. Close to Sarasota's downtown area and cultural centers, there are many venues for entertainment and education. Rentals are allowed and are always in demand. Own your own piece of Paradise.
Listing Agent: Stephen Clementi (912-704-2116)
1218 MOONMIST CIR #S2, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$739,00053 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4691272
REDUCED by $35,900 (4.6%) on 05/28/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1334 Built: 1968Monthly Fee: $1,057 Tax: $4,193 (2025)Community: Polynesian GardensVilla
Taxes:$4,193
Remarks: Welcome to your New Home, minutes from the world-renowned Siesta Key Beach, consistently ranked as one of the #1 beaches in the U.S famous for its powdery white quartz sand and crystal-clear Gulf waters. This impeccably remodeled turnkey furnished home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the best of coastal living within the charming Polynesian Gardens community. This, home offers a refined take on island living, featuring a new roof, new AC, and impact-rated windows and doors for style, comfort, and peace of mind. Designed with a light, coastal aesthetic, the open-concept layout is both inviting and functional. At the heart of the home, the designer kitchen showcases custom white cabinetry, brand-new stainless appliances, and a tile backsplash, complemented by a dining area seamlessly positioned adjacent to the kitchen and perfect for effortless entertaining or relaxed everyday living. The home features a spacious primary suite with a beautifully appointed ensuite bath, along with a guest bedroom and full guest bathroom, offering privacy and comfort for family and visitors. The living space extends into an enclosed, expanded lanai, creating a versatile indoor-outdoor retreat to enjoy year-round. A rare highlight is the oversized private garden, offering a lush, tropical setting with exceptional privacy, an uncommon feature that truly sets this villa apart and enhances the feeling of a private coastal escape. Residents of Polynesian Gardens enjoy a resort-style lifestyle with amenities including a community pier on the intercoastal, a heated pool, and clubhouse. Beyond the community, enjoy effortless access to the vibrant energy of Siesta Key Village, known for its beachside restaurants, bars, live music, and boutique shopping, as well as the relaxed charm of Crescent Beach village. This property also offers a proven rental history with strong year-round bookings, making it an exceptional opportunity for both personal enjoyment and income potential. Whether you’re spending the day boating along the Intracoastal, enjoying the white quartz sands of Siesta Key Beach, or unwinding in your own private garden retreat, this exceptional villa captures the essence of luxury coastal living. Perfectly positioned near Siesta Key Village and the Gulf beaches, this turnkey remodeled property presents an incredible opportunity as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or income-producing investment
Listing Agent: Jayne Appleyard (941-681-5042)
5600 BEACH WAY DR #315, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$750,000375 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4655560
REDUCED by $20,000 (2.6%) on 06/03/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1259 Built: 1970 Tax: $7,099 (2024)Community: Beachway AptsCondo
Taxes:$7,099
Remarks: Your Florida beach escape awaits — and with a motivated seller, this is an opportunity you won't want to miss.... take a look at this condo that is steps away from the quartz crystal white powdery sands and warm Gulf waters of the award-winning Siesta Key Beach? This wonderfully located turn-key, furnished end unit condo is oh so unique on the top floor with views of the beautiful white sandy beach and sparkling blue Gulf waters, a rare, remodeled find on the spectacular Gulf coasts of Florida! The rental income is excellent! This recently, completely remodeled from ceiling to floor, wall to wall, unit has 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, hard flooring throughout, a sprawling island, quartz countertops, impact windows and sliders, AND has a spacious balcony, ready for you to relax and enjoy. This unit transfers with $50,000 in furnishings and furniture. This is a perfect place for you to have your dream of a beach life come to reality, with the potential of using it to generate income with monthly rentals. This amazing mid-rise condominium community offers a heated community pool, outside grills, a clubroom with a kitchen, plenty of guest parking and a laundry room on each floor. Recent improvements include newer roofs 2020, a newer elevator 2019, re-plumbed stacks 2018, refreshed landscaping 2020, and new vinyl fencing 2021. The quarterly fee includes access to the heated community pool, basic cable, water/sewer, pest control, weekend on-site maintenance person, and community insurance. Enjoy convenient access to Siesta Key Beach and to Siesta Key Village shops and restaurants with the free trolley service that stops right in front of the Beach Way community, or, walk, orrrrr take a bike cruise to many nearby shops and restaurants… You are not only buying a beach property, you are buying a lifestyle in the beautiful Southwest Florida Sun. This unit can be your own sanctuary escape and your retirement investment... Come see, come sigh and make this Siesta Key lifestyle in the Sun your own.
Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S (941-803-7522)
Listing Agent: Karie Backman (941-404-8389)
4708 OCEAN BLVD #E7, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$2,299,000270 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4665893
REDUCED by $51,000 (2.2%) on 05/04/2026
Bed: 3 Bath: 3.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2277 Built: 1981 Tax: $16,841 (2025)Community: Windward PassageCondo
Taxes:$16,841
Remarks: Experience refined coastal living in North Siesta Key at 4708 Ocean Boulevard, a fully renovated 2025 corner residence ideally positioned on the Gulf of Mexico at Big Pass. This exceptional 3-bedroom, 3-bath condominium offers unobstructed panoramic views of the Gulf, Sarasota Bay, and distant vistas of Lido Key and downtown Sarasota. Encompassing 2,277 square feet with miles of Gulf-front views, the residence has been thoughtfully redesigned with wide-plank European engineered oak flooring, impact-rated windows and doors, and integrated smart-home technology throughout. The chef’s kitchen is a statement in both form and function, featuring custom cabinetry, Milano Dolomite countertops, a striking Macaubas Quartzite island, and premium GE Café appliances—perfect for entertaining against a backdrop of endless blue water. The primary suite is a private retreat with direct access to a Gulf-front balcony and a spa-inspired bath complete with dual vanities, rainfall shower, and bidet. Two additional guest suites provide comfort and privacy, each finished with designer details. Additional highlights include a two-car tandem garage with hurricane-rated door, new HVAC systems, electric hurricane shutters, and an integrated sound and entertainment system. Amenities include a heated pool, guest parking, and direct walking access to the sugar-white sands and vibrant Village of Siesta Key. This residence blends timeless coastal elegance with modern luxury—an extraordinary Gulf-front retreat on one of Siesta Key’s most coveted stretches of shoreline.
Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-388-4447)
Listing Agent: Stacey King (646-734-5014)
3942 HAMILTON CLUB CIR #13, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,349,00015 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4696120
Bed: 3 Bath: 3.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2691 Built: 1997 Tax: $10,009 (2025)Community: Hamilton ClubSingle Family
Taxes:$10,009
Remarks: Siesta Key, exclusive gated community of only 18 homes with Marina, pool and tennis all within a private, lush, tropical paradise . Walking paths around the lagoon as well as the beautiful Marina make Hamilton Club a truly unique lifestyle. Inspired by the architcture of Bermuda with its close ties to 17th Century Great Britian is recognised by its striking pastel colored walls and "welcoming arms" staircases . Very close to the Village and Beach , yet equally convenient to Downtown . This sophisticated townhome has been completly renovated with fine finishes , wood and stone prevail with architectural beauty . Soaring ceilings bring in the most elegant lighting . The kitchen with its sweeping bar of magnificent granite can accomodate a large party-open to the Great Room , it is both sleek and inviting .Premium appliances include Miele, Bosch , GE and KitchenAid .Expansive counter space , built in shelving and a variety of pantries and drawers add to the incredible functionality. The Great Room with 20 foot ceilings opens to the screened balcony with a charming view of the lagoon and pool area . The primary bedroom is enhanced by the stunning view of treetops and is all the more cozy for having its own fireplace . Impact rated windows and a metal roof combine to make this solid structure weather worthy . On the ground floor , in addition to the oversized two car gargage is a climate controlled bonus room which opens to the ground floor lanai . Boating , swimming , tennis and walking paths , within a private and peaceful environment close to everything -that is the Hamilton Club .
Listing Agent: Barbara Dumbaugh (941-349-3444)
5201 AVENIDA DEL MARE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,450,000136 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4680975
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 6/5/2026)
REDUCED by $45,000 (3.0%) on 04/30/2026
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2802 Built: 2008 Tax: $6,145 (2025)Community: Sarasota BeachSpa: NoSingle Family
Taxes:$6,145
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. WELCOME to one of Siesta Key's hidden gems. From this Key West style home, you can walk or bike ride to the soft, quartz sands of Siesta Beach or the quaint Siesta Village in minutes. This exceptional home offers high end finishes throughout. The native yard features beach sunflowers and other native plants and shrubs. The front door entrance invites you into the main level with an easy flow between the living room and the dining room. The gourmet kitchen features wood cabinets, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and French Door refrigerator. The guest bath, laundry room and bonus room complete the downstairs. The backyard is a fenced, private oasis with a pool surrounded by stone pavers with room for lounge chairs, grill and an outdoor table setting. Mature royal palm trees and smaller palms create a beautiful habitat for birds and other wildlife. The second floor has two comfortable bedrooms, one with a private balcony. A full bath completes this level. The top level offers a spacious Primary Bedroom and En Suite Bathroom retreat with exceptional amenities, a large bathroom with granite countertops, wrap-around walk-in shower, and separate garden tub, with a screened-in balcony overlooking the pool area. The top level is completed by an additional Bedroom with an en suite Bathroom with walk-in shower, linen closet, and granite countertops. Additional features include solar panels (paid in full), a security system, stone paved driveway and walkway, along with an oversized 2 car garage. This open, sunny home is located in a quiet neighborhood at the end of the street and has so many quality features. It is definitely worth a visit.
Listing is courtesy of: PREFERRED SHORE LLC (941-999-1179)
Listing Agent: Mary Kassen (941-900-9776)
Please select an email frequency other than None since you have chosen for us to email you with changes that match your search.