Location: Sarasota, 34242
Do Not Show Listings
1200 EAST PEPPERTREE LANE #302, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$719,00073 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4685295
REDUCED by $10,000 (1.4%) on 05/01/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1463 Built: 1975 Tax: $6,135 (2025)Community: Peppertree BaySpa: YesCondo
Market Analysis: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Nearby Properties: For SaleFor RentSoldRented
Taxes:$6,135
Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
High School: Sarasota High
Tax Year: 2025
Middle School: Brookside Middle
Remarks: PRICE IMPROVEMENT OF $20.000!! Turnkey coastal living in the desirable mid-rise tower at Peppertree Bay on Siesta Key. This sought-after split-plan residence offers bright open living spaces, exceptional privacy, and the convenience of effortless island living with resort-style Gulf-to-Bay amenities just moments from world-famous Siesta Beach. Offered fully turnkey furnished, this beautifully maintained two-bedroom, two-bath residence is ready for immediate enjoyment as a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or investment property. The split-bedroom layout provides privacy for owners and guests, while the open living and dining areas create a comfortable space for everyday living and entertaining. A feature seldom found in these units is the dedicated laundry room with a utility sink, adding both convenience and functionality. The residence also includes elevator access, covered parking, and generous storage. Peppertree Bay is one of Siesta Key’s most sought-after Gulf-to-Bay communities, offering private beach access to the powdery quartz sands of Siesta Beach, two heated pools, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness center, clubhouse, fishing pier, and beautifully maintained tropical grounds. Ideally located just minutes from Siesta Village dining, shopping, and entertainment, this residence offers the best of relaxed island living.
Listing is courtesy of: WILLIAM RAVEIS REAL ESTATE (941-867-3901)
Listing Agent: Renee Nadiv (941-299-4242)
5334 CALLE FLORIDA, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,870,000146 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4676260
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2838 Built: 1998 Tax: $5,619 (2025)Community: Sarasota BeachSpa: YesSingle Family
Taxes:$5,619
Elementary School: None
High School: None
Middle School: None
Remarks: Fantastic opportunity to own a unique home on Palm Island, in this exceptional Siesta Key residence, ideally located at 5334 Calle Florida. Situated on a large lot and elevated approximately 10 feet above sea level, the main home has never flooded during any storms, offering peace of mind along with island luxury. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home features 2,838 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space highlighted by a dramatic great room with soaring 20-foot ceilings, creating an open and airy coastal feel. The large primary suite has a custom built window seat, 2 walk in closets and an oversized primary bathroom. The entire home features built in speakers, including the back porch. Designed for comfort and efficiency, the home is equipped with a three-zone air conditioning system and hurricane-rated Kevlar screens, hurricane rated garage and front door for added protection. The spacious two-car garage provides ample storage, perfect for island living. The exterior is landscaped with outdoor lights and power in soffits for seasonal or all year round lighting. Outdoor living is elevated—literally—with an elevated, heated pool and hot tub, an outdoor shower, and plenty of space to relax or entertain in true Florida style. Located on Palm Island, just moments from the world-renowned Siesta Key Beach, this property offers the perfect blend of privacy, elevation, and coastal charm. Whether as a primary residence or luxury retreat, this home is a rare opportunity to own a high-and-dry island property in one of Sarasota’s most sought-after neighborhoods. Roof replaced 2021, Pool resurfaced 2024, Pool cage repainted and rescreened 2025, Water heater 2025. Unique Architectural Details *** Custom Built *** Oversized Primary Suite *** Soaring Ceilings *** Open Concept *** Elevated Key West Style *** Screened Lanai
Listing is courtesy of: LPT REALTY, LLC (877-366-2213)
Listing Agent: Niall Phelan (941-914-8589)
1218 MOONMIST CIR #S2, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$774,90024 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4691272
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1334 Built: 1968Monthly Fee: $1,057 Tax: $4,193 (2025)Community: Polynesian GardensVilla
