Homes For Sale in Arcadia 34266 - 88 homes

Remarks: Some homes just feel comfortable the second you pull into the driveway… and this one absolutely does. This solid concrete block, 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom home checks so many boxes with its durable metal roof, split bedroom floor plan, tile flooring throughout, and a layout that simply works for real life. The primary suite is oversized and tucked away for privacy with a large walk-in closet and plenty of room to truly spread out. Right in the heart of the home, the kitchen keeps everyone connected with tons of countertop space for meal prepping, homework sessions, holiday baking, or hosting friends on game day. Step outside and you’ll find a fully privacy fenced backyard that’s ready for pets, playtime, backyard barbecues, or simply enjoying your own little slice of peace and quiet. There’s even a storage shed for all the extras. And the curb appeal? So good. A sprawling shade tree anchors the front yard and practically begs for a picnic table underneath it, while the front porch feels made for sweet tea sipping and slow evenings. Located just minutes from everything we love about Arcadia including local schools, charming antique shopping, cozy cafés, and the beloved local bookstore, this home offers comfort, convenience, and that small-town Florida lifestyle people are constantly searching for.

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (863-494-9009)

Listing Agent: Brandi Long (863-990-7256)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Historic Potential Meets Modern Vision on Oak Street. A Masterpiece in the Making. Rarely does an opportunity arise to claim a piece of Florida’s history and mold it exactly to your taste. Located on the iconic, tree-lined Oak Street in the heart of Arcadia’s historic district, this residence is ready for its next chapter. The property has been meticulously gutted to the studs, offering a true "blank canvas" for the visionary buyer. Forget the limitations of someone else’s floor plan—this is an open-pallet opportunity where you can dictate the layout, finishes, and modern amenities while preserving the timeless architectural integrity of a historic exterior. Property Highlights: Prime Location: Situated on one of Arcadia’s most desirable and recognizable historic streets, walking distance to local antique shops and dining. Ready for Build-Out: All demolition and debris removal are complete, saving you weeks of labor and significant cost. Architectural Heritage: Large window openings and classic structural lines provide the perfect foundation for a high-end restoration. Total Customization: Ideal for an investor looking for a high-value flip or a homeowner dreaming of a custom historic estate without the typical "hidden surprises" of a renovation. Bring your architect, your contractor, and your imagination. This is more than just a house; it’s a chance to build your dream home within the shell of a classic Arcadia treasure. Schedule your private tour today and see the potential for yourself.

Listing is courtesy of: REMAX LANDMARK (863-722-0523)

Listing Agent: Akos Jankura (727-773-7829)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Welcome to this charming home in southeast Arcadia, where space, privacy, and comfort come together. Set on a generous 1.44 acre lot, this property offers room to spread out, enjoy the outdoors, and create the lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of whether that means space for animals, hobbies, or simply a little extra breathing room. There have been many major improvements to the house giving you peace of mind from day one. Recent improvements include a newer roof, A/C system, hot water heater, new counter tops, screened-in porch, fresh interior paint, New garage door and updated appliances. Inside, the home features a bright, open layout with split bedrooms and abundant natural light. French doors welcome you into the foyer and continue through the living and dining areas, opening to the newly screened back porch where greenery and shade create a relaxing outdoor retreat. Additional highlights include a brick wood-burning fireplace, a dedicated laundry room, a mud room, and thoughtful storage throughout. The west side of the property offers a separate entrance to the home, ideal for added privacy or future outdoor enhancements. A standout feature is the approximately 1,100-square-foot detached garage with double bay doors, providing excellent space for a workshop, storage, or recreational toys. Located just outside of town, this home offers a peaceful setting while still being close to shopping, dining, and daily conveniences. Septic, irrigation, and drain field were updated in 2016. With solid upgrades already in place, all that’s left is to add your personal touch and make this home your own. Schedule your own personal tour today!

