REFINE SEARCH
Status
Keywords
Price
 
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Garages
Liv Area Sq Ft
Min Year
Max Year
Property Types
No Image
Age Restricted
Foreclosure
Short Sale
Pets Allowed
Furnished
Pool
Spa
Reduced Price
Back on yellowkey
Possible Short Term Rental
Carports
Max Association Fee (monthly)
Max Monthly Payment
Search

Umatilla Single Family Homes For Sale - 83 homes

Umatilla Single Family Homes for Sale are located in Lake County, Florida. Find single family homes for sale in Umatilla with data from the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). Our REALTORS® can assist you in your real estate search for Umatilla single family houses.

Location: Umatilla

Sort:
  • 16750 KEENE RD, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $949,90033 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5109361

    For Sale G5109361 - 16750 KEENE RD, UMATILLA, FL 32784 45 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2042
       Built: 2018   Tax: $4,044 (2025)
    Community: N/A
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $5,542 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($5,205) + Taxes in 2025 ($337)


    Taxes:$4,044

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 14048 SE 200TH CT, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $32,70029 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5109743

    REDUCED by $1,300 (3.8%) on 04/07/2026

    For Sale G5109743 - 14048 SE 200TH CT, UMATILLA, FL 32784 2 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 1.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 560
       Built: 1967   Tax: $557 (2024)
    Community: Big Scrub Campsites
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $226 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($179) + Taxes in 2024 ($46)


    Taxes:$557

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: None


  • 590 CRESCENT ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $825,000257 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5100308

    1 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/7/2026)

    For Sale G5100308 - 590 CRESCENT ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784 62 photos

    Bed: 4   Bath: 3.5   Gar: 3
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 4291
       Built: 2005   Tax: $5,425 (2023)
    Community: N/A
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $4,973 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($4,520) + Taxes in 2023 ($452)


    Taxes:$5,425

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2023

    Middle School: None


  • 207 AMBERWOOD WAY, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $306,99075 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6378468

    INCREASED by $3,000 (1.0%) on 04/07/2026

    For Sale O6378468 - 207 AMBERWOOD WAY, UMATILLA, FL 32784 29 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1504
       Built: 2026
    Monthly Fee: $63
       Tax: $1,034 (2025)
    Community: Magnolia Pointe Phase 1
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,831 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,682) + Fees ($63) + Taxes in 2025 ($86)


    Taxes:$1,034

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 216 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $360,999314 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: S5128435

    REDUCED by $14,000 (3.7%) on 04/07/2026

    For Sale S5128435 - 216 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784 26 photos

    Bed: 4   Bath: 2.5   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2414
       Built: 2025
    Monthly Fee: $76

    Community: Seasons At Magnolia Pointe
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,054 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,978) + Fees ($76) + Taxes in 2025 ($0)


    Taxes:$0

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 211 CASSADY ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $399,9009 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5110642

    For Sale G5110642 - 211 CASSADY ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784 95 photos

    Bed: 6   Bath: 3.5
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 3165
       Built: 1920   Tax: $7,313 (2025)
    Community: Umatilla Oak Park
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,801 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,191) + Taxes in 2025 ($609)


    Taxes:$7,313

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 87 LONE STAR ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $219,500189 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6350668

    For Sale O6350668 - 87 LONE STAR ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784 59 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1292
       Built: 1957   Tax: $658 (2024)
    Community: N/A
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,258 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,203) + Taxes in 2024 ($55)


    Taxes:$658

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2024

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $294,99975 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6378059

    For Sale O6378059 - UMATILLA, FL 32784 56 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1329
       Built: 2018
    Monthly Fee: $200
       Tax: $332 (2025)
    Community: Umatilla Cottages At Waters Edge
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,844 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,616) + Fees ($200) + Taxes in 2025 ($28)


    Taxes:$332

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 40700 LONG ISLAND DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $390,00090 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5106149

    5 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/6/2026)

    For Sale G5106149 - 40700 LONG ISLAND DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784 45 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1587
       Built: 1984   Tax: $2,279 (2025)
    Community: Lakenridge
    Spa: Yes

    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,327 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,137) + Taxes in 2025 ($190)


    Taxes:$2,279

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 110 TURTLE RUN, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $245,000124 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: S5140178

    3 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/6/2026)

    For Sale S5140178 - 110 TURTLE RUN, UMATILLA, FL 32784 15 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1184
       Built: 2018
    Monthly Fee: $100
       Tax: $332 (2025)
    Community: Umatilla Cottages At Waters Edge
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,470 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,342) + Fees ($100) + Taxes in 2025 ($28)


    Taxes:$332

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 19703 TWIN PONDS RD, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $1,275,00010 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5110585

    For Sale G5110585 - 19703 TWIN PONDS RD, UMATILLA, FL 32784 62 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.5   Gar: 6
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2935
       Built: 1999   Tax: $4,625 (2025)
    Community: Acreage & Unrec
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $7,372 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($6,986) + Taxes in 2025 ($385)


    Taxes:$4,625

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 57 S TROWELL AVE, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $300,00027 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: V4947993

    REDUCED by $10,000 (3.2%) on 04/01/2026

    For Sale V4947993 - 57 S TROWELL AVE, UMATILLA, FL 32784 23 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 1.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1418
       Built: 1914   Tax: $4,064 (2025)
    Community: N J Trowells Add/Umatilla
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,982 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,644) + Taxes in 2025 ($339)