Taxes:$4,193
Remarks: Welcome to your New Home, minutes from the world-renowned Siesta Key Beach, consistently ranked as one of the #1 beaches in the U.S famous for its powdery white quartz sand and crystal-clear Gulf waters. This impeccably remodeled turnkey furnished home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the best of coastal living within the charming Polynesian Gardens community. This, home offers a refined take on island living, featuring a new roof, new AC, and impact-rated windows and doors for style, comfort, and peace of mind. Designed with a light, coastal aesthetic, the open-concept layout is both inviting and functional. At the heart of the home, the designer kitchen showcases custom white cabinetry, brand-new stainless appliances, and a tile backsplash, complemented by a dining area seamlessly positioned adjacent to the kitchen and perfect for effortless entertaining or relaxed everyday living. The home features a spacious primary suite with a beautifully appointed ensuite bath, along with a guest bedroom and full guest bathroom, offering privacy and comfort for family and visitors. The living space extends into an enclosed, expanded lanai, creating a versatile indoor-outdoor retreat to enjoy year-round. A rare highlight is the oversized private garden, offering a lush, tropical setting with exceptional privacy, an uncommon feature that truly sets this villa apart and enhances the feeling of a private coastal escape. Residents of Polynesian Gardens enjoy a resort-style lifestyle with amenities including a community pier on the intercoastal, a heated pool, and clubhouse. Beyond the community, enjoy effortless access to the vibrant energy of Siesta Key Village, known for its beachside restaurants, bars, live music, and boutique shopping, as well as the relaxed charm of Crescent Beach village. This property also offers a proven rental history with strong year-round bookings, making it an exceptional opportunity for both personal enjoyment and income potential. Whether you’re spending the day boating along the Intracoastal, enjoying the white quartz sands of Siesta Key Beach, or unwinding in your own private garden retreat, this exceptional villa captures the essence of luxury coastal living. Perfectly positioned near Siesta Key Village and the Gulf beaches, this turnkey remodeled property presents an incredible opportunity as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or income-producing investment
Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (888-883-8509)
Listing Agent: Jayne Appleyard (941-681-5042)
6415 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #306, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$595,800162 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4667533
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1287 Built: 1975Monthly Fee: $1,263 Tax: $6,921 (2024)Community: AnchorageCondo
Taxes:$6,921
Tax Year: 2024
Remarks: Welcome to one of the best locations on Siesta Key. The Anchorage is located on the corner of Stickney Point and Midnight Pass. It’s all about convenience and living the good life. Location is fantastic! Wait until you see the grounds! You have the best of both worlds. Your new condominium is a 2 bedroom 2 bathroom split plan with brand-new hurricane sliding doors. Inside you have abundant natural light and a spacious combo kitchen/dining room/living room setting offering a move-in-ready condition. What truly sets The Anchorage apart is its canal-front dockage with first-come, first-serve boat slips, providing direct access to Sarasota Bay and the Intracoastal Waterway. For boating enthusiasts, this is an exceptional value, $10.00 per month boat slip fee. This is crazy insane ridiculous pricing for a boat slip…offering a rare opportunity to enjoy waterfront living and boating convenience without the premium price or waitlists typically found on Siesta Key. The building is solid concrete! This is a perfect investment for rental opportunities. Weekly rentals are allowed. The building and grounds are in wonderful shape! The Anchorage has so many amenities to offer owners and renters, including an Olympic-size heated swimming pool, Fitness Center, Lighted Pickleball & Tennis Courts, Clubhouse, BBQ & Picnic Areas and Kayak Storage. If you have a boat, The Anchorage also offers free dockage along the Seawall! There is a trolly that you could take to Siesta Key Village to enjoy more shopping, entertainment and dining options. Your new condo has its own carport. The Anchorage is very conveniently located near Stickney Point Bridge to give you easy access to the mainland, including downtown Sarasota!
Listing is courtesy of: DELUCA REALTY INC (941-487-7162)
Listing Agent: Anthony Deluca (941-685-6001)
7108 MIDNIGHT PASS RD, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$4,219,00077 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4685107
Bed: 7 Bath: 5.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 4697 Built: 1970Monthly Fee: $467 Tax: $10,150 (2025)Community: Siesta Properties IncSpa: NoSingle Family
Taxes:$10,150
High School: Riverview High
Remarks: A rare opportunity situated on an expansive 1.8 acres, this estate is located behind the gates of one of Siesta Key’s most exceptional estate settings. Surrounded by lush tropical foliage and serene lagoon-style water features, the property offers remarkable privacy and versatility with a 5-bedroom, 4-bath main residence and a separate 2-bedroom, 1-bath guest house—ideal for multi-generational living, hosting guests, or providing dedicated staff accommodations. The grounds evoke a secluded, natural sanctuary while remaining just minutes from Siesta Key’s vibrant dining, boutique shopping, and world-renowned coastline. Positioned within the prestigious Sanderling Club, the estate grants access to one of Sarasota’s most storied and sought-after communities. Celebrated for its historic bay-to-gulf setting and architectural significance, the Sanderling Club offers residents private beach access, 24-hour gated security, tennis and pickleball courts, a beach front clubhouse, and a members-only marina just steps from the property—delivering a refined coastal lifestyle unlike anywhere else. Located moments from the iconic, powder-soft sands of Siesta Beach, this property presents a rare chance to create a legacy residence in an extraordinary setting. Whether you choose to enhance the existing homes or envision an entirely new custom masterpiece, the possibilities are limitless. Properties of this scale within the Sanderling Club are exceptionally scarce, making this offering truly remarkable.
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)
Listing Agent: Maryana Zilinskiy (941-744-6065)
5790 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #209, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,150,00014 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: N6144235
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1433 Built: 1979 Tax: $9,389 (2025)Community: Gulf & Bay Club Ph 1Condo
Taxes:$9,389
Remarks: Welcome to highly sought-after "Building A" at the Gulf & Bay Club located on Siesta Key Beach! Where you'll be just steps to the No. 1 BEACH in the USA! As you enter the gated community, you will feel like you've landed in paradise as you make your way down the brick paved streets to the building closest to the beach. Offered TURN-KEY FURNISHED, this nicely updated 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo located on the second floor offers quick and easy access to the amenities and is just steps to private beach access! From the moment you enter you'll be drawn to the incredible views of the beach, gulf, pool, pond and beautiful grounds of the community! The kitchen features a large island, breakfast bar, granite countertops, new appliances and plenty of cabinetry for storage. The open floor plan is great for entertaining. Comfortably sleeps 6 people. Both bathrooms have been beautifully updated. New wood flooring follows throughout with tile in the kitchen. The unit offers an inside laundry room and an owner’s storage closet for your beach toys! Enjoy several upgrades including ceiling fans in each room, crown molding, custom trim woodwork and more! Amenities include 32 pristine acres, 800 feet of private beach on Siesta Key, a lush Tropical courtyard with a freshwater lake, 3 large heated pools, outdoor barbecuing areas, 6 tennis courts including 1 Har-Tru court, pickleball, basketball, shuffleboard, 2 clubhouses, media center, pool table and TV’s, fitness center and more! Schedule a showing today!
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-493-1000)
Listing Agent: Jamie Mullis (941-716-1375)
5968 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #158, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$760,000105 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4681104
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1134 Built: 1975 Tax: $7,449 (2025)Community: Palm Bay Club IiiCondo
Taxes:$7,449
Remarks: Looking for the perfect 2-bedroom, 2-bath investment beach condo on Siesta Key? This second-level residence presents a strong income-producing opportunity at the desirable, gulf-front Palm Bay Club. Ideally situated on the beach side of Midnight Pass Road, unit #158 features a comfortable coastal design with an open floor plan, beachy ambiance, and tile flooring throughout, making it move-in ready for owners, guests, and short-term renters alike. Just steps from the pristine blue waters and powder-white sands of Siesta Beach, the thoughtfully designed and tastefully furnished interior maximizes space and functionality with seamless flow from the kitchen to dining and living areas. One of the premier beach-to-bay communities on Siesta Key, Palm Bay Club offers an exceptional array of amenities including two heated swimming pools, a hot tub overlooking the bay, fitness center, lighted tennis court with two pickleball courts, BBQ grills, a fishing pier, and boat docks available for daily rental. With a rare three-night minimum rental policy on Siesta Key and onsite management, this is an outstanding opportunity for the savvy owner-investor seeking both lifestyle and income.
Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-349-3444)
Listing Agent: Jonathan Abrams, Pllc (941-232-2868)
225 HOURGLASS WAY #106, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$500,00092 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4683200
REDUCED by $75,000 (13.0%) on 05/08/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1271 Built: 1969Monthly Fee: $1,566 Tax: $3,860 (2025)Community: Whispering SandsCondo
Taxes:$3,860
Remarks: Step into your own island retreat with this rare ground floor END unit in the highly sought after GULF FRONT property of Whispering Sands! Perfectly positioned with a full length screened & glassed lanai overlooking the picturesque lagoon and lush tropical landscaping, this residence captures a peaceful, serene setting with a touch of everyday luxury. Thoughtfully updated and designed for effortless living, the OPEN CONCEPT floor plan features non-slip porcelain tile placed on the diagonal, skip trowel ceiling, and a spacious light-filled living space with an additional, sunny, west facing window. The nicely RENOVATED kitchen is a standout, offering granite countertops, colorful tile backsplash, a 9’ breakfast bar, white soft-close cabinetry, and a suite of GE, Whirlpool, Frigidaire, and LG appliances, all enhanced by overhead recessed, dimmable LED lighting. The cabinetry and granite extend into the entire length of the dining area, creating additional storage and an elegant serving space ideal for entertaining. The original interior living room sliders have been removed to seamlessly incorporate the lanai, transforming it into a sun-drenched sunroom that expands your cooled living space and invites the outdoors in. Just outside, a small brick paver patio off the sunroom offers the perfect spot for grilling, sunning, or unwinding after a day at the beach. Both bathrooms in this unit have been tastefully updated with NEW vanities, fixtures, and cabinetry. Additional highlights include a complete set of 2016 hurricane impact sunroom sliders and 2025 water heater. At Whispering Sands, every day feels like a vacation—with 800’ of PRIVATE beach, two heated pools with new travertine tile decks, clubhouse – currently undergoing a complete remodel which will include a catering kitchen and fitness rooms – beachside Tiki Hut, grills, and canoe/kayak—all just a short stroll to the vibrant shops and dining options of Siesta Key Village. Your island getaway awaits!
Listing Agent: Harriet Stopher (404-316-8944)
467 CANAL RD #467, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$2,590,000556 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4628207
0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 5/8/2026)
Bed: 4 Bath: 3.5 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 3228 Built: 2005Monthly Fee: $158 Tax: $10,222 (2023)Community: Grand Siesta 1Spa: YesTownhouse
Taxes:$10,222
Tax Year: 2023
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Possible Seller Finance. High & Dry!! BEACH, BOATING & BISTROS!!!! SIESTA KEY`CANAL FRONT featuring WEEKLY RENTALS!! DOCK & LIFT!! GULF VIEWS!! BEACH ACCESS STEPS AWAY!!! Great location with Gulf Views steps to Public Beach Access #8 offering the ultimate waterfront lifestyle of this rare, furnished 3 bedroom/3.5 Bath plus office (or 4th bedroom), RMF-zoned opportunity on Siesta Key. Built in 2005 with high elevation and Impact Glass for peace of mind. Savor spacious living with high ceilings in 4 stories and 3,036+/- sq. ft. of living area, all accessible by stairs or private elevator, plus a ground-floor bonus room set behind the garage for your gym or office. Retreat to the large master suite, which boasts water vistas and master bath with dual vanities, granite counters, walk-in shower. Multiple terraces provide a picture-perfect panorama of your tropical setting, with each level more stunning than the last and culminating with stunning Siesta Key Beach views from the soaring top floor. Entertain with ease and style by the open, heated pool and spa, which leads to your own private dock and boatlift. Just a short boat ride on the Grand Canal to worldclass fishing and watersports. HOA is reasonably priced and lends to your comfort and convenience of maintenance-free living. Seller will also consider partial trade on storm damaged home.
Listing is courtesy of: PREFERRED SHORE LLC (941-999-1179)
Listing Agent: Dan Miller (941-376-7442)
925 BEACH RD #107, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$568,00056 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4687498
REDUCED by $25,000 (4.2%) on 05/08/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 940 Built: 1972 Tax: $3,927 (2025)Community: La SiestaCondo
Taxes:$3,927
Remarks: Located directly across the street from world-famous Siesta Key Beach—recently ranked the #1 Beach in the United States and among the top beaches in the world— this residence offers exceptional convenience and effortless access to the sand. Simply walk to the beach in approximately five minutes—no driving, no searching for parking, just easy coastal living. Enjoy morning walks and evening sunsets on Siesta Key Beach just steps away. This 2-bedroom, 2 full bath residence offers approximately 940 square feet of comfortable living space with an open layout designed for relaxed island living. The updated kitchen features wood cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances, flowing seamlessly into the dining and living areas. Tile flooring throughout provides durability and easy maintenance, while the split-bedroom floor plan allows for privacy between residents and guests. One of the largest 2-bedroom, 2 full bath floor plans in the community, competitively priced at $593,000. Weekly rentals are permitted, offering outstanding flexibility for both personal use and income potential. Onsite property management is available, making guest coordination and rental operations easy and convenient. Covered parking is included, along with ample guest parking. La Siesta residents enjoy access to a heated pool, fitness room, clubhouse, and beautifully maintained grounds. Located just minutes from Siesta Key Village’s restaurants, shopping, and entertainment, this property offers the ideal balance of relaxation and accessibility. Whether you’re searching for a personal beach retreat, seasonal residence, or an income-producing investment, this location delivers the lifestyle buyers and vacationers come to Siesta Key to enjoy.
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-366-8070)
Listing Agent: Lisa Garcia (941-266-9060)
925 BEACH RD #109, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$619,000219 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4665443
Bed: 1 Bath: 1.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 697 Built: 1972 Tax: $2,804 (2025)Community: La SiestaCondo
Taxes:$2,804
Remarks: Good things come in small packages. This one-bedroom unit has a lot of rental power: 2026 bookings are already over $31,000. And there is over $8,000 in rental income booked for 2027. Have you ever dreamed of owning a piece of paradise steps from Siesta Beach, consistently ranked among the top beaches in the U.S.? You've arrived. Experience sunsets and direct beach access from this newly renovated beautiful TURNKEY-FURNISHED one-bedroom, one-bath condo at La Siesta, offering easy access to the white sand and Gulf waters that make this area world-renowned. This condo features an open floor plan that maximizes space and natural light with brand new luxury vinyl flooring, cabinetry, appliances, HVAC, and coastal-inspired decor, creating an inviting retreat that comfortably sleeps four. Whether for investment or a personal beach getaway, this first-floor residence offers excellent flexibility. La Siesta allows weekly rentals (52 times per year), and this condo has a track record of strong occupancy, providing an appealing balance of income and enjoyment. Step from your screened-in lanai and you’re just across the street from the powder-soft sands of Siesta Beach, or take a stroll or hop the free trolley to Siesta Key Village for dining and shopping. Community amenities include a heated over-sized pool, clubhouse, fitness room, and two barbecue areas, perfect after a day by the water. With low HOA fees, a prime location, and a move-in-ready interior, this La Siesta condo has it all - making it easy to embrace or invest in the Siesta Key lifestyle.
Listing Agent: Jennifer Russo (212-683-1173)
355 CALLE MIRAMAR, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$3,300,000126 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: N6142420
REDUCED by $200,000 (5.7%) on 05/08/2026
Bed: 6 Bath: 0.0 Gar: 2 Liv Area Sq Ft: 2660 Built: 1993 Tax: $25,782 (2025)Community: Sarasota BeachSpa: YesApartment
Taxes:$25,782
Remarks: Rare opportunity to own a pristine, income-producing duplex just steps from Siesta Key Village and one block from the powdery sands of Siesta Key Beach—recognized as one of the finest beaches in the world. Properties offering this level of condition, location, and flexibility are seldom available. Each residence features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms and has been thoughtfully renovated and fully furnished for immediate enjoyment or turnkey rental use. Interiors showcase luxury vinyl flooring throughout, updated kitchens, split-bedroom layouts, in-unit laundry, and large flat-screen televisions in all bedrooms and livi. ng areas—designed to support both comfortable living and strong rental demand. There are no rental restrictionss. Bright, sunfilled open bedrooms with generous closets complement spacious, well-appointed kitchens. Outdoor living is exceptional, with 2 heated private pools and spas, front and rear patios, and deeded canal access just around the corner—features that enhance both lifestyle enjoyment and guest appeal. Each unit includes a private garage with game room, accommodating up to two vehicles, along with additional driveway parking—an exceptional convenience on Siesta Key. The property offers outstanding versatility, whether used as a primary or seasonal residence with supplemental rental income, or operated as a dual-income investment. Significant exterior improvements include updated siding and trim, hurricane-rated windows on the front elevation, refreshed lighting, fresh exterior paint, and brick paver driveways and walkways—creating a polished coastal offering in one of Siesta Key’s most desirable and supply-constrained locations.
