Homes for Sale Near Bayshore High in Longboat Key - 74 homes

Remarks: Tucked away on one of Longboat Key’s most unexpectedly serene streets, this elevated 3-bedroom island home offers something increasingly rare: space, privacy, nature, and convenient coastal living, all in one place. Set at the end of a quiet, dead-end road that gently meets Sarasota Bay, with deeded access to both the beach and the bay just moments away. Life here unfolds at an unhurried pace. Mornings begin on the porch with filtered sunlight and birdsong drifting in from Joan M. Durante Park, the 32-acre preserve that borders the property and wraps the street in natural beauty. Winding trails, mangroves, boardwalks, and bayfront docks become an extension of your backyard, offering a daily connection to the outdoors that feels both grounding and restorative. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully remodeled and is truly move-in ready, blending a relaxed coastal feel with modern comfort. The open-concept layout is light-filled and welcoming, anchored by a beautifully updated kitchen with quartz countertops, a generous island, and ample storage, perfect for everyday living or hosting friends who linger long after sunset. The primary suite is privately positioned, while additional bedrooms flex easily as guest space, a home office, or a creative retreat. Below, the spacious under-house garage offers exceptional versatility with room for cars, bikes, kayaks, paddleboards, or even a home gym, making island adventures effortless. At the entrance to the street, island life comes alive with Euphemia Haye Restaurant and The Haye Loft, ideal for impromptu dinners or sunset drinks without ever getting in the car. Beaches, boating, and quiet moments by the bay are all just part of the rhythm here. This is a home for those who value privacy without isolation, nature without sacrifice, and a lifestyle that feels intentional, calm, and deeply connected to Longboat Key.

Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-383-7591)

Listing Agent: Angela Scott (941-928-7462)

Remarks: NEW PRICE, AMAZING OPPORTUNITY!!! Experience the ultimate island lifestyle in this masterfully renovated 2,880 sqft, 4 Bed/3 Bath "lock-and-leave" condo at Cedars Tennis Resort and Club. Elevated sanctuary on the tranquil north end of Longboat Key. Offering the expansive feel of a single-family residence with the effortless "lock-and-leave" ease of being in the beautiful condo community of Cedars Tennis Resort and Club. This exquisite 4BR/3BA retreat defines coastal chic. A private elevator serves all three levels, opening into a sun-drenched great room with soaring ceilings, a fireplace, and a gourmet kitchen featuring dual islands and designer finishes. The refined dining room opens right off of this space with its custom built-in cabinetry and dry bar, ideal for any social gathering. Relax on your private, screened lanais overlooking lush tropical foliage and serene ponds, with peek-a-boo views of the Gulf. There is one on each living level. Rounding out the main living area is a versatile den/office (currently used as the 4th bedroom), a full third bathroom, beautiful hardwood floors throughout and a dedicated laundry room. The primary suite is a true oasis with a spa-inspired sunken bath, large walk-in shower, dual vanities and walk-in closets. Upstairs beyond the oasis of a primary there are two additional oversized guest bedrooms and a beautifully renovated guest bathroom with a walk-in shower. Recent updates beyond the full interior renovation include 2026 garage door replacements, and 2024 roof and AC replacement. Hardi- Board siding on exterior and Pella high-impact windows. The split 3-car garage provides total peace of mind and the rare abundance of space and storage. Nestled in the 66-acre village-like townhome community enveloped by nature, providing effortless access to both the beach and the bay on the beautiful north end of Longboat Key. The spacious and tropical community features lit boardwalks winding through mangroves, leading to an array of exceptional amenities including a heated Jr. Olympic Size Pool, nine Har-Tru Tennis Courts, three Pickleball courts, a Clubhouse with a Pro-Shop, a 24-hour Fitness Center, a Tiki bar, a restaurant, a fishing pier, and a kayak launch. Please note that some amenities require an additional club membership. The property is within walking distance to a variety of local attractions, such as Harry's Deli & Continental Kitchen, the true island gem that is Joan Durante Park, Euphemia Haye Restaurant & The Haye Loft, and, of course, Longboat Key's globally renowned sugary white sand beaches. Furthermore, it offers convenient proximity to other major attractions and cultural venues, including St. Armand's Circle, Mote Aquarium, the Asolo Repertory Theatre, Van Zel Performing Arts Center, Marie Selby Gardens, Anna Maria Island, the Ringling Museum complex, and numerous dining options on Longboat Key and in downtown Sarasota. Cedars East is the rare community on LBK that offers shorter-term rental allowance with its 2-week minimum, making it the perfect balance for offsetting costs when not in use, without living in a hotel community. Exceptional onsite management is in place if desired. Fantastic residence, rare opportunity, come take a look today!

Listing is courtesy of: CENTURY 21 BEGGINS ENTERPRISES (813-658-2121)

Listing Agent: Jesse Griffin (941-822-6165)

Remarks: Tucked along a quiet canal in Longboat Key’s Sleepy Lagoon Park, 761 Norton Street delivers the kind of waterfront lifestyle that’s increasingly rare—equal parts boating-centric, resort-style, and built for hosting at scale. With 4 bedrooms, 4 ensuite baths, 3 half baths, and 4,674 square feet under air, the home is thoughtfully designed for those who want space and flexibility without sacrificing flow, comfort, or privacy, ideal for multi-generational living, extended stays, and entertaining without compromise. Constructed for exceptional strength and durability, this home offers solid concrete block walls on all levels with reinforced rebar, and hurricane-rated windows and doors. A travertine foyer filled with natural light and a planter with water feature sets the tone, complemented by a 5-stop elevator. This home features smart home functionality. The living level features an open-concept eat-in kitchen, appointed with wood cabinetry, stainless steel KitchenAid appliances, a beverage cooler, and cooktop, created to serve both everyday ease and elevated entertaining. Designed to maximize indoor-outdoor living, the home opens to a travertine pool deck anchored by an infinity-edge pool and spa, an outdoor shower, and an outdoor kitchen with a Coyote grill, a true backyard retreat that feels like a private resort. For boating enthusiasts, the property’s canal-front setting is enhanced by a 28,000-lb boat lift and lift for two jet skis, offering exceptional convenience for water access and day-to-day coastal living. Inside, architectural details add warmth and dimension, including a two-tone tray ceiling, travertine fireplace, and curated art niches along the hallway. Guest accommodations are generous and private, including multiple en-suite bedrooms with walk-in closets. One suite offers a walk-in shower and vanity, while another features a more spa-like bath with a Jacuzzi tub, dual vanities, a walk-in shower, and a water closet with a bidet. Adding to the home’s standout appeal is its rare, mirrored design, featuring an additional living level with a second kitchen/bar/living arrangement, as well as matching guest suites, creating two complete living experiences under one roof. Whether hosting seasonal guests, accommodating extended family, or simply wanting room to spread out, the layout provides the ultimate “together-but-separate” lifestyle. Additional highlights include a 4-car tandem garage, solid, poured concrete construction and a prime Longboat Key location. Experience the best of island living at this canal-front address featuring seamless access to the Bay, Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf waters. Just minutes away from St. Armand’s Circle, the new St. Regis, downtown Sarasota, and Anna Maria Island, you’re perfectly positioned near celebrated restaurants, boutique shopping, and culture. And from your own dock, the boating lifestyle becomes part of everyday life, with restaurants visible across the way and just a quick boat ride from home, it’s easy to head out for lunch, sunset cocktails, or a spontaneous evening on the water.

Listing is courtesy of: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN (941-867-6199)

Listing Agent: Joel Schemmel (941-587-4894)

Remarks: Sought after mid-key cottage home with DEEDED BEACH ACCESS on the barrier island of Longboat Key.  Entering the home, you are greeted by terrazzo floors, wood beam ceilings and a tile accented gas fireplace in the large living room.  An additional room overlooking screened in pool can be used as an office, exercise room or extra space for guests. Newly renovated kitchen with wood cabinets, quartz countertops, new sink and fixtures.  Bathrooms have been completely renovated with beautiful walk-in tiled showers. A built-in bookcase in the living room adds charm with plantation shutters, accent lighting and ceiling fans throughout. Completely restored home by licensed general contractor and professionally mitigated after hurricane Helene flood damage. The house shares a driveway and deeded beach access with 5920 Gulf of Mexico Drive making it a perfect guest house or family compound when purchased together. Another possibility is to use one as as a rental for an ongoing revenue stream. The property is being sold As-Is (use FAR-BAR-ASIS-7.