    Taxes:$4,064

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 311 S CENTRAL AVE, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $365,00012 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6395427

    For Sale O6395427 - 311 S CENTRAL AVE, UMATILLA, FL 32784 63 photos

    Bed: 4   Bath: 3.0   Gar: 1
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2360
       Built: 1910   Tax: $5,055 (2025)
    Community: Umatilla Mitchenors Add
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,421 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,000) + Taxes in 2025 ($421)


    Taxes:$5,055

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • TBD LOT 01000 SILVER DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $945,00022 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5109980

    For Sale G5109980 - TBD LOT 01000 SILVER DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784 63 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 3.5   Gar: 3
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2956
       Built: 2027   Tax: $1,152 (2025)
    Community: Silver Beach Heights
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $5,274 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($5,178) + Taxes in 2025 ($96)


    Taxes:$1,152

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 183 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $451,999350 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: S5125965

    For Sale S5125965 - 183 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784 28 photos

    Bed: 5   Bath: 3.5   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 3030
       Built: 2025
    Monthly Fee: $76

    Community: Seasons At Magnolia Pointe
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,553 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,477) + Fees ($76) + Taxes in 2025 ($0)


    Taxes:$0

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 179 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $465,999282 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: S5130401

    For Sale S5130401 - 179 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784 29 photos

    Bed: 5   Bath: 3.5   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 3030
       Built: 2025
    Monthly Fee: $76

    Community: Seasons At Magnolia Pointe
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,629 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($2,553) + Fees ($76) + Taxes in 2025 ($0)


    Taxes:$0

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None


  • 192 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $361,950569 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: S5112829

    1 Days Off yellowkey (back on 4/3/2026)

    For Sale S5112829 - 192 FLAG LILLY LN, UMATILLA, FL 32784 23 photos

    Bed: 4   Bath: 3.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2070
       Built: 2025
    Monthly Fee: $76

    Community: Seasons At Magnolia Pointe
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,059 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,983) + Fees ($76) + Taxes in 2023 ($0)


    Taxes:$0

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2023

    Middle School: None


  • 212 CASSADY ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $299,90055 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5108196

    For Sale G5108196 - 212 CASSADY ST, UMATILLA, FL 32784 31 photos

    Bed: 5   Bath: 4.0
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 2948
       Built: 1920   Tax: $6,569 (2025)
    Community: Not Applicable
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $2,191 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,643) + Taxes in 2025 ($547)


    Taxes:$6,569

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 1080 BEAR HAMMOCK DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $312,99014 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: O6395503

    For Sale O6395503 - 1080 BEAR HAMMOCK DR, UMATILLA, FL 32784 35 photos

    Bed: 3   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1328
       Built: 2026
    Monthly Fee: $63
       Tax: $1,034 (2026)
    Community: Magnolia Pointe
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,864 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,715) + Fees ($63) + Taxes in 2026 ($86)


    Taxes:$1,034

    Elementary School: Umatilla Elem

    High School: Umatilla High

    Tax Year: 2026

    Middle School: Umatilla Middle


  • 106 FAIRWAY CIR, UMATILLA, FL 32784

    $300,00062 Days on yellowkey   MLS ID: G5108101

    For Sale G5108101 - 106 FAIRWAY CIR, UMATILLA, FL 32784 62 photos

    Bed: 2   Bath: 2.0   Gar: 2
    Liv Area Sq Ft: 1805
       Built: 2006
    Monthly Fee: $50
       Tax: $2,094 (2025)
    Community: Twin Lakes Estates Phase Iii
    Single Family


    Estimated Monthly Payment: $1,868 (change assumption)
    Mortgage ($1,644) + Fees ($50) + Taxes in 2025 ($175)


    Taxes:$2,094

    Elementary School: None

    High School: None

    Tax Year: 2025

    Middle School: None




Why Bother Searching Elsewhere for Umatilla Single Family Homes for Sale?

Umatilla home, townhome, and condo, villa, and other listing sale data is continuously updated on yellowkeyrealty.com. yellowkeyrealty.com offers one of the most exhaustive, current, and relevant set of data you can find on single family homes for sale in Umatilla. You can use our website to view Multiple Listing Service (MLS) data on Umatilla single family homes. Feel free to reach out to a REALTOR ® at 1-954-369-1486 if you are unable to find specific information on any of our Umatilla single family home listings.



Data is updated at least once a week by Sunday nights. Some properties that appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have been sold and may no longer be available. The data relating to real estate for sale/lease on this web site come in part from a cooperative data exchange program of the multiple listing service (MLS) in which this real estate firm (Broker) participates. Data can be retrieved from any one of the following MLS’s: Greater Fort Lauderdale REALTORS®, Space Coast Association of REALTORS®, My Florida Regional MLS, Florida Gulf Coast MLS, "©2024 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved." The properties displayed may not be all of the properties in the MLS’s database, or all of the properties listed with Brokers participating in the cooperative data exchange program. Properties listed by Brokers other than this Broker are marked with either the listing Broker’s logo or name or the MLS name or a logo provided by the MLS. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. The Florida Association of Realtors® and its cooperating MLSs do not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing.