REFINE SEARCH
Status
Keywords
Price
 
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Garages
Liv Area Sq Ft
Min Year
Max Year
Property Types
No Image
Age Restricted
Foreclosure
Short Sale
Pets Allowed
Furnished
Pool
Spa
Reduced Price
Back on yellowkey
Possible Short Term Rental
Carports
Max Association Fee (monthly)
Max Monthly Payment
Search

Lake Panasoffkee Single Family Homes For Sale - 30 homes

Lake Panasoffkee Single Family Homes for Sale are located in Sumter County, Florida. Find single family homes for sale in Lake Panasoffkee with data from the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). Our REALTORS® can assist you in your real estate search for Lake Panasoffkee single family houses.

Location: Lake Panasoffkee

Sort:
  • 2381 CR 423 #Lot 41, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $225,000290 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5102927

    For Sale G5102927 - 2381 CR 423 #Lot 41, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 18 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1068
       Built: 2025   Tax: $42 (2024)
    Community: Indian Estates
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,236 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,233) + Taxes in 2024 ($3)


    Taxes:$42

    Elementary School: Bushnell Elementary School

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 1082 CR 457, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $150,00015 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5114120

    0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 7/20/2026)

    For Sale G5114120 - 1082 CR 457, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 20 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1386
       Built: 1983
    Monthly Fee: $3
       Tax: $1,752 (2025)
    Community: Blk A 2Nd Add
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $971 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($822) + Fees ($3) + Taxes in 2025 ($146)


    Taxes:$1,752

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 853 CR 484, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $172,000195 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5106286

    For Sale G5106286 - 853 CR 484, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 38 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 930
       Built: 1973   Tax: $645 (2025)
    Community: Panasoffkee Retreats
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $996 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($942) + Taxes in 2025 ($54)


    Taxes:$645

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 1289 CR 436, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $185,70087 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5111514

    0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 7/19/2026)

    REDUCED by $100 (0.1%) on 07/13/2026

    For Sale G5111514 - 1289 CR 436, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 38 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 1.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1308
       Built: 1990   Tax: $1,220 (2025)
    Community: Emert Acres
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,119 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,018) + Taxes in 2025 ($102)


    Taxes:$1,220

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 557 COUNTY ROAD 487, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $284,5007 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5115070

    For Sale G5115070 - 557 COUNTY ROAD 487, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 13 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1396
       Built: 2026   Tax: $179 (2025)
    Community: Magnolia Manor
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,574 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,559) + Taxes in 2025 ($15)


    Taxes:$179

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 1141 COUNTY ROAD 457, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $203,00047 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5113351

    For Sale G5113351 - 1141 COUNTY ROAD 457, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 50 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 1.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1284
       Built: 1978
    Monthly Fee: $3
       Tax: $820 (2025)
    Community: 2Nd Add Tracys Pt
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,184 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,112) + Fees ($3) + Taxes in 2025 ($68)


    Taxes:$820

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 1244 COUNTY ROAD 437, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $179,00036 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5113843

    REDUCED by $20,000 (10.1%) on 07/11/2026

    For Sale G5113843 - 1244 COUNTY ROAD 437, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 50 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1204
       Built: 1983
    Monthly Fee: $3
       Tax: $1,719 (2025)
    Community: Tracys Point 3Rd Add
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,127 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($981) + Fees ($3) + Taxes in 2025 ($143)


    Taxes:$1,719

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 2345 CR 453, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $234,90031 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: OM726925

    REDUCED by $20,099 (7.9%) on 07/15/2026

    For Sale OM726925 - 2345 CR 453, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 64 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 3.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1476
       Built: 1963   Tax: $901 (2025)
    Community: Tracys Point 2Nd Add
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,362 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,287) + Taxes in 2025 ($75)


    Taxes:$901

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 1175 CR 463B, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $275,00010 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: TB8528453

    For Sale TB8528453 - 1175 CR 463B, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 40 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1312
       Built: 1934   Tax: $1,647 (2025)
    Community: Holiday Haven
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,644 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,507) + Taxes in 2025 ($137)


    Taxes:$1,647

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 2472 CR 447, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $269,90059 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5112792

    For Sale G5112792 - 2472 CR 447, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 53 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1243
       Built: 1995
    Monthly Fee: $3
       Tax: $1,786 (2025)
    Community: 6Th Add Tracys Point
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,631 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,479) + Fees ($3) + Taxes in 2025 ($149)


    Taxes:$1,786

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 1880 CR 422, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $149,00022 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: D6147923

    For Sale D6147923 - 1880 CR 422, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 52 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1488
       Built: 1960   Tax: $1,258 (2025)
    Community: Pana-Coo-Chee Retreats
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $921 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($816) + Taxes in 2025 ($105)