Listing is courtesy of: SELLSTATE VISION REALTY (941-336-5400)

Listing Agent: Savannah Zarris (941-807-4304)

Remarks: Escape to a stunning farmhouse-style retreat on 15 peaceful acres. Located at 5826 Hwy 72, this property is ideal as a personal residence, an income-producing Airbnb, or a private weekend escape. It features a 1-bed, 1-bath barn loft, a 4-bedroom, 2-bath home, a large barn perfect for entertaining, and plenty of space for all your animals. A long private driveway welcomes you in and leads to the charming home, where an open floor plan keeps the space bright and easy to enjoy. The bedrooms are spacious, and the primary suite offers a walk-in shower and timeless farmhouse details. The metal roof is in excellent condition, giving you extra peace of mind. The property is zoned for horses and offers endless outdoor fun. Spend your days fishing in the large scenic pond, grilling with friends, or relaxing beneath the beautiful mature oak trees. The kitchen opens to both the screened-in front porch and the covered back porch, perfect for enjoying quiet mornings or sunset views. With all 15 acres fully fenced and gated, you’ll have room to spread out and enjoy true country living. You’re just minutes from Downtown Arcadia, I-75, and everything Southwest Florida has to offer, while still being able to slip away into your own private oasis at any time. This property is full of southern charm and endless opportunity. Schedule your own personal tour today!

Listing is courtesy of: SELLSTATE VISION REALTY (941-336-5400)

Listing Agent: Savannah Zarris (941-807-4304)

Remarks: PRIVATE FLORIDA COUNTRY ESTATE – Prices are going up! Arcadia is the new place to be! Opportunity is knocking! Behind the beautiful Chicago brick entry lies the opportunity of a lifetime. Imagine a stunning courtyard home centered around a magnificent resort-style pool, creating a private sanctuary unlike any other. With generous room to expand, this exceptional property is ready for your vision to become reality. One Acre. Endless Possibilities. Discover the perfect blend of privacy, charm, and opportunity at 1508 Arcadia Avenue. Nestled beneath majestic oak trees on over one beautifully landscaped acre, this move-in-ready ranch offers peaceful country living with convenient access to Sarasota, Venice, Punta Gorda, Gulf Coast beaches, shopping, dining, and recreation. Filled with natural light, the home features soaring ceilings, expansive windows, an open-concept floor plan, Chicago brick accents, a cozy fireplace, gas appliances, barn doors, and inviting spaces designed for comfortable living and effortless entertaining. Whether your style is modern farmhouse, coastal farmhouse, classic country, or contemporary, this home is the perfect canvas to create your dream residence. The existing Chicago brick courtyard offers an exciting opportunity to design a private outdoor oasis with a pool, entertaining area, and privacy wall, creating a truly memorable entrance and exceptional outdoor living space. The spacious corner parcel provides room for a guest house, workshop, RV garage, boat storage, gardens, or simply plenty of space to enjoy the Florida lifestyle. Property Highlights: • Over one beautifully landscaped acre • Prime corner lot • Open-concept floor plan • Soaring ceilings and abundant natural light • Fireplace and gas appliances • Chicago brick courtyard • Barn doors and architectural character • Fenced dog run • Two-car garage • Room for a pool, RVs, boats, and future expansion Ideal as a primary residence, seasonal getaway, vacation home, or investment opportunity, this property offers outstanding flexibility and value. Recently appraised at over $450,000 and now offered at a reduced price, presenting an exceptional opportunity for today’s buyers. Arcadia continues to experience exciting growth, making this an excellent time to invest in one of Southwest Florida’s emerging markets. Move-in ready, easy to show, and priced to sell. Schedule your private showing today and discover the possibilities of this exceptional property!

Listing is courtesy of: ILLUSTRATED PROPERTIES LLC (CO (561-626-7000)

Listing Agent: Island Iris Mcdonald (561-400-5607)

Remarks: Looking for a slice of sunny paradise? This gem in a friendly 55+ community has everything you need for easy, breezy Florida living—and it comes with land ownership, no lot rent! With two split bedrooms, two bathrooms, and newer flooring throughout, this home is the perfect retreat for seasonal snowbirds or anyone craving a simpler pace year-round. The open kitchen, living, and dining space is ideal for hosting friends or enjoying peaceful mornings with sunshine pouring in. There’s even an indoor laundry area for added convenience. The screened-in porch is an added bonus along with the serene lake views—a little slice of Old Florida charm right in your backyard. Outside, you’ll appreciate the one-car carport and plenty of room to enjoy the warm breeze. Located less than an hour from I-75, airports, beaches, golf, and top-tier medical care, plus all the antique shops and charm of downtown Arcadia, this home is both a steal and a lifestyle. All this under $90,000? Pack your bags—paradise is calling!