Listing Agent: Matthew Vander Wyden (941-483-0977)
6518 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #209, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$850,000177 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4673460
REDUCED by $25,000 (2.9%) on 04/17/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1215 Built: 1975 Tax: $8,542 (2024)Community: House SunCondo
Taxes:$8,542
Remarks: Experience true beachfront living on world-famous Siesta Key. This turnkey-furnished 2-bedroom, 2-bath residence offers an exceptional opportunity to own along Siesta Key’s shoreline, combining Gulf views with impressive short-term rental income potential. Located just steps from the island’s iconic powder-white sand, this inviting condominium is designed for comfort, convenience, and effortless coastal living. Inside, an open and airy layout welcomes you with abundant natural light and luxury vinyl flooring throughout the main living areas. The living room flows seamlessly to large sliders that open to a wonderful 14x7 private patio, the perfect place to relax and take in the stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Kitchen features wooden cabinets providing lots of ample storage, a breakfast bar for additional seating, and a functional layout ideal for everyday cooking or hosting guests. The primary suite includes ceramic tile flooring, a private en-suite bath, and ample closet space. Both bathrooms have been updated with new vanities and granite countertops—the primary bathroom offering a standalone shower, while the guest bathroom features a convenient tub/shower combination. Every window and sliders have recently been replaced by association in the last few years This community is one of the few on Siesta Key allowing weekly rentals, paired with a professional on-site rental management team, creating strong income potential while still giving you the freedom to enjoy your own beach retreat. Resort-style amenities elevate the beachfront experience. Enjoy a beach-facing pool and tennis courts, fitness center, rooftop lounge with panoramic Gulf views, and outdoor grilling/bar areas with firepits—everything you need for relaxed days and evenings by the water. Direct beach access places you just steps from the shoreline. Ideally located near Siesta Key Village’s vibrant shops, dining, and entertainment, this residence offers the perfect combination of coastal living, convenience, and investment appeal—an outstanding opportunity to enjoy and share the Siesta Key lifestyle.
Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-383-6411)
Listing Agent: David Leventhal (941-518-7694)
8773 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #302G, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$500,00017 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4691760
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1303 Built: 1981 Tax: $4,030 (2025)Community: Island Reef Ii Ph 1 2 & 3Condo
Taxes:$4,030
Remarks: Turnkey Furnished residence at Island Reef with two bedrooms and two baths. Laundry in residence. Furnished! Carport! island Reef is a serene waterfront community, one of the few gulf to Bay Community that offers many desirable amenities including: Beach, Boat Docks (lifts allowed), Two lit Tennis Courts, Pickleball, 2 Fitness Rooms, Kayak storage, Library, Billiards, Game room, Clubhouse, two Heated Pools, and Gas grills. PET FRIENDLY! Tropical Gardens add to the appeal of Island Reef and this wonderful community is close to two of Siesta Key's popular restaurants. Complimentary trolley to Siesta Beach, Siesta Village for dining, shopping, ice cream, mini donuts, cut brunch spots and dancing and live music every night of the week.
Listing Agent: Marlene Marshall (941-539-8850)
1320 MOONMIST DR #B-11, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,200,000119 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4679270
REDUCED by $100,000 (7.7%) on 04/13/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1790 Built: 1968 Tax: $5,819 (2025)Community: Polynesian GardensCondo
Taxes:$5,819
Remarks: Rarely available direct bayfront 2/2 maintenance free villa in Polynesian Gardens. Magnificent views of the Intracoastal/Little Sarasota Bay. Watch the manatees and boats go by from your paved patio directly on the water. Spacious 2 bedrooms/2 full baths with very large great room. Updated kitchen and baths with new cabinetry, granite and stainless-steel appliances. Plenty of closet space. Garage with plenty of storage plus an extra driveway allows for 2 parking spaces. Newer washer/dryer in garage. Beautiful landscaping. Community has a heated pool, clubhouse and fishing pier. Close to shops, dining and America's #1 Beach - Siesta Key. Free trolley stops directly in the front of the community on Midnight Pass Road. Two pets allowed any size.
Listing Agent: Helene Hyland (941-685-2274)
1125 W PEPPERTREE DR #706, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$799,900221 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4668225
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1163 Built: 1974 Tax: $6,423 (2024)Community: Peppertree Bay IiiCondo
Taxes:$6,423
Elementary School: Gulf Gate Elementary
Remarks: LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Discover your slice of paradise in the desirable Peppertree Bay community on Siesta Key. This fabulous, turnkey furnished 7th-floor Gulfside condo, offers direct beach access and panoramic views of Siesta Key and Downtown Sarasota. Featuring tile flooring throughout, this 2-bed, 2-bath layout includes a custom kitchen with quartz countertops, mosaic tile backsplash, center island with breakfast bar, ample cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances. The open-concept dining and living areas flow seamlessly onto the Florida room patio, perfect for entertaining or unwinding. Both bedroom suites are positioned on opposite sides of the unit for privacy and each offers patio access. Additional highlights include a custom utility room with in-unit washer & dryer, generous storage, and under-building parking. Peppertree Bay is a gulf-to-bay community offering resort-style amenities: fishing pier, BBQ grills and picnic areas, tennis and pickleball courts, fitness center, and two clubhouses with full kitchens and vibrant social events. Enjoy easy access to Siesta Key Village for live music, boutique shopping, and dining, plus convenient off-island access to all that Sarasota has to offer. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, vacation retreat, or investment opportunity, this condo will not disappoint. Bonus: current owners are open to seasonal lease-back, offering instant income potential if available.
Listing Agent: Christine Green (941-914-2463)
8779 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #401H, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$595,000287 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4661131
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1485 Built: 1980 Tax: $4,969 (2025)Community: Island Reef Ii Ph 1 2 & 3Spa: NoCondo
Taxes:$4,969
Remarks: ENJOY THE BAY VIEWS FROM THIS UPDATED HOME! Kitchen with Granite countertop, Laundry in Residence, office space off foyer. Partially Furnished! Carport! Island Reef is a serene waterfront community, one of the few Gulf to Bay community that offers many desirable amenities including: Beach, Boat Docks (lifts allowed) two lit tennis courts, pickleball, 2 fitness rooms, Kayak Storage, Library, Billiards, game room, clubhouse, two heated pools and Gas Grills, PET FRIENDLY! Tropical Gardens add to the appeal of Island Reef and this wonderful community is close to two of Siesta Key’s popular restaurants. Complimentary trolley to Siesta Beach, Siesta Village for dining, shopping, ice cream, mini donuts, cut brunch spots and dancing and live music every night of the week!
35 SANDY COVE RD #2A, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$925,000234 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4653716
REDUCED by $50,000 (5.1%) on 05/08/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Gar: 1 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1254 Built: 1970 Tax: $7,373 (2025)Community: Sandy CoveCondo
Taxes:$7,373
Remarks: Sandy Cove – Mid-Century Modern Gulf Front Paradise: Period-preserved mid-century architecture meets breathtaking Gulf front water views in this exceptional Siesta Key residence. Located in Sandy Cove, a hidden gem and distinguished 1970s development of villas and mid-rises, this fifth-floor residence offers a panoramic vista over Big Pass to Lido, Bird Key, and downtown Sarasota—a guaranteed "wow" moment. Sandy Cove Condos was designed in 1969 by Frank Folsom Smith with James Holliday and James Durden, earning a 1970 AIA Florida Award for architectural excellence. This light-filled, architecturally preserved residence is over 1,200 square feet with two bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a thoughtful split floor plan. Upon arrival, you're greeted by a charming garden courtyard that offers a glimpse into the home. Step inside and be captivated by the spectacular living room featuring soaring vaulted ceilings that provide ample natural light and an airy, open ambiance. Enjoy breathtaking Gulf water views from your living room and kitchen sliders, which open seamlessly to your private patio. The sliders pull back to welcome Gulf breezes throughout the entire residence, connecting to several delightful porches and patios—including an additional private palm tree patio with IPE decking. A rare and highly coveted feature: this residence includes a private one-car garage. Gulf front residences in Sandy Cove rarely become available, making this a unique chance to own a piece of Siesta Key's architectural history. The home has potential to be sold furnished and is offered in as-is condition, presenting an opportunity for buyers to customize their personal vision. Ideally situated close to Siesta Key Village—just a short distance away, this truly unique location offers a natural private beach exclusive to the community, along with a fishing pier. Come see this truly "if you know, you know" treasure on Siesta Key.