Listing is courtesy of: JOHN DONATO REAL ESTATE INC (941-504-4987)

Listing Agent: John Donato (941-504-4987)

Remarks: DEEDED BEACH ACCESS AND DEEP WATER CANAL at this beautifully renovated mid-key beach house on the barrier island of Longboat Key.  You can enjoy a 3-minute walk to the beach using your private beach access or step outside and enjoy the canal on your trex dock. The uncrowded beach with natural surroundings, fine sand beaches, warm breezes, and clear turquoise waters is truly a special place. Entering the home, you are greeted by terrazzo floors, stunning 2 story foyer and a water view of the canal.   All new wood kitchen cabinets including island and coffee bar with quartz countertops making this a great area to entertain guests.  All 3 bathrooms have been completely renovated and include custom tile showers. Large master bedroom with en-suite bathroom. An enclosed lanai overlooking the canal is a perfect spot for an office or tropical retreat. Large living room with wood burning fireplace and new tile flooring provides a relaxing space. New kitchen and bath fixtures throughout.  Ceiling fans in each room. Being in the middle of LBK provides easy access to Anna Maria Island and Bradenton to the north, St. Armands and Sarasota to the south. SRQ airport is less than 45 minutes. Completely restored home by licensed general contractor and professionally mitigated after hurricane Helene flood damage. The house shares a driveway, deeded beach and canal access with 5924 Gulf of Mexico Drive making it a perfect guest house or family compound when purchased together (or use one as a rental for an ongoing revenue stream}. The property is being sold as-is. Please use AS IS Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase_FloridaRealtors-FloridaBar-ASIS-7.xdp

Listing is courtesy of: JOHN DONATO REAL ESTATE INC (941-504-4987)

Listing Agent: John Donato (941-504-4987)

Remarks: The Future of Luxury Living on Longboat Key! Discover this newly constructed coastal retreat that sets the standard for modern waterfront living. Located on the private north end of Longboat Key, this turnkey-furnished residence is a sanctuary of style & elegance. Soaring 16-foot driftwood ceilings create an atmosphere of warmth and grandeur, while large impact glass sliders connect you seamlessly between indoor and outdoor living. From the porcelain tiles, custom cabinetry, quartzite countertops in the kitchen to the Italian glass vanities in every bathroom, this home has been constructed with every detail in mind. Enjoy customizable Lutron lighting, automatic shades, built in surround sound system, and a Brinks alarm system with CCTV cameras to protect it all. Looking outdoors, a fire pit, outdoor grill, luxury pool & spa with a waterfall, newly installed dock & 10,000 lb boat lift await you. Built to withstand the elements, this flood-resistant home remains untouched by storms & was powered throughout the storms with it's own generator, offering peace of mind and unmatched durability. Experience the perfect fusion of luxury, privacy, and coastal charm—schedule your private tour today.

Listing is courtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY (941-349-4411)

Listing Agent: Cole Collins (941-350-8360)

Remarks: Come savor laid-back luxury and the island lifestyle that Longboat Key is known for in this tranquil, seaside retreat. AND listed more than $100,000. under a current appraisal! This home is a decorators dream! Completely remodeled with a brand new kitchen, all new flooring, 4 bedrooms and 3 baths in an open and inviting space. The line is blurred between indoor and outdoor living with a gorgeous sparkling pool just beyond the mahogany French doors, surrounded by tropical plants and situated on a fabulous canal. For the boaters, you have a 14,000 lb. lift and no fixed bridges to the Gulf of Mexico, making your day on the water an easy experience. Nightly sunsets at the neighborhood beach is just a short walk away and something to make a regular habit of! A short distance to multiple restaurants, shopping, 12 miles of biking paths, and the incredible Joan Durante Park on the Bay only add to the remarkable quality of life living on an island can provide. When you’re ready for something more, St.Armands Circle and the cultural mecca of Downtown Sarasota is just a short drive away. This extraordinary home is a true island paradise you must come see.

Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-383-7591)

Listing Agent: Jodene Moneuse, Pa (941-302-4913)

Remarks: Welcome to Laguna Yacht Village on beautiful Longboat Key- a gated waterfront community located across the street from the beach, with private bay access. This fully furnished turnkey home is perfectly positioned to embrace the island lifestyle, with fantastic gulf views from almost every room. The home includes a deeded deep-water dock (Slip #6- boat lift included), located in a protected lagoon just minutes from the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf of Mexico with no fixed bridges, making it a boater’s dream. This modern Key West inspired three story single residence with an oversized 3-car garage features four bedrooms, three full baths, and over 2,886 square feet of beautifully designed living space. Perfectly positioned to embrace the island lifestyle, this home includes a deeded deep-water dock (Slip #6) located in a protected lagoon just minutes from the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf of Mexico — with no fixed bridges, making it a boater’s dream. Step inside and experience a harmonious blend of coastal elegance and comfort. Expansive living areas feature soaring ceilings, an abundance of natural light, and sophisticated finishes throughout. The culinary-inspired kitchen, designed in timeless style, boasts custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, and an oversized central island — the ideal space for hosting and entertaining. The primary suite, complete with a study, serves as a serene retreat with dual vanities, a hydro-massage soaking tub, and a walk-in glass-enclosed shower for the ultimate spa-like experience. Multiple balconies, including an elevated screened patio off the main level, provide refreshing sea breezes and captivating water views of the Gulf. A ground-floor patio further extends the outdoor living experience. The oversized garage provides ample storage for beach gear and boating essentials. The gated community features a resort-style pool offering a true lock-and-leave lifestyle. Residents will appreciate convenient proximity to Longboat Key’s pristine beach, award-winning island restaurants, boutique shopping, and parks — all while being a short drive from the cultural heart of downtown Sarasota and St. Armands Circle.