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (863-494-9009)

Listing Agent: Brandi Long (863-990-7256)

Remarks: Don’t miss this exceptional opportunity to own a beautifully designed, custom-built brick home nestled on two spacious lots in the highly desirable Voss Oaks Subdivision. *This expansive residence offers 5 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, thoughtfully updated and filled with upscale finishes and conveniences. You'll find elegant crown molding and ceiling fans throughout, enhancing both comfort and style. *The eat-in kitchen is a chef’s dream, featuring granite countertops, a double oven, and a seamless flow into the large family room, where a cozy wood-burning fireplace creates a perfect gathering space. Retreat to the impressive 15’ x 31’ master suite, a true sanctuary of space and comfort. *Additional modern conveniences include a central vacuum system and a alarm system for peace of mind. *Step outside to your personal oasis—an oversized 13’ x 56’ screened back porch overlooking a newly resurfaced 15’ x 34’ heated saltwater pool, all within a fully enclosed lanai. An additional 16’ x 12’ open-air porch is ideal for outdoor cooking and entertaining. *Car enthusiasts and hobbyists will appreciate the attached 25’ x 22’ garage and a massive detached 25’ x 35’ garage, fully insulated with spray foam and equipped with air conditioning. *Situated among mature oak trees and lush landscaping, the home also features a sprinkler system to keep the grounds pristine year-round. Additional Lots are available under separate contract. *This home truly offers the perfect blend of luxury, functionality, and location. Schedule your private showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: TIMOTHY D BACKER (863-494-7075)

Listing Agent: Timothy Backer (863-494-7075)

Remarks: Charming and full of character, this Arcadia property offers the perfect blend of comfort and classic Florida living. Located on a quiet street, this home welcomes you with a spacious front porch, ideal for morning coffee or relaxing evenings in a peaceful setting. This expansive home features 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and 1,951 square feet of living space, providing plenty of room for families, guests, or flexible living arrangements. Inside, you’ll find a bright and inviting layout with abundant natural light throughout. Upstairs, enjoy a second-story screened-in balcony—your own private retreat to take in the fresh air year-round, perfect for relaxing or entertaining without the bugs. Step outside to a generously sized yard with ample space for gardening, pets, or creating your own outdoor oasis. Situated just minutes from historic downtown Arcadia, this home places you in the heart of one of Florida’s most charming small-town districts. Spend your weekends exploring local antique shops, boutique stores, and art galleries, or enjoy dining at beloved local restaurants and cafés offering everything from casual bites to Southern-style comfort food. Known for its rich history, vibrant community events, and laid-back lifestyle, historic Arcadia offers a unique blend of charm and convenience. Enjoy monthly market days, seasonal festivals, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes this town truly special. Whether you're searching for a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or investment opportunity, this home delivers space, character, and lifestyle in a highly desirable location. Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of historic Arcadia!

Listing is courtesy of: ANYTIME REALTY LLC (941-564-6358)

Listing Agent: Joseph Ciarla (941-730-1247)

Remarks: This is the kind of investment opportunity that doesn't come around often! Situated on nearly half an acre with no lot rent, this income-producing property features two manufactured homes, each offering 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. Both homes are currently occupied by long-term tenants who have rented for decades, providing consistent, reliable rental income from day one. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or secure a property with established cash flow, this one checks all the boxes. With room to grow and proven rental history, this is a smart opportunity for both seasoned and first-time investors. (One home rents for $325/month and the other for $425/month) *Please do not disturb the tenants or enter the property without a scheduled appointment.*

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (863-494-9009)

Listing Agent: Brandi Long (863-990-7256)

Remarks: Step into timeless charm with this beautifully restored historic home located at 503 N Polk St in Arcadia, Florida. Expertly and meticulously renovated by a master carpenter, this one-of-a-kind residence showcases exceptional craftsmanship throughout. Nearly every detail has been thoughtfully recreated by hand—from the custom doors and trim to the intricate woodwork—preserving the home's historic character while providing the comfort and quality of a modern renovation. Situated on a fenced corner lot, the property offers both privacy and curb appeal. A welcoming front porch invites you to relax and enjoy the peaceful neighborhood, perfectly capturing the charm of classic Florida living. Inside, you’ll find a warm and inviting interior where the artistry of the renovation truly shines. The handcrafted woodwork adds depth and authenticity rarely found in today’s homes, creating a space that feels both historic and unique. Located close to Historic Downtown Arcadia, you’ll enjoy easy access to local shops, dining, antique stores, and community events that make this charming town so special. This is a rare opportunity to own a fully restored historic home where craftsmanship, character, and location come together beautifully.

Listing is courtesy of: REMAX LANDMARK (863-722-0523)

Listing Agent: Akos Jankura (727-773-7829)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Tucked behind a gated entry, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and laid-back country living. Settled on almost 1 acre of private land and offering a circular driveway, warm natural light, and inviting open-concept design makes this home feel both welcoming and thoughtfully crafted. Inside, upgraded finishes like luxury vinyl plank flooring, crown molding, tray ceilings, and custom accents create a polished yet comfortable atmosphere throughout. The heart of the home is the beautifully designed kitchen featuring a large island with farmhouse sink, LG ThinQ stainless steel appliances, and plenty of space to gather, entertain, or simply enjoy everyday living. The spacious primary suite feels like a private retreat with a spa-inspired bathroom complete with a soaking tub, frameless glass shower, dual vanities, and oversized walk-in closet. Additional bedrooms offer flexibility for guests, hobbies, or a home office while the oversized laundry room and custom mudroom add everyday functionality. Step outside and you’ll quickly see what makes this property truly special. The expansive L-shaped deck with shaded seating area creates the ideal space for relaxing evenings, weekend cookouts, or enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Beyond the home, the fully fenced property also includes an insulated workshop with A/C and electric, an additional utility shed with water and power, and plenty of room to spread out and enjoy the lifestyle this property was designed for. Beautifully maintained and move-in ready, this one-of-a-kind Arcadia property combines charm, upgrades, and versatility in a setting that feels like home the moment you arrive.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (813-685-7755)

Listing Agent: Trish Mccullough-Johnson (239-994-2804)

Remarks: Welcome to this charming 4-bedroom, 2 bathroom single-wide mobile home seated on just over half an acre, offering plenty of space and privacy. The property features a detached 2-car carport that can also be used as a workshop-perfect for storage, hobbies, or projects. Conveniently located near shops, restaurants, and downtown Arcadia, this home combines peaceful living with easy access to everyday essentials. You don't want to miss out on this opportunity of owning a piece of paradise in the beautiful arcadia, call us now to schedule your private tour!

Listing is courtesy of: EXP REALTY LLC (863-494-9009)

Listing Agent: Ana Jaimes (863-781-6839)

Remarks: Welcome to your own private slice of Florida paradise! Nestled on 2.28 beautiful acres, this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is surrounded by breathtaking natural beauty, including majestic oak trees, lush ferns, and mature Florida landscaping that create a serene and inviting setting. Lovingly maintained and thoughtfully remodeled, the home offers comfortable living with tasteful updates throughout, making it truly move-in ready. Step outside to enjoy the newly installed deck, the perfect place to relax, entertain, or take in the peaceful views of your picturesque property. Whether you’re looking for a quiet retreat, a full-time residence, or a property with room to enjoy nature, this one delivers the space and tranquility you’ve been searching for. Best of all, the seller is highly motivated, presenting an excellent opportunity to make this beautiful acreage property your own. Don’t miss your chance to experience the best of Florida country living!

Listing is courtesy of: SELLSTATE VISION REALTY (941-336-5400)

Listing Agent: Jeorgia Sutton (941-336-5400)

Remarks: Secluded Creekside Stilt Cabin in the Woods- 17 Acres with a lake. Discover the peaceful, scenic retreat you’ve been dreaming of. This elevated cabin sits tucked away on 17 acres in a beautiful rural setting, surrounded by woods, open pasture, and a private lake. Prairie Creek, a natural tributary of the Peace River, flows just steps from your door—perfect for fishing, canoeing, kayaking, or swimming. Towering oaks, swaying palms, and native foliage provide cool shade and a haven for songbirds, waterfowl, and other wildlife. Ideal for nature lovers or anyone seeking tranquility with room for livestock.Inside, the home features a cozy living and dining room combination, a well-equipped kitchen, and two comfortable bedrooms with a shared full bath. Step outside to a spacious patio—ideal for gathering around a BBQ grill or firepit under the stars. Below the stilt cabin, there’s room to park a small car or store your yard tools and gear.