Listing Agent: Mickey Kiernan (941-402-9115)
1300 N PORTOFINO DR #S206, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$410,000115 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4680023
1 Days Off yellowkey (back on 5/8/2026)
REDUCED by $15,000 (3.5%) on 04/20/2026
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 929 Built: 1969 Tax: $4,437 (2025)Community: Siesta Harbor IiCondo
Taxes:$4,437
Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Experience the best of waterfront living in this beautifully updated and fully furnished second-floor condo in the highly sought-after Siesta Harbor community. This TURNKEY 2-bedroom, 2-bath residence offers stunning canal and marina views and a prime location just steps from direct beach access across the street through Crescent Arms. Immaculately maintained and move-in ready, the condo features an enclosed lanai with horizontal sliding windows, tasteful furnishings, and thoughtful updates throughout for comfort and relaxation. The spacious open-concept living and dining areas flow seamlessly into a modern kitchen showcasing white cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ample storage. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and a stand-up shower, while the enclosed lanai provides the perfect spot to enjoy morning coffee or evening cocktails year-round, with dolphins frequently seen playing in the marina. Siesta Harbor is a vibrant 55+ waterfront boating community situated on its own canal and the main waterway of the Intracoastal Waterway. Boat slips may be available for vessels up to 30' (check with the office for availability). Residents enjoy resort-style activities, and amenities including a heated pool, outdoor jacuzzi and shower, indoor sauna, fitness room, shuffleboard court, fishing pier with seating on the ICW, and a beautifully renovated clubhouse with full kitchen, outstanding library, barbecue area with grills, and a full calendar of social activities. Additional highlights include FOB-accessed private beach access, FREE laundry on the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th floors, one designated covered carport parking space, ample guest parking, covered parking, an on-site manager, lush tropical landscaping, and a new roof (2025). Ideally located near the South Bridge, this community offers easy on-and-off access to the Key, is within short distance to restaurants and shops, and has the free Siesta Key trolley stopping right in front of the complex for easy access to Siesta Key Public Beach and Siesta Key Village. Whether you're watching boats drift by on the Intracoastal, crossing the street for unforgettable sunsets, or enjoying the active social lifestyle, this property is perfect as a vacation retreat, full-time residence, or investment opportunity. You deserve paradise!
Listing Agent: David Anthony (941-786-4282)
5880 MIDNIGHT PASS RD #804, SARASOTA, FL 34242
$1,350,000112 Days on yellowkey MLS ID: A4680425
Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Liv Area Sq Ft: 1498 Built: 1982 Tax: $11,821 (2025)Community: CasarinaSpa: YesCondo
Taxes:$11,821
Remarks: An unusual price for an unusual seaside residence. Completely renovated with stunning views from every window. Enjoy your morning coffee on the lanai and relish the downtown skyline as well as the Gulf of Mexico and Siesta Beach. Renovations include completely repainted, impact resistance windows, new interior doors, closet organizers and new front door. Casarina amenities include heated pool/spa, pickle ball/tennis courts, exercise room, gas grills, etc. This is worth a visit to see everything you can bring into your life.
Listing Agent: Linda Stowe (941-228-5685)
Please select an email frequency other than None since you have chosen for us to email you with changes that match your search.