Listing is courtesy of: KELLER WILLIAMS ISLAND LIFE REAL ESTATE (941-254-6467)

Listing Agent: Brandy Loebker (941-404-4737)

Remarks: Experience the epitome of Island living in this meticulously kept and beautifully renovated retreat located in the beachfront community of The Westchester on Longboat Key. This ground floor walk-out, 2 bedroom, 2 bath residence is a true coastal oasis all done up in seaside hues. The gorgeous kitchen opens to the large living/dining area and the spectacular views can be seen through impact resistant sliding doors that open wide for easy indoor/outdoor living. Step out to one of two private screened in lanais and you'll find the perfect spot to enjoy a morning coffee or an evening beverage while watching the sunset. This home is being offered with all the designer furnishings, so all you’ll need to do is bring your flip flops. Here you will find a remarkable quality of laid back island life with the gorgeous beach that stretches for miles, 2 sparkling pools, a tennis and pickleball court, a shuffleboard court, and a lovely clubhouse. An on site manager is available Monday through Friday. If you're ready for more, fine dining and nightlife in the world famous St. Armands Circle and the cultural mecca of downtown Sarasota are just a short drive away. Important to note: The pool area is currently undergoing a transforamtion and will include a new spa, a tiki hut and new landscaping when complete. Also important: The Westchester has completed its Milestone Inspection and all assessments have been paid in full.

Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-383-7591)

Listing Agent: Jodene Moneuse, Pa (941-302-4913)

Remarks: DIRECT WATERFRONT OPPORTUNITY IN LONGBOAT KEY! Here's your rare chance to own a waterfront property with direct access to the Intercoastal Waterway! Perfectly located for vacation rentals, this canal-front 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom end unit offers incredible potential for income, especially with high demand bookings from January to April. This property boasts 21 feet of water frontage and a newly installed seawall (June 2021). Enjoy the Florida lifestyle with easy access to boating, kayaking, and fishing. Additional outdoor amenities include a paver patio. Just steps away from a private beach access, kayak launch, and deeded beach entry. The property also has direct access to the scenic Joan M. Durante Park, with 32 acres of walking trails, gardens, recreational areas, and breathtaking Sarasota Bay views. Take a short walk to top-rated restaurants, shops, a deli, bike and kayak rentals, and more. Plus, you're just a short drive to St. Armands Circle and Anna Maria Island! This is the most economical waterfront property you'll find in all of Longboat Key!

Listing is courtesy of: NIZZ REALTY INC (954-526-5105)

Listing Agent: Filitsa Sterner Mistretta (941-928-3666)

Remarks: One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Boaters will love this spacious elevated home in a premier waterfront location on Longboat Key with dock, lift and by boat it is just four homes from the intercoastal, open bay waters and a short boat ride to the Gulf. Built for large gatherings, this home is beautifully designed with loads of gathering and entertaining spaces. The open plan home was thoughtfully designed with five bedrooms, four with en-suite baths. The kitchen features custom wood cabinets and granite countertops. Entertaining will be a breeze with two large gathering spaces, including a great room with dining area and adjacent bonus room that would be a wonderful media or game room. Ground level highlights include two bonus areas and a huge four-car garage. The composite dock has a 10,000-pound boat lift, water and electric. Recent updates include hurricane windows and doors (2025), metal roof (2025), pool equipment and pool heater (2025) and interior freshly painted. This location on Longboat Key can't be beat with community beach access just across the street, and a heated pool and boating in your own backyard. This is the ideal home to create wonderful island memories.

Listing is courtesy of: PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY (941-364-4000)

Listing Agent: Holly Switow (941-735-3186)

Remarks: A rare offering on Florida’s coveted west coast, this private island sanctuary feels worlds away yet remains moments from the region’s most beloved coastal destinations. Set on the exclusive 38-acre island of Jewfish Key (accessible only by boat), this remarkable 1.35-acre estate commands its own secluded shoreline and uninterrupted views of crystal clear waters. Inspired by Polynesian architecture and designed to dissolve the boundaries between indoors and out, this estate home unfolds through airy pavilions connected by elevated walkways. Towering palms and lush tropical landscaping envelop the home, while its 18-foot elevation ensures both peace of mind and panoramic, horizon-level vistas. Inside, the freshly reimagined kitchen serves as the gathering heart of the home, with sleek quartz countertops, modern cabinetry, and a spacious oversized island that effortlessly bridges culinary function and relaxed entertaining. Expansive sliding glass doors draw natural light into the living space and frame sweeping views of the sandbar and bay, perfect for sunset watching. The main residence includes four bedrooms and four-and-a-half baths, plus a separate guest suite offering an additional bedroom, kitchen, and full bath, ideal for hosting with comfort and privacy. The primary suite is where the pace of the island truly settles in. Wake up to wide-open bay views, linger with coffee in the sitting area, or enjoy a glass of wine as the sun sinks toward the horizon. The ensuite feels fresh and spa-like, with a soaking tub, walk-in shower, and water views. A series of screened porches and wraparound decks encourage slow living, morning yoga on the deck, afternoon reading in the shade, sunset grilling and cocktails overlooking the Gulf. Outdoors, a newly installed pool and spa with a sun shelf and expansive sundeck overlook the storied Jewfish Key Sandbar. A private dock with jet ski lift offers instant access to calm waters perfect for fishing, snorkeling, paddle boarding, or exploring neighboring Longboat Key and Anna Maria Island, both just minutes away by boat and beloved for dining, boutique shopping, and laid-back coastal culture. Equal parts island hideaway and refined coastal home, this one-of-a-kind property offers the rare combination of true privacy, effortless access, and natural beauty, set against a backdrop of turquoise water, powder soft sand, and endless sky. Here, relaxation, adventure, and natural beauty converge in a setting that feels almost like an escape, yet unmistakably home.

Listing is courtesy of: SIGHT REAL ESTATE, LLC (877-361-0878)

Listing Agent: Chase Moore (727-325-7272)

Remarks: Beautifully renovated in 2023, with dazzling views of the Gulf of Mexico and the private beach across the way, this 2nd floor island retreat is located in a charming Gulf-to-Bay community, nestled between the azure blue water of the Gulf of Mexico and serene Bishops Bayou, where Manatees & Dolphins play. This lovely 2nd level end-unit features an open floor plan, enhanced by a gorgeous designer kitchen with quartz countertop & backsplash and bronze hardware, which overlooks the dining-living room combo, all offering Gulf views. The Florida room overlooks one of the two sparkling swimming pools, which are at your disposal. Hurricane resistant sliding doors and windows offer peace of mind, and the roof has recently been replaced. Luxury vinyl flooring extends all the way through the living space, including the primary suite, which is tucked away for optimal privacy. The screened front patio is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the turquoise water views, and there is a 9' x 5' storage room for all your toys. Just bring your flip flops & beach wear and start enjoying the laid-back island lifestyle. Two heated pool, tennis & pickleball courts, 23 boat slips, a vintage boathouse/clubhouse, grilling stations, kayak launch, shuffleboard, private deeded beach directly across the road with gazebos and beach lounges plus those amazing sunsets. Two large pets are welcome and the condo can be rented 6 times per year with one month minimum. After a fun-filled day kayaking, beach strolling, fishing or boating, first-class restaurants and casual eateries are located within a short walk, bike or boat ride. Coffee, smoothie & donut shops, liquor store, 24-hour gym, Pilates studio & beauty salon, boutiques and more are just a block away. Don't miss this wonderful opportunity to make your dreams of living on Longboat Key come true!

Listing is courtesy of: ROSEBAY INTERNATIONAL REALTY, INC (941-366-7673)

Listing Agent: Tina Rudek Stark, Pa (941-920-0303)

Remarks: Your easy island escape awaits in the beach-to-bay community of Sutton Place on Longboat Key. Spend your days at the deeded Gulf beach, lounging by one of two heated pools, kayaking on the bay, or heading out on the water—all within the community. This two-bedroom townhome is ideal for seasonal or year round living, offering impact windows and doors, steel roof trusses, and a private oversized garage for bikes, beach chairs, and island gear. The renovated kitchen features quartz countertops and Bosch appliances, and both bedrooms include walk-in closets and fully tiled baths. Unwind on two enclosed balconies overlooking a tranquil pond, then lock up and travel with confidence. Centrally located mid-island, Sutton Place offers the perfect blend of resort-style amenities in a beautiful setting.

Listing is courtesy of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY (941-951-6660)

Listing Agent: Sherri Mills (941-350-7112)