Listing is courtesy of: UNITED COUNTRY GULFLAND R.E. (863-494-2100)

Listing Agent: Mac Martin (863-494-2100)

Remarks: Auction Property. Auction Opportunity — Spacious 2BR/3BA Two-Story Home on Nearly ¾-Acre Cul-de-Sac Lot in Arcadia! This 1,611 SF residence sits on a gorgeous 34,000+ SF lot (Lots 7 & 8, Block B) in the Orange Heights 1st Addition, offering privacy and room to spread out. The two-story layout features a first-floor living room, kitchen, and guest bedroom, with the primary suite upstairs — both bedrooms with built-in closets. A huge front Florida room adds versatile living and entertaining space, while a storage shed out back rounds out the functionality. Block and wood frame construction on a slab foundation with central A/C and central heat. Well water and septic — no monthly utility surprises. Zoned RMF-M on a quiet cul-de-sac with southwest-facing front exposure and paved road access. No HOA, no CDD, Flood Zone X. Reserve auction — buyers must register and bid. All auction properties subject to a buyer's premium per Event Agreement and Auction Terms & Conditions. Buyers and buyer's agent to verify all information. Occupants are not to be disturbed. One or more photos are virtually staged.

Listing is courtesy of: ALLISON JAMES ESTATES & HOMES (941-500-4922)

Listing Agent: Jonathan Marshman (941-268-0324)

Remarks: Welcome to this beautiful newer construction 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offering the perfect blend of comfort and style! Step inside to a spacious open-concept layout featuring a large living room and an inviting kitchen complete with stunning granite countertops, ample cabinetry, and plenty of room for gathering with family and friends. The split-bedroom floor plan provides privacy and functionality, while the generously sized bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy a fully fenced backyard—ideal for pets, play, or weekend barbecues. A large metal building provides excellent additional storage, workshop space, or room for your hobbies and equipment. Perfect for entertaining both indoors and out, this home is conveniently located near schools, restaurants, and shopping, making everyday living a breeze. Don’t miss this move-in ready gem!

Listing is courtesy of: REMAX LANDMARK (863-722-0523)

Listing Agent: Jose Zamora (863-444-8297)

Remarks: Under contract-accepting backup offers. Welcome to this charming home waiting for the perfect family! This property features 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, offering a comfortable layout ideal for everyday living. The home includes a large backyard, providing plenty of space for children to play and for pets to enjoy the outdoors. The beautiful, quiet backyard is shaded by large oak trees, creating the perfect setting for relaxing evenings, outdoor cooking, and family gatherings. Whether you're entertaining guests or simply enjoying a peaceful afternoon, this backyard offers the perfect retreat. Conveniently located and full of potential, this home is ready for its next family to create lasting memories. Don't miss the opportunity to schedule your showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: MAHE REALTY LLC (813-451-8221)

Listing Agent: Daniel Echevarria (813-451-8221)

Remarks: Tucked away on a peaceful half-acre, this well-cared-for home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and quiet living—just minutes from Historic Downtown Arcadia. From the moment you arrive, the large covered and screened front porch invites you to slow down and enjoy the surroundings. Inside, the layout is both practical and flexible, featuring two generously sized bedrooms plus a third room that can easily serve as an additional bedroom, office, or hobby space. The primary suite is complemented by its own den/office area, creating a private retreat within the home. An enclosed Florida room adds even more living space, perfect for relaxing year-round. Built to last, the home features a durable metal roof and has proven its strength through past storms. An attached storage area with electricity provides added convenience for tools, projects, or extra storage. Outside, you’ll find a cozy fire pit—ideal for quiet evenings under the stars. If you’re looking for a move-in ready home that offers peaceful living without sacrificing proximity to town, this one is well worth a look.

Listing is courtesy of: RE/MAX PALM REALTY (941-743-5525)

Listing Agent: Priscilla Perez-Mcguire (941-875-5747)

Remarks: Beautiful 4/2 home conveniently located near schools, shopping, restaurants and just a short walk to historic downtown!! This home is energy efficient with 6" solid poured concrete walls and a BRAND NEW metal roof for low energy and insurance cost! Home has been completely remodeled inside with new kitchen cabinets and countertops, tile flooring throughout, freshly painted and new kitchen appliances. The property is almost completely fenced for privacy and comes with shed for storage. Come see this beautiful home and make it your own!!!

Listing is courtesy of: REMAX LANDMARK (863-722-0523)

Listing Agent: Jose Zamora (863-444-8297)

Remarks: Charming 2/1 home with a bonus room! Centrally located close to schools, shopping, restaurants and the historic downtown Arcadia. The property features Tile flooring throughout the home, metal roof, recently remodeled bathroom and a fenced in backyard. Great for entertaining and family gatherings. Make your appointment for a private showing today!

Listing is courtesy of: REMAX LANDMARK (863-722-0523)

Listing Agent: Jose Zamora (863-444-8297)