    Taxes:$1,258

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 4136 CR 400, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $365,00029 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6418508

    REDUCED by $10,000 (2.7%) on 07/14/2026

    For Sale O6418508 - 4136 CR 400, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 50 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1524
       Built: 1962   Tax: $1,973 (2025)
    Community: Idlewild Park
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,164 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,000) + Taxes in 2025 ($164)


    Taxes:$1,973

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 1240 CR 463, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $249,90025 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5114327

    0 Days Off yellowkey (back on 7/10/2026)

    For Sale G5114327 - 1240 CR 463, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 27 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1320
       Built: 1964
    Monthly Fee: $2
       Tax: $1,182 (2025)
    Community: Holiday Haven
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,470 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,369) + Fees ($2) + Taxes in 2025 ($99)


    Taxes:$1,182

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 2346 CR 401, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $220,000182 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: OM717040

    REDUCED by $10,000 (4.3%) on 07/10/2026

    For Sale OM717040 - 2346 CR 401, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 41 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1131
       Built: 1966   Tax: $961 (2025)
    Community: N/A
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,286 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,205) + Taxes in 2025 ($80)


    Taxes:$961

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 2548 CR 422, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $189,00083 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: TB8503203

    REDUCED by $1,000 (0.5%) on 07/08/2026

    For Sale TB8503203 - 2548 CR 422, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 38 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1938
       Built: 1981   Tax: $2,618 (2025)
    Community: Panacoochee Retreats
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,254 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,036) + Taxes in 2025 ($218)


    Taxes:$2,618

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 2399 CR 423 #Lot 43, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $199,000477 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5095021

    REDUCED by $12,000 (5.7%) on 07/05/2026

    For Sale G5095021 - 2399 CR 423 #Lot 43, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 21 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1068
       Built: 2025   Tax: $42 (2024)
    Community: Indian Estates
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,094 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,090) + Taxes in 2024 ($3)


    Taxes:$42

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: None


  • 951 CR 453, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $222,50057 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: W7886067

    REDUCED by $2,500 (1.1%) on 06/30/2026

    For Sale W7886067 - 951 CR 453, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 45 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 1.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 784
       Built: 1959
    Monthly Fee: $3
       Tax: $1,267 (2024)
    Community: Tracys Point
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,328 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,219) + Fees ($3) + Taxes in 2024 ($106)


    Taxes:$1,267

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 2693 CR 426F, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $70,000356 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5099790

    For Sale G5099790 - 2693 CR 426F, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 20 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 1.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 560
       Built: 1997   Tax: $392 (2024)
    Community: Panacoochee Retreat
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $416 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($384) + Taxes in 2024 ($33)


    Taxes:$392

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


  • 1195 CR 441, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $260,00046 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: TB8515840

    1 Days Off yellowkey (back on 6/27/2026)

    For Sale TB8515840 - 1195 CR 441, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 61 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1238
       Built: 2005
    Monthly Fee: $6
       Tax: $1,222 (2025)
    Community: Tracys Point 3Rd Add
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,532 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,425) + Fees ($6) + Taxes in 2025 ($102)


    Taxes:$1,222

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 4885 CR 307, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538

    $689,00048 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5113305

    For Sale G5113305 - 4885 CR 307, LAKE PANASOFFKEE, FL 33538 88 photos

    Bed: 4   Bath: 3.0   Gar: 4
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2538
       Built: 2006   Tax: $3,136 (2025)
    Community: Sunset Shores
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $4,037 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($3,775) + Taxes in 2025 ($261)


    Taxes:$3,136

    Elementary School: Lake Panasoffkee Elementary

    High School: South Sumter High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: South Sumter Middle


12


Why Bother Searching Elsewhere for Lake Panasoffkee Single Family Homes for Sale?

Lake Panasoffkee home, townhome, and condo, villa, and other listing sale data is continuously updated on yellowkeyrealty.com. yellowkeyrealty.com offers one of the most exhaustive, current, and relevant set of data you can find on single family homes for sale in Lake Panasoffkee. You can use our website to view Multiple Listing Service (MLS) data on Lake Panasoffkee single family homes. Feel free to reach out to a REALTOR ® at 1-954-369-1486 if you are unable to find specific information on any of our Lake Panasoffkee single family home listings.



Data is updated at least once a week by Sunday nights. Some properties that appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have been sold and may no longer be available. The data relating to real estate for sale/lease on this web site come in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the multiple listing service (MLS) in which this real estate firm (Broker) participates. Data can be retrieved from any one of the following MLS’s: Greater Fort Lauderdale REALTORS®, Space Coast Association of REALTORS®, My Florida Regional MLS, Florida Gulf Coast MLS, "©2024 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved." The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the MLS’s database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker’s logo or name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. The Florida Association of Realtors® and its cooperating MLSs do